Supreme Court of New York April 2012 casesPurcell v. Metlife Inc.Gonzalez v. New York City TransitKim v. Wasserstein Enters., LLCGarcia v. Mt. Airy Estates, Inc.People v. BurroughsWang v. Tiaa–Cref Life Ins. Co.Kemper Independence Ins. Co. v. WertRep 35 Engel, LLC v. Holber Assocs., L.P.Martin v. SchriroDavis v. Breadstreet Holdings Corp.Bitter v. RenzoBattiste v. MathisBarquin v. Toost Control & Orsid Realty Corp.Goel v. RamachandranStrough Real Estate Assocs., Inc. v. BowenLower Manhattan Dialysis Ctr., Inc. v. LantzCatanzaro v. City of New YorkMetro-North Commuter R.R. Co. v. Empire City Subway Co.Bullrock Concrete Corp. v. Mario's Constr. Inc.Kitchen & Bath Design Gallery v. LombardDion v. Metro. Transp. Auth.Mendieta v. City of New YorkAkter v. Denis P. Mullarkey, LLCPosa v. David Zwirner, Inc.People v. CanalesCountry Glen, LLC v. Botticelli Builders, LLCAttaway v. Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corp.Duffy v. Cnty. of NassauBernard v. Cabrini Med. Ctr.Jacobs v. Port Auth. of New York & New JerseyFrezzell v. KellyJian Ming Liang v. Port Auth. of New York & New JerseyMASS OP, LLC v. U.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'nBd. of Directors of the Maidstone Landing Homeowners Ass'n, Inc. v. Maidstone Landing, LLCClark v. Allen & Overy LLPClancy v. Silverstein Props., Inc.Gregg v. WeissWells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. ChateauTown of Stony Point v. State of New York Dep't of Fin.Beltran v. Navillus Tile, Inc.Manzanares v. ATM Four LLCMcCabe v. Inc. Village of Flower HillRabos v. R&R Bagels & Bakery Inc.61 Broadway Owner, LLC v. Strategic Captial Solutions, LLCHernandez v. MarquezAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. MedinaLighthouse 925 Hempstead, LLC v. Sprint Spectrum L.P.Med. Liab. Mut. Ins. v. United Airconditioning Corp.Stathakos v. Metro. Transit Auth. Long Island R.R.Freeport Police Benevolent Ass'n v. Inc. Village of FreeportUS Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. McPhersonMSCI Inc. v. JacobMurray v. Bd. of Educ. of Connetquot Cent. School Dist.Schwartz v. MulhallRevelations Perfume & Cosmetics, Inc. v. NelsonState Farm Mutual Auto. Ins. Co. v. ClemonsMSCI Inc. v. Philip Jacob, Axioma, Inc.Khatari v. ShamiMaluf v. VanceFreudenberg v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co.20-35 86th St. Realty LLC v. Tower Ins. Co. of N.Y.Haas v. New York City Bd./Dep't of Educ.Great American Restoration Servs. Inc. v. SippinBedson v. Clarett Grp., LLCDoxey v. Freeport Union Free Sch. Dist.Hughes v. PacienzaHughes v. Pacienza Abramowitz v. Lefkowicz & Gottfried, LLPSieger v. Louis Zak & Powersystems Int'l, Inc.Bay Assocs. of Lawrence, Ltd. v. John P. Picone, Inc.Bardes v. PintadoBlaustein v. Gristedb's Foods, Inc.Yafie v. Eastern Sav. Bank FSBSammut v. Southside Hosp.Kim v. Wasserstein Enters., LLCWest-Lee v. Dormitory Auth. of StateSchwartz v. MulhallSmith v. GEICO Ins. Co.Absolute Trucking, Inc. v. City of New York Bus. Integrity Comm'nAmerican Express Bank, FSB v. Yin Kat YongEckert v. Chabad of RoslynGiumenta Corp. v. Desktop Solutions Software, Inc.Samson v. 91st St. Tenants Corp.Bd. of Managers of 184 Thompson St. Condominium v. 184 Thompson St. Owner LLCLieutenants Benevolent Ass'n of the City of New York, Inc. v. City of New YorkBrinkley