Supreme Court of New York April 2019 casesW. 58th St. Coal., Inc. v. City of New YorkPeople v. JustinianoVaccaro v. 123 Wash., LLCPeople v. SanchezSeeking Valhalla Tr. v. DeaneCohen v. TomilinsonParham v. N.Y. Hous. Auth.Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corp. v. MeloSilva v. Kings Cnty. Pub. Adm'rBd. of Managers of Lux Condo. v. Core Mgmt. NY, LLCGuity v. Cnty. of WestchesterHudson Meridian Constr. Grp., LLC v. 118 E. 59th St. Realty LLCLaw Office of Wallace Neel, P.C. v. PaulLodziato v. City of New YorkMcDonald v. Seneca Cnty. Bd. of ElectionsPizzarotti, LLC v. X-Treme Concrete Inc.J&B Trading Co. v. Leading Ins. Grp. Ins. Co.Padawer v. OgdenKelly v. BaldwinChristakis v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.3P-733, LLC v. DavisLopez v. FrydO'Meara v. EAN Holdings, LLCYanni v. YanniCalvelos v. Brann Valencia v. OmarWood v. LiebleinR.M. v. A.M.Gilbert v. HarrisRamos v. 110 Bennett Ave., LLCDonohue v. Netherwood Acres, LLCPatricof v. PatricofSkrobola v. All Pro Paving Co.Vnuk v. City of AlbanySiwiec v. United Rest. Grp. Inc.Selendy v. Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan, LLPGoodheart v. Amchem Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Bd. of Managers of Union Square Condo. v. Core Mgmt. NY, LLCCarroll v. Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.Revercomb v. Aire Ancient Baths S.L.McKenna-Aguirre v. City of New YorkMoyal v. Tripost Capital Partners, LLCSheffield v. PucciSinchi v. HWA 1290 III LLCVisaggio v. ArenaFerreira v. City of New YorkGonzalez v. JakaitisCosta v. HassanR.M. v. E.M.Coastal Land Servs., Inc. v. VillavicencioMeza v. CascioZurich Am. Ins. Co. v. Liberty Mut. Fire Ins. Co.Chalco v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Nadler v. SamadiThomas v. KlagerHutzel v. Turner Constr.Ramirez v. 255 W. 108th St. Corp.Conklin v. Am. Biltrite, Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Jonas v. Bayer Corp.Boyce v. T Squared Invs., LLCRoza 14W LLC v. Fordham Fin. Mgmt., Inc.57th St. Vacation Owners Ass'n, Inc. v. SSNN-2210 Midwest Rd. LLCEdelman v. GreunerSW Prods., Inc. v. CBGB Festival, LLCCodner v. Kennedy Enters., Inc.Angiolillo v. Christie's, Inc.Voron v. Bd. of Managers of the Newswalk Condo.Perez v. City of New YorkMendez v. Bank of Am.CLC v. Westchester Med. Ctr.Rivers v. Mt. Sinai Med. Ctr.Vezozzo Filho v. BorgesAnaya v. WeWork Cos.Estrella v. N.Y. Presbyterian Hosp.Heinze v. N.Y. Presbyterian Hosp.Kim Young v. Avon Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Chun Chan v. Mehran Holdings Ltd.O'Keefe v. WohlMartin v. SahgalSrica v. Am. Builtrite Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Dewalt v. PlascenciaAnonymous v. AnonymousRodriguez v. Westchester Med. Ctr.Blalock v. SagniDippolito v. CicchielloBd. of Managers of the Apthorp Condo. v. Apthorp Garage LLCState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. BandeleLegal Aid Soc'y v. N.Y. Cnty. Dist. Attorney's OfficeHolley v. HernandezMulvaney v. Cnty. of WestchestrrCarrero v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Morgan Stanley Mortg. Loan Trust 2007-2ax v. Morgan Stanley Mortg. Capital Holdings LLCGiglio v. MMR Care Corp.Wells Fargo Bank v. SandovalPickrodt v. TaylorLuk v. BriedjCertain Underwriters At Lloyd's, London v. AT&T, Corp.Fid. & Guar. Ins. Co. v. Apple Builders & Renovators, Inc.Ameriprise Ins. Co. v. Metro Radiology, P.C.G & G Seafood, Inc. v. MS Fish Corp.Boine v. ArevaloDeutsche Bank Nat'l Tr. Co. v. Unknown Heirs to SoutoPeople v. AletebRobbins v. Floranamel LLCKBS Sheapshead Bay, LLC v. Terrapin Design Grp. LLCPeople v. MoralesGiordano v. CastoldiBarrison v. D'Amato & Lynch, LLPCity of N.Y. v. Big Apple Mgmt., LLCBenitez v. ArmstrongWimbledon Fund, SPC (Class TT) v. Weston Capital Partners Master Fund II, Ltd.Angiolillo v. Christie's, Inc.Bd. of Managers of Hudson View W. Condo. v. VakninWestchester Fire Ins. Co. v. SchorschMcIntosh v. MazurAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. RamirezTreadway v. Workmarket. Inc.Emigrant Bank v. AlibayofNYCTL 2017-A Tr. v. JBJ Holding LLCBenny v. Concord Partners 46th St. LLCAmeriprise Ins. Co. v. KrutishinkiyPerez v. BaezReis v. LTGO, Inc.Jackson v. BrezenoffGodette v. Mortg. Elec. Registration Sys.957 Park Ave., LLC v. 955 Tenant Stockholders, Inc.Mendez v. City of New YorkHornbuckle v. HannibalClark v. Castor & Pollux Ltd. Liab. Co.Gelmann v. Trs. of Columbia Univ. in N.Y.Wright v. Kok-Min KyanOne Bryant Park LLC v. AXA Ins. Co.Nationstar Mortg. LLC v. ColeMadeof, LLC v. BronsonAyrapetyants v. BarayevSchieldrop v. Lucida, Inc.W.D. v. Cnty. of RocklandBostic v. City of N.Y.People v. D.G.Mulvaney v. Cnty. of WestchesterMoran v. Wujun Huai30 W.S.L.L.C. v. AndrewsClancy v. TiedemannGuaman v. 178 Court St.Mulvaney v. Cnty. of WestchesterQuadriad Realty Partners, LLC v. Wilbee Corp.Horoshko v. BezmenovaIfill v. NYS Dep't of Corr.Battaglia Family Ltd. P'ship v. MazzaMikeshina v. Tishman Constr. Corp.Taylor v A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Sotheby's, Inc. v. ChowaikiArasim v. 38 Co.Kassab v. KasabJP Morgan Chase Bank v. JonesQuadriad Realty Partners, LLC v. Wilbee Corp.Kissel v. Royal Charter Props., Inc.D&A Woodlands Enter., Inc. v. SinatraBorrie v. Cnty. of SuffolkTaylor v. HamburgerShannon v. HollandRolf v. Tribeca Dev. Partners LLCEpstein v. FeldmanMalone v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalCepeda v. PayanoU.S. Bank v. SouryYoung v. Dep't of Educ.Magno v. MolinaN.Y. Geomatics, Inc. v. JTJ ContractingSacchetti v. Cardella Trucking Co.Flintlock Constr. Servs., LLC v. Glob. Precast, Inc.J.P.'s Catering, Inc. v. MIPR Hudson Valley Corp.Pala Assets Holdings Ltd. v. Rolta, LLCTejada v. One City Block LLCJackson v. 3M Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)45-34 Pearson St. LIC, LLC v. OhanaSuverant LLC v. Brainchild, Inc.Higgins v. Legacy Yards Tenant, LLCBrawer v. LeporNYCTL 1998-2 Tr. v. D & A Equities LLCLivingston v. Sahara Dreams LLC938 Nicholas Ave. Lender. LLC v. 936-938 Cliffcrest Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.NYCTL 2017-A Tr. v. ShariffBuckstine v. SchorMulvaney v. Cnty. of WestchesterPeople v. AllenCircular Energ, LLC v. Town of RomulusPrestigiacomo v. Amchem Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Clark Tower, LLC v. Wells Fargo BankU.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. Creative Encounters, LLCDiaz v. KZ Eng'g P.C.Pereda v. Time Warner Inc.Pers.