v. Nassau Health Care Corp.McGuffie v. Costco, Costco Wholesale Corp.Cnty. of Suffolk v. Love'm Sheltering, Inc.Contino v. 340 Madison Owner LLCGordon v. Bd. of Managers of the 18 East 12th St. Condo.Gilchrist v. City of New YorkPaz v. GuevaraRoss v. 1510 Assocs. LLCTower Ins. Co. of New York v. Metro Prop. Grp., LLCHernandez v. CBF TruckingPeople v. ZapullaPeople v. QuayeCnty. of Suffolk v. Long Island Power Auth.Garcia v. Mt. Airy Estates, Inc.Teisseiere v. W7879 LLCJeffco Plumbing, Inc. v. AnnittoG.C. v. G.C.Katz v. New York City Civil Serv. Comm'nChiaperotti v. City of New YorkSmith v. AndreoMcCullough v. L.P. Stair & Rail, Inc.Capone v. KotchOrosz v. OroszHerrera v. Metro. Suburban Bus Auth.Slaine v. Magnum Masonry, Inc.Kenny v. Turner Constr. Co.BGC Partners, Inc. v. Refco Sec., LLCGarretson v. Town of IslipPeople v. RamosPeople v. TavarezBlake v. RheaButler v. MathissonAlbunio v. City of N.Y.Tower Ins. Co. of New York v. Ritmo's "60's" Inc.TIA of New York Inc. v. Stanley Realty, LLCGlobal Bus. Inst. v. Rivkin Radler, LLPBroadway Collision & Towing, Inc. v. MintzGouskos v. CohenStewart Info. Servs. Corp. v. Corporatair LLCKryman v. JalasStrunk v. New York State Bd. of ElectionsNationwide Gen. Ins. Co. v. BatesMinsky v. City of New YorkPartamian v. SuconickMemmos v. AnaniadisJeffco Plumbing, Inc. v. AnnittoPeyton v. PWV Acquisition LLCPeople v. SharpMuller v. South Shore Med. Care, PCSt. Stephen Cmty. A.M.E. Church v. 2131 8th Ave. LLCPeople v. HamlettDeblinger v. Sani-Pine Prods. Co.O'Brien v. Inc. Vill. of Valley Stream of N.Y.Dignam v. 305 Riverside Corp.Gallery v. LombardAndes Cent. Sch. Dist. v. KingIbragimov v. SessaHerrera v. LeverWells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. WagnerStewart Info. Servs. Corp. v. Corporatair LLCNukho v. O'ConnorTunne v. Duane Reade, Inc.Donovan v. HaubenEver Win, Inc. v. 1–10 Indus. Assocs., LLCCab East LLC v. ClarkYanping Xu v. Gold Coast Freightways, Inc.Rodriguez v. Oak RoomStout St. Fund 1, LP v. State Farm Fire & Cas. Co.Johnson v. Keyspan Corp.TD Bank, N.A. v. S. Shore Motor Grp., Inc.Total Fitness & Karate Ctr., Inc. v. Zurich North America333 Fifth Ave. Assocs., LLC v. Utica First Ins. Co.Jenkins v. AstorinoStanislaw v. StanislawNomet Mgmt. Corp. v. Va. Sur. Co.Gov't Emps. Ins. Co. v. SchussheimShaw Funding, L.P. v. BorisYellowbook Sales & Distribution Co. v. DiGiovanniSecond 82nd SM LLC v. New York State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalAlbany Eng'g Corp. v. Hudson River-Black River Regulating Dist.Chevy Chase Bank, FSB v. ZaneskiaPantelis v. SkanskaHermitage Ins. Co. v. ZaidmanClarke v. Davmar Holdings, Inc.Gioia v. City of New YorkRuotolo v. Mussman & NortheyPeople v. RamseySagres 2001 LP v. Sagres Partners LLCPeople v. BurroughsBrusco v. KoffWilliams v. Police Dep't of N.Y. Sch. Safety Div.Mercado v. Caithness Long Island, LLCTAP Holdings, LLC v. Orix Fin. Corp.Roberts v. Einsidler Mgmt., Inc.1650 Realty Assocs., LLC v. Golden Touch Mgmt., Inc.Padovan v. KormyloHerrera v. Lever1136 Realty, LLC v. Banco Popular of North AmericaG.C. v. G.C.McCormick v. City of N.Y.Schmeelk v. King Kullen Grocery Co.Addonisio v. City of New YorkParabit Realty LLC v. Town of HempsteadTing Zhou Li v. Chun Kien Realty Corp.Brezski v. Rockville Ctr. Union Free Sch. Dist.Hutton v. City of New YorkBaum v. DrimmerWardrett v. WambuaPeople v. PerezAable Multi Servs. v. PerrySmith v. 111 Chelsea LLCSelective Ins. Co. of America v. Chu & Gassman Consulting Eng'rs, P.C.Lupo v. Pro Foods, LLCHahn v. RaffoneLieblich v. PruzanLiberty Doorworks, Inc. v. BaranelloSunTrust Mortg., Inc. v. KingstonShum v. Carpatia Resorts USASaunders v. BohariArbitration of Certain Controversies Between Petry Holding, Inc. v. Rural Media Grp., Inc.NBTY Acquisition LLC v. Marlyn Neutraceuticals, Inc.Nukho v. O'ConnorMikhailov v. KatanMoyal v. Theemasystems, Ltd.Camacho v. City of New YorkGioia v. City of New YorkPeople v. FowlerLoporcaro v. City of New YorkPerruzza v. L&M Creations of New YorkLang v. KellyKelly v. Lenox Hill Hosp.Liberty Doorworks, Inc. v. BaranelloJohnson v. DoldoFeng Xing v. LeckelBohan v. City of New YorkFalk v. GalloGorton v. MarmonHarris v. Cnty. of NassauTudeme v. WaltersGordon v. Bd. of Managers of the 18 E. 12th St. Condo.Fusco v. GoldfarbHuei-Ying Chen v. CaropreseIn re PasternackWinkler v. Suffolk OB/GYN Grp., P.C.Excell v. City of New YorkHaave v. Jean-LouisSignal Capital Holdings Corp. v. Banc of Am. Leasing & Capital, LLCOrosz v. OroszKatan Grp., LLC v. CPC Res., Inc.People v. DrumgoolePryor Cashman LLP v. U.S. Coal Corp.Lombardi v. 79 Crosby St. LLCIn re Estate of FamigliettiMorrisania Towers Hous. Co. Ltd. P'ship v. Lexington Ins. Co.Parkway Trading Grp. Corp. v. BlesofskyLowery v. RheaSci. Applications Int'l Corp. v. Envtl. Risk Solutions, LLCEarl–Strunk v. N.Y. State Bd. of ElectionsWest 63 Empire Assocs., LLC v. Walker & Zanger, Inc.Samuel v. City of Saratoga SpringsSewer v. City of New YorkTudeme v. David Walters, Monarch Staffing, Inc.Fernandez v. MoreroRevich v. Long Island Spine & Orthopedics, P.C.Ramirez v. Rotavele Elevator, Inc.Sagres 2001 LP v. Sagres Partners LLCChung v. MingoiaMorante v. DuncanDavidson v. EgelmanTrotter v. Rashti & RashtiMartinez v. RodriguezPeople v. ChuynRobinson v. CrawfordHuntington v. MastroianniLee v. Unitech Design, Inc.Bd. of Managers of the Lido Beach Towers Condo. v. Caseworks Architect, PLLCCannonball Fund, Ltd. v. Marcum & Kliegman, LLPPiroozian v. HomapourPeople v. GilmorePeople v. ValerioThermwell Prods., Inc. v. Nitto Denko America, Inc.Erkula v. SanchezMarsala v. City of Long BeachO.C. ex rel. F.D. v. City of New YorkKanani v. Dist. Attorney of the Cnty. of New YorkLjuba v. LjubaJ.S. v. GoldweberAkhtab v. BCBG Max Azria Grp. Inc.Prudential Ins. Co. of Am. v. Wrynn]Maya N.Y., LLC v. Daryl Hagler, N.E. Dev., LLCLee v. QueensNikolla v. LiekeShure v. S & S Eatery, L.L.C.Gabriel v. Dep't of Educ.Miracle Inn, LLC v. First American Int'l BankHofftnger Stern & Ross, LLP v. NeumanMcGivney v. Union Tpk. Rest. LLCJem Caterers of Woodbury, Ltd. v. Woodbury Jewish Ctr.People v. LudwigsenPeyton v. PWV Acquisition LLCPeople v. SantiagoCasale v. LondaMarsala v. City of Long BeachTyson v. NarainLaw Office of James E. Hurley v. Beulah Church of God in Christ Jesus Inc.Luetto v. AbreuPlatten v. New York State Div. of ParoleState Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Page Taxi Corp.Kim v. Baybridge at Bayside Condo 11Donovan v. HaubenBurkett v. Magna Contracting Corp.Mizuno v. BarakWindley v. City of New YorkE. Hampton Union Free Sch. Dist. v. Sandpebble Builders Inc.Alliancebernstein L.P. v. GelwargGreen v. Canarsie A.W.A.R.E., Inc.Rodriguez v. DiazBank of Smithtown v. 415 West 150 LLCIDS USA, Inc. v. Impac Logistic Serv., LLCHF Lexington KY LLC v. Wildcat Synergy Manager LLCAngelea v. AronskyCurry v. Duane Reade Inc.Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. ChateauInner View Inc. v. Circle Press, Inc.Hotel Capital LLC v. Wells Fargo Bank, Nat'l Ass'nLouizov v. City of New YorkPeople v. RamirezRuiz-Hernandez v. TPE NWI Gen.People v. DiazAzadi v. EjlalIssing v. Madison Square Garden Ctr., Inc.Rotter v. RipkaCVL Real Estate Holding Co. v. WeinsteinChristensen v. O'BrienHYMF, Inc. v. Highland Capital Mgmt., L.P.Gettinger Assocs., LLC v. Abraham Kamber & Co.Gettinger Assocs., LLC v. Abraham Kamber & Co.W.D. v. AliagaYoon Jung Kim v. CarpioTroy v. SlawskiYoung v. BrownPraetorian Ins. Co. v. First Class Grp., Inc.Brusco v. KoffGorelik v. GorelikGlen-Haven Residential Health Care Facilities, Inc. v. MerolaBd. of Managers of St. James Tower Condo. v. KutlerBailey v. IslamFernandez v. 608136 LLCJones v. Olamar Food Corp.Mohamed v. PersaudPeople v. WatersQBE Ins. Corp. v. OlivaresPeople v. RamirezGilbert v. TaylorVelesaca v. Metro. Transp. Auth.Gaboton v. New York State Dep't of Motor VehiclesGrech v. HRC Corp.Jankite v. CSPN Paliuras Constr. Corp.Davis v. New York City Transit Auth.Johnson v. SchriroAcadia 1 Corp. v. Ins. Co. of N. Am.,Mincone & Mincone, P.C. v. Irwin Union Bank & Trust Co.Biggio v. CarmanSpota v. ShureMargulffis v. GardnerGov't Emps. Ins. Co. v. GorobetzSolomons v. Douglas Elliman LLCDavidson v. 247 West 37th St. Assocs., LLCPeople v. DiazHeintz v. IrgangTask Oil Corp. v. Xerxes Corp.Alba Invs., LLC v. GCM Servs. Corp.Barros v. Hirsch Co.Brown v. PowellAssaf & Siegal, PLLC v. MiciottaFilstein v. BrombergStrauss v. City Univ. of New YorkBuffalo United Charter Sch. v. New York State Pub. Emp't Relations Bd.Sforza v. ModelewskiACA Fin. Guar. Corp. v. Goldman, Sachs & Co.Lombardi v. 79 Crosby St. LLCZanelli v. RichPeople v. HopeSwartz v. AllowayBaum v. New York City Hous. Auth.People v. Coal. Against Brest Cancer, Inc.Berger v. ShenChelsea Piers L.P. v. Hudson River Park TrustBarreto v. Metro. Transp. Auth.Kim v. Wasserstein Enters., LLCFrederick v. New York City Dep't of Hous. Pres. & Dev. Hope Cmty.Dittmer v. Claremont Children's Sch.Suffolk Anesthesiology Assocs., P.C. v. VerdoneAslam v. Fenway Dev., LLCWright v. Mitchell21st Century Advantage Ins. Co. v. Kissena Med. Imaging, P.C.Petrocone v. Town of North HempsteadWalsh v. Double N Equip. Rental Corp.McDonald v. AC.&S., Inc.Kroeger v. FischerPM&JP Car Wash, LLC v. Nu Finish Car Wash, Ltd.Cuomo v. Empire Prop. Solutions, LLCJordan v. YardenyMcLaughlin v. DeFalcoSuperior Rest. NYC, L.P. v. 316 Bowery Realty Corp.State Bank of Long Island v. Botticelli Builders, LLCT&F Fast Foods Corp. v. Kessanidis Twins Realty, LLCSzpyrka v. Mentor Dev. Corp.Khatari v. ShamiTrjola v. DainesMorrisania Towers Hous. Co. v. Lexington Ins. Co.People v. DavisEckardt v. Starr Bldg. Realty LLCM.M. v. T.M.In re CocoMcHugh v. MartinMaluf v. VanceUS Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. McPhersonHoffman v. BantaIn re ShureAyala v. Hunts Point Assocs., LLCAlbaum v. Greens Golf Club, LLCLombard v. ZapolskyHogin v. City of New YorkFin. Freedom Acquisition LLC v. MalloyAetna Life