-Touch Home Care, Inc. v. N.Y. Human Res. Admin.Davis v. Scottish Re Grp. Ltd.Estate of Savage v. KredentserMamoon v. Dot Net Inc.Mendoza v. Prestige Bay Plaza Dev. Corp.Consol. Edison Co. of N.Y. v. Armienti, Debellis & Whiten, LLPEndurance Am. Ins. Co. v. BurbridgeFleishman v. E. Union Funding LLCLazaro v. BOP MW Residental Mkt., LLCBroadway SKY, LLC v. 53rd St. Holdings, LLCKobax Corp. v. Townhouse Renovations Inc.938 Nicholas Ave. Lender, LLC v. 936-938 Cliffcrest Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.Griffin v. Gregorys Coffee Mgmt. LLCDesign Dev. NYC, Inc. v. GoldsteinN.Y. State Ass'n of Indep. Sch. v. EliaUmeh v. ChecolePeople v. PeopleDiaz v. Riverview Operating Co.Stock v. Air & Liquid Sys. Corp. (In re Asbestos Litig.)Sasso v. Sun Enters.Bank of N.Y. Mellon v. VasquezWhitaker v. LongobardiBazan v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Fifth Ave. Ctr. v. Dryland Props., LLCN.Y. State Workers' Comp. Bd. v. Episcopal Church Home & Affiliates, Inc.Larsen v. O'NeillI.H. v. HernandezBaskin v. Mabco Transit, Inc.Abulayua v. City of N.Y.Gaston v. Trs. of Columbia Univ.Country-Wide Ins. Co. v. Onasis Pimentel, All Cnty., LLCBison Capital Corp. v. Hunton & Williams, LLPAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. UrenaTidewater Plantations, Inc. v. Deutsche Bank AGPeterson v. Occidental Chem. Corp.Jarmuth v. LeonardNew Century Mortg. Corp. v. BosmanOstrolenk Faber LLP v. Sakar Int'l, Inc.Hawkins v. City of N.Y.Thompson v. KingsleySoumbaskis v. FitzgeraldWilliams v. Madvapes Holdings, LLCBurlington Ins. Co. v. Castillo Iron Works, Inc.BOFI Fed. Bank v. DavisCasola v. N. Westchester Hosp. Ass'nTorres v. Roberts (In re Civil Practice Law & rules)Carroll v. BruciaRidge Park LLC v. DHC Contracting Inc.First Cent. Sav. Bank v. WeingartenLong Island Real Props., Ltd. v. U.S. BankClarke v. BeninatiAlimari v. T-C 2300 Broadway LLCDavidoff Hutcher & Citron LLP v. ParadaRosenzwaig v. Sound Shore Med. Ctr.Rad & D'Aprile, Inc. v. Arnell Constr. Corp.JPMorgan Chase Bank v. Ex'r of Estate of LernerZheng Wu v. Guo WenguiNationwide Affinity Ins. Co. of Am. v. PFJ Med. Care, P.C.Smalls v. New 56th & Park (NY) Owner, LLCPizarro v. WheelockFrey ex rel. Frey v. ItzkowitzPeople v. H.M.People v. J.W.Fisher v. Legal Aid Soc'yNatale v. Inc. Vill. of LynbrookSingh v. The City of New YorkSpectrum News NY1 v N.Y.C. Police Dept.Richman v. ReeseAmankwah v. Dep't of Educ. Cebularz v. SamadiBavaro v. Ne. Orthopedics & Sports Med., PLLCMaldonado v. City of N.Y.Pizzarotti IBC, LLC v. A.L. One Constr., Inc.Redhead Builders LLC v. Aran World Inc.Battaglia v. 6340 NB LLC.Padgett v. FigueroaPellegrino v. VogelsangS.F.S. v. A.L.S.Martinez v. Orange Reg'l Med. Ctr.Banks v. Richard A.325 E. 14th St. Corp. v. Marie Fr. Realty Corp.Jaramillo v. S.A.C. & S.A.C., LLCNYCTL 1998-2 Tr. v. Jacob & Jerry Invs. LLCForan v. Computershare, Inc.McMahon v. Cobblestone Lofts Condo.Clementi v. Suffolk Cnty. Water Auth.Weil v. StenzlerSpurs Capital Mgmt., LLC v. GhilardiHanasab v. 1880 Bos. Rd. Apartments LLCSingh v. NYCHATaylor v. HamburgerMaack v. Wyckoff Heights Med. Ctr.Evanston Ins. Co. v. P.S. Bruckel, Inc.Betters v. BettersSpicijaric v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Rojas v. Cauldwell-Wingate Co.Mixon v. City of New YorkLucente v. USTA Nat'l Tennis Ctr. Inc.Accolade Condo. Homeowners Ass'n v. SI Pearl Partners LLCGonzalez v. KrumholzMorrone v. BiberajJavorowsky v. AhmedZucker Real Estate Corp. v. WilsonImber v. Carl Fischer Photography, Inc.Swezy v. Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner & Smith Inc.Gayoso v. Am. Honda Motor Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Funding Strategy Partners, LLC v. AG Equip. Direct, LLCWolff v. ISC Park Ave. Corp.Zhicay v. 116 Wilbur Place, LLCGenting N.Y., LLC v. N.Y.C. Envtl. Control Bd.Paul Ryan Ass'n v. HaydenU.S. Bank v. AbuBrown v. Prospect Heights Shares LLCOrea v. NH Hotels U.S., Inc.Hilbertz, v. City of N.Y.Coleman v. Servs. for Underserved, Inc.Mayorga v. 75 Plaza LLCDeJesus v. SLG 100 Park LLCIonescu v. Harvard Maint., Inc.Desai v. Cure Auto Ins.Cartagena v. EganCox v. 2282 Second Ave. LLCFennhahn v. Brenntag N. Am., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Goyer v. RobertsMolina Healthcare, Inc. v. Wellcare Health Plans, Inc.Hyson v. LamannaMulvaney v. Cnty. of WestchesterStrong-Bastien v. City of YonkersHalpern v. Rosalind & Joseph Gurwin Jewish Geriatric Ctr. of Long IslandWiener v. BraunsteinSpillane v. TuncaJPmorgan Chase Bank v. BrockwellZacky v. Savile Opportunity Fund, L.P.Carbajal v. RodriguezSlebakis v. Roys PoyiadjisTapestry, Inc. v. Gibb Boglin v. N.Y. Hous. Auth.Betancur v. VeselyWatson v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.GEM Invs. Am. LLC v. MarquezB.Z. Chiropractic, P.C. v. Allstate Ins. Co.Dunn v. New Lounge 4324, LLCL.K. McLean Assocs. v. Baldassano Architecture, LLPMichels Corp. v. Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.Khan v. City of N.Y.Wenzel v. All City Remodeling, Inc.Berman v. JankelowitzAvelar v. McMahonDoe v. Cnty. of PutnamBd. of Managers of Legacy Condo. v. Core Mgmt. NY, LLCDebono Bros. Builders & Developers, Inc. v. AnmuthVivona v. ParkMessinger v. MessingerSantander Consumer U.S., Inc. v. Kobi Auto Collision & Paint Ctr., Inc.Sao Fernando Int'l, Ltd. v. DebbaneJ.D. Masters Plumbing & Heating, Inc. v. Thirty Six E. L.L.C.Tyczynski v. 973 Fifth, LLCDavis v. Graham Court Owners Corp.40 Broad St. Portfolio, LLC v. LM Realty 24C, LLCM & E Christopher LLC v. Ananadam Inc.Escobar v. Tutor Perini Corp.Anderson v. AHA (At Home Sols. LLC)Fernandez v. SotoPH-105 Realty Corp v. ElayaanPaulsingh v. Leon's Ambulette Inc.Kelly v. Hiro Real Estate L.L.C.Fernandez v. SotoMartinez v. Vila Window Repair, Inc.U.S. Bank v. Seon Yeong KangHalpin v. Chubb Indem. Ins. Co.Gontarek v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Singh v. PliskinLama v. 3681 Broadway HDFCDonaldson v. Bunch & Sons Constr. LLCAllstate Ins. Co. v. McCormackRosario v. Audubon Realty LLCColazzo v. PonteUAP N. Am. Ltd. v. Soho Props. Inc.Starr Indem. & Liab. Co. v. Monte Carlo, LLCEl-Taieb v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. Renewal Nabet v. SteinPunter v. N.Y.C. Health & Hosps. Corp.Ashton v. Norfolk S. Ry. Co.M.L. v. PanzaBarberena v. City of New York (In re Carnegie Hill Neighbors, Inc.)Avetisian v. City of New YorkSheehan v. Cnty. of SuffolkPeople v. CrucianiCarbures Europe, S.A. v. Emerging Markets Intrinsic Cayman Ltd.People v. GoetheGrant v. N.Y.C. Health & Hosps. Corp.Blue Outdoor Media LLC v. Silverpoint Media Grp. LLCBlumenthal v. Metro. Transp. Auth.Capstone Bus. Funding, LLC. v. Sanitas Partners V.I., LLCAlderman v. Dep't of Educ. Meagher v. Birchwood At Spring Lake Homeowners Ass'n, Inc.Belle Lighting LLC v. U.S. Legwear, Inc.Zurich Am. Ins. Co. v. Blackman Plumbing Supply Co.Deschaine v. Tricon Constr., LLCSalerno v. IlardiGil v. Margis Realty LLCEmmons v. Broome Cnty.Musleh v. Roger Carter, Inc.Mountain Valley Indem. Co. v. ThelismonGerard Owners Corp. v. RoshodeshRasolli Footwear Corp. v. COD Capital Corp.Weisenfeld