Ins. Co. v. Appalachian Asset Mgmt. Corp.Golding v. Nationscredit Fin. Servs. Corp.Allied Irish Banks, PLC v. Young Men's Christian Ass'n of GreenwichIn re Rehab. of Executive Life Ins. Co. of New YorkJG Club Holdings, LLC v. Jacaranda Holdings, LLCJ.G. Wentworth Originations, LLC v. JourPeople v. SantiagoPeople v. MikeCustomweld Indus., Inc v. Pike Co.People v. JonesSpecialized Realty Servs., LLC v. MaikischHaas v. N.Y.C. Board/Department of Educ.Med. Prods., Inc. v. GoldsteinIngrid v. V.S. Hunter Assocs., Inc.Kim v. SanfilippoGordon v. Bd. of Managers of the 18 East 12th St. Condo.Hyung Ki Lee v. New York Hosp. QueensMarsala v. City of Long Beach Time Square Constr., Inc. v. Jarvis Mgmt. Corp.Walsh v. Double N Equip. Rental Corp.People v. LucianoLi-Shan Wang v. TIAA-CREF Life Ins. Co.Schwarz v. ValenteMintz & Fraade, P.C. v. DocuPort, Inc.Pinon v. 99 Lynn Ave LLCOrtega v. New York City Hous. Auth.Redmond v. BaileyBurns v. Rockville Skilled Nursing & Rehab. Ctr., LLCSusko v. 377 Greenwich LLCSiler v. Ennis Francis Houses Mgmt.Civil Serv. Emps. Ass'n, Inc. v. Nassau Health Care Corp.Warner v. Continuum Health PartnersAlan B. Greenfield, M.D., P.C. v. Long Beach Imaging Holdings, LLCProcess Equip. Co. of Tipp City v. WeilGonzalez-Bianco v. Bank of Am., N.A.Zakharyuk v. RomannBenn v. BennWilson v. Imagesat Int'l N.V.HF Lexington KY LLC v. Wildcat Synergy Manager LLCAntebi v. Thor Gallery at Warren Conner, LLCHaigh v. Metro North Commuter R.R.Berenbaum v. Joffrey Ballet Ctr. for American Dance, Inc.Gaddi v. GaddiDe Lage Landen Fin. Servs., Inc. v. GordonWorld Cable Inc. v. Thompson-WestRoberts v. Bd. of Educ.Tate Law Grp., LLC v. Stillwater Funding, LLCBank of Am. N.A. v. LucidoGov't Emps. Ins. Co. v. AdornoBenjamin v. City of N.Y.10 E. End Ave. Owners, Inc. v. Two E. End Ave. Apartment Corp.Betz v. Town of HuntingtonBranch v. Cnty. of SullivanSarmiento v. Turner Constr. Co.Lanter v. Allstate Ins. Co.East Hampton Union Free Sch. Dist. v. Sandpebble Builders Inc.Schiller v. Bender, Burrows & Rosenthal, LLPBastiampillat v. AdisaCecere v. Zep Mfg. Co.McCarthy v. N. Westchester Hosp.Ayala v. Hunts Point Assocs., LLCJing Chen v. HuynhDelvalle v. ReeseLoporcaro v. City of N.Y.People v. McLarenHomar v. Am. Home Mortg. Acceptance, Inc.Koom v. Muslim Ctr. of New York, Inc.Loporcaro v. City of New YorkTroeller v. New York City Dep't of Educ.Geyer v. PerloffIn re DolanGensch v. InterligiLevitt v. GotheraAlonso v. HernandezBrusco v. KoffMercedes v. FarrellyBaker, Sanders, Barshay, Grossman, Fass, Muhlstock & Neuwirth, LLC v. Comprehensive Mental Assessment & Med. Care, P.C.Lopez v. Carollo BakeryPeople v. Elliott167 8th Ave LLC v. LeishmanGioia v. City of N.Y.Borden v. 400 E. 55TH St. Assocs. L.P.Maya New York, LLC v. HaglerPrudential Ins. Co. of America v. WrynnSchiano v. Marina, Inc.Girvin v. BirnbaumPortfolio Recovery Assocs., LLC v. PloskiPostert v. Dep't of Educ. of the City of New YorkVaccaro v. SchonholzRoyzman v. Consol. Edison Co. of New YorkCity of New York v. Nova Cas. Co.Utica Mut. Ins. Co. v. CullumBd. of Managers of Gateway Condo. v. LeonardBradley v. 50 Orchard St. Assocs. LLCBrandt v. ZahnerLee v. 2075-2081 Wallace Ave. Owners Corp.Wolf v. Metro. Prop. & Cas. Ins. Co.Recovery Racing III, LLC v. TambiniRieue v. New York State Higher Educ. Servs. Corp.Cohen v. Cuomo