v. IskanderN. Am. Airlines, Inc. v. Wilmington Tr. Co.Estate of Martinez v. 977 Grant Towers LLCMarfo v. CastilloCIT Bank v. O'HaraMarrero v. ThomasPik Sim G. Liu v. Kim Sum Kenneth PungKarpf v. MarkFutterman v. KriegerSeen v. 84 Lumber Co.Contratti v. Mut. Redevelopment Houses, Inc.Redden v. City of N.Y.Mercatante v. Amchem Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Pon v. GDA Realty Corp.Gronich & Co. v. Simon Prop. Grp., Inc.Am. Transit Ins. Co. v. OrtizBarcia v. Costco Wholesale Corp.Karma Props. LLC v. Lilok, Inc.Dejesus v. City of New YorkNYCTL 2016-A Tr. v. GamsyAguilar v. RebackCabrera v. Provident Alpine Partners, LPDaniels v. JeromeNatoli v. City of New YorkWatson Farley & Williams LLP v. Bay Bridge Tex., LLCAshley v. Red Lobster Hosp. LLCWellington v. Christa Constr. LLCAuburn Realty, LLC v. SurujdyalDraper v. PasqualeRobles v. WiserHudson Yards LLC v. SegalC.F. v. N.Y.C. Dep't of Health & Mental HygieneAli v. NorrisHabberstad v. Revere Sec. LLCTrinchese Constr., Inc. v. EscarzaMohamed v. City of BuffaloJones v. GottliebHilbertz v. City of N.Y.Thomas v. O'NeillMartinez v. PenaOverbaugh v. BenoitNarvaes-Reyes v. PalominioLindsey v. Remica Prop. Grp. Corp.Jankowski v. RP Excavating & Landscaping, Inc.Donnelly v. Grove Beach Hotel Owners, Inc.Boutin v. SkatesIn re Thanks to Scandinavia, Inc.Ulloa v. N.Y. & Presbyterian Hosp.Gamaleldin v. GiuffreS&R Dev. Estates, LLC v. Town of GreenburghState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co. v. M.V.B. Collision Inc.Cesar v. Jean-CharlesPraetorian Ins. Co. v. Long Island Power Auth.Witchey v. FinneganComen v. Town of CarmelYaofei Chen v. Minxing WangTrilok Enter. LLC. v. Your Mktg. Corp.Vivona v. Bridgeview Assoc., LLCDeutsche Bank Nat'l Tr. Co. v. DeSilvaWalsh v. N.Y. Univ.Jarmuth v. NunnerleyN.Y. Marine Gen. Ins. Co. v. Arch Specialty Ins. Co.Lynch v. StevelmanWilmington Tr., N.A. v. Wei P. Teo Sperling v. AmoachiBrinson v. JamesPac. Alliance USA, Inc. v. 1450 Broadway, LLCRobert Toma & Noid Events, Inc. v. KaraviasSmith v. DMC Prof'l Contractors Inc.Labiner v. Jerome Florist, Inc.People v. PaulaveniMorse v. CipolloneMorris v. Tully Constr. Co.Bovee v. Champlain Valley Physicians Hosp. Med. Ctr.VFS Leon, LLC v. PritchettMagnet Grp. LLC v. Toymail, Inc.Krzyzanowski v. City of New York570 Smith St. Realty Corp. v. Seneca Ins. Co.Hunzinger v. CostelloStukes v. PuthumanaHoneydew Investing Ltd. v. AbadiJolly v. City of New YorkVinciguerra v. Turner Constr. Co.Parrino v. PeopleVenture v. Preferred Mut. Ins. Co.Roosevelt Lee L.P. v. 32 Hair Studio, Inc.Wells Fargo Bank v. GlasgowHey Jude Prods., Inc. v. SimonShaheen v. YYY Third Ave. LLCReese v. RichmanChondrite Asset Tr. v. 9 Jewels, LLCNoonan v. Vill. of Garden CityR.C. v. City of New YorkSunside Realty LLC v. Croydon Manor Apt. Corp.People v. BoydHiegel v. Orange Reg'l Med. Ctr.Brown v. 2007 Jeep, VIN No. 1J4GL58K87W615079Crockett v. 351 St. Nicholas Ave. LLCPerforming Right Soc'y Ltd. v. eMusic.com Inc.Cohen v. CohenBroccoli v. Absolute Plus Corp.McCloskey v. City of N.Y. Civil Serv. Comm'nCM Realty Holdings Corp. v. DAC Holdings LLCParker Madison Partners v. Airbnb, Inc.Epps v. ArabeloCortlandt St. Recovery v. BondermanHarold v. N.Y.C. & Hosps. Corp.Watkins v. CNY Constr. 701 LLC.Starr Indem. & Liab. Co. v. Petroleum Tank Cleaners Ltd.Concepcion v. City of N.Y.Hogue v. Vill. of Dering HarborU.S. Bank v. Cannella
