Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York September 1997 casesForzano v. ScuderiPeople v. HarrisMatter of ShabbirBurell v. New York City Transit AuthorityNoritsu Am. Corp. v. MazurPeople v. DemskyVillage of Tarrytown v. Woodland Lake EstatesPeople v. WardenPEOPLE v. TANMunz v. MunzPeople v. ManiramMatter of Burks v. WingPeople v. SeabrookMatter of Nicole QSweeney v. Port Authority of New York N.JPeople v. Warden of West FacilityPeople v. PiperLifshitz v. BradyPeople v. ClarkePeople v. RossMatter of RosenbergPeople v. BoothAuletti v. Chemical BankPeople v. BryantMatter of Crane v. CranePeople v. ScottMatter of Lakeside Family Children ServicesPeople v. BarnesTyler v. OaksPeople v. RobinsonHextall v. PierreMatter of Rodgers v. CrumbMatter of Salvati v. SalvatiKass v. KassKeshavarz v. MurphyGarcia v. Renaissance Gardens AssociatesPeople v. RidorePeople v. PenaPEOPLE v. DOYLMatter of Rowlett v. CoombePeople v. WilliamsFoster v. AbramsMatter of JiminezMatter of Evelyn Rebecca WPalmieri v. La ContiSmith v. World YachtPeople v. EmptagePeople v. MohammedPeople v. KingPeople v. GainesBommer v. New York HospPeople v. HammonsHeron v. Pike Co., Inc.People v. GordonMatter of HassenfratzCorbett v. New Rochelle HospBurrell v. New York City Transit AuthorityMatter of Melendez v. MelendezMarine Midland Bank v. Jake's ProductsSheffield v. GoordIn re SantanaPeople v. MirandaGulotta v. Bechtel Corp.Brennan v. 3785 South Park, Inc.Nolen v. GoordMatter of St. Farm Mut. A. Ins. Co. v. CordesPeople v. WatsonPeople v. SmithMatter AielloPeople v. HenryPeople v. FochlerPeople v. PanMatter of Amer. Lenders. Ser. Comp. of StatePowell v. United Parcel Service, Inc.People v. VaccaroIsaacs, Evans Haley, L. L. P. v. LandPeople v. AndersonPeople v. BrownMatter of Dutchess County Dept. of Soc. ServMental Hygiene Legal Services v. FordA to Z Appl. Die Cut. v. 319 McKibbin St.People v. TaylorPeople v. RamosFernandez v. MinskyMatter of Curtis v. HillerMatter of Hartnett v. HartnettMcCullough v. New York City Housing AuthorityVerstreate v. CohenMatter of Stevens v. Coudert BrothersPeople v. SmeraldoPeople v. MarriaCalandrillo v. AlessiNABI v. NABIMatter of NaughtonMatter of Crystal C19 E. 80TH ST. TENANTS' v. NYS, HOUSDAVID FRANKEL REALTY v. NYS DIV. OF HOUSMatter of Matthew S. v. Angela WRipley v. Town of North HempsteadPeople v. ShabazzTunstall v. Sol Seifer & Co.Harper v. AustinPeople v. HoldridgePeople v. WoodTrinidad v. Prospective Dev. GroupHartzell v. WingPeople v. MatthewsPeople v. CrossBensimon v. FishmanBeslow v. Novell, Inc.People v. MolinaPeople v. GarciaBifaro v. SmithMatter of Muhammad v. BennettPeople v. PageMatter of Uhler v. a PPeople v. SloanMatter of V. En. Ser. v. N.Y.C. D. of En. PPilot Communications, L. L. C. v. CorlettAlbion Fed. S. L. Ass'n v. Thrift Ass'nPeople v. ReichardtBesaw v. WingPeople v. HallPeople v. CallahanSaland v. Village of SouthamptonFox v. Monfort, Inc.Chris-Craft Indus. v. Phoenix SportsPeople v. OwensBanks v. Hanson Place Dental AssociatesPeople v. DukesMatter of Melendez v. GoordMastrantoni v. MastrantoniBrown v. KonczeskiNAB Construction Corp. v. Consolidated Edison Co. of New York, Inc.Willard v. Preferred Mutual Insurance Co.Greenberg v. McLaughlinPeople v. SmithPeople v. EudellPeople v. AllenPeople v. BenjaminHardy v. WalkerPeople v. GreenLee v. Citibank, N. A.Matter of DowningRUIZ v. NEW YORK ZOOLOGICAL SOCYPeople v. LeeJarmusz v. State of New YorkMalsch v. City of New YorkMatter of Dawes v. SelskyPeople v. HollandPeople v. YoungBerg v. Wegmans Food MarketsPeople v. CampbellPeople v. MoorePeople v. WareMatter of Williams v. GoordPeople v. WoodruffZiobro v. Children's Hospital of BuffaloPfeiffer v. BizarEvans v. EvansWells v. WellsPeople v. KennedyPeople v. HenryMatter of Richard SPeople v. VasquezRice v. DavisSEQUA CORP. v. MISR INTL. BANK53 West 53rd, Inc., v. 53rd St. AssociatesPeople v. FeltonPeople v. BacchiMatter of Corrin LMatisoff v. DobiRandolph v. Nationwide Mut. Fire Ins. Co.SCP (Bermuda), Inc., v. Bermudatel LTDRIDGE MEADOWS HOMEOWNERS v. TARA DEV. COPeople v. GavinIn re KelleherCarlton Invs. v. TLC Beatrice HoldingsSullivan v. SullivanMatter of StoddardPeople v. MccannMatter of Jackson v. PortuondoBogard v. PaulPeople v. CastroPeople v. MitchellPeople v. VasquezSotheby's Intl. Realty v. KaminsCION v. CIONMurphy v. Omer Construction Co.People v. MillerMatter of Michael DIn re the Claim of HeebPeople v. RodriguezCoopers Lybrand v. SabetPeople v. MitchellKurnitz v. New Rochelle Hosp. Med. CTRDeboth v. Uniroyal Tire Co.Balk v. City of New YorkSawma v. StatePeople v. MartePeople v. NunezPeople v. OwensPeople v. ColeDoyle, Doherty Fleishell v. GrunbergPeople v. JohnsonPeople v. JablonskiBuscaglia v. LaporteKOBY v. KOBYNYDIC/Westchester Mobile MRI Associates, L.P. v. Lawrence HospitalPalazzolo v. PalazzoloHubert v. DevineMatter of Van Steenburg v. ThomasPeople v. MccoyNabi v. NabiPeople v. BermudezPeople v. McDowellPeople v. ScottPEOPLE v. EZERamirez v. ArmstrongBubeck v. Main Urology AssociatesPeople v. WilliamsStackwick v. Young Men's Christian Ass'n of Greater RochesterPeople v. KellerMatter of KakoullisDi Rose v. GoordPrudential Sec. v. Paul BrigianosNorthberry Corp. v. Lee Liang ConstrPeople v. BurrisPeople v. LucaPeople v. StokesMatter of Wayne HCastillo v. GoordWhalen v. Kawasaki Motors Corp.Matter of DelaneyPeople v. DelossantosMatter of WeingartenGood-Land Mgt. v. Port Chester ScaffoldingPeople v. TorresQuinn v. County of RensselaerParamount Ins. Co. v. SanzoneMinley v. State of New YorkPeople v. PhillipsMatter of Bramble v. MeadPeople v. PartridgeIn re Tina G.People v. MackN.Y.C. v. Cross Bay Contracting Corp.Parker v. StateTilden Commercial Alliance, Inc. v. 2nd Edition Originals, Inc.Hausknecht v. AckermanTaylor-Gove v. St. Joseph's HospitalWeisberger v. GoldsteinIsnardi v. Genovese Drug Stores, Inc.Osorio v. BraunerPeople v. KovzeloveMatter of DeMarco v. RafteryMatter of Dumpson v. McClellanTrustees of Univ. of Pa. v. Home Ins. Co.Bechhoefer v. Nationwide Mut. Ins. Co.Matter of Quick v. Steuben Co. SELF-INS. PPeople v. WardenPeople v. JeffriesAdams v. FrankelPeople v. EnglishChemical Bank v. LevineMatter of Wayne Co. D.S.S. v. Brett DBurros v. Village of DansvilleUn. Bk., Africa v. Equatorial Trade CapDawson v. RuizLA CASA DI ARTURO, INC. v. MANGANOFrantz v. McGonagleFidelity Deposit Co. of Md. v. AltmanPeople v. AldingerPeople v. GreenRoyal Indemnity Company v. BelcerPeople v. RobinsonMatter of Dresner v. StatePulice v. PulicePeople v. LaveryMatter of OrmerodPeople v. DemerritPeople v. PenaMatter of Carbone v. Board of TrusteesPeople v. WareByan v. Prudential Insurance Co. of AmericaBoring v. DenkoKrampen v. FosterMatter of AbramsBorelli v. 1051 Realty Corp.People v. SummersJajoute v. City Health and Hospitals Corp.Matter of GambutiEvans v. EvansPeople v. ConnorVainchenker v. VainchenkerPeople v. TolliverFilson v. Cold River Trail Rides Inc.Matter of Greene v. CoombeHanil Bank v. SonPeople v. JacksonMatter of Lodick v. City of Niagara FallsWhaley v. CarpenterLogue v. VelezIn re PackPeople v. TerryPeople v. ChimentiPeople v. Van EttenPeople v. ProfitPeople v. Johnston38 Gold St. Inc. v. 211 Thompson OwnersPeople v. GarciaPeople v. LewisGross v. WolffCarroll v. HarwinFisher v. Alexander Fiden Machinery Co.Matter of Natasha CCatechis v. CorinesMatter of Arnheim v. Grievance ComPeople v. WalkerLamonica v. LamonicaLevine v. Fifth Housing Company, Inc.MICHAELSON v. MANHATTAN BRONX SUR. TR. OPMatter of Requal PPeople v. PringlePEOPLE v. BERKPeople v. PrempehMatter of Brian EMatter of AshfordPeople v. PringleMatter of Donald F. LPeople v. RosarioPoyer v. Wegman'sCaruso v. Allnet Communication Serv., Inc.Greene v. Merchants & Business Men's Mutual InsurancePoole v. Consolidated Rail Corp.Matter of Sneed v. HammonsKura v. Teachers Insurance & Annuity Ass'n of AmericaPeople v. MerckVan Vlack v. BakerMatter of Prendergast v. Kingston City SchoolMoore v. TappenReuters Ltd. v. Dow JonesA.B.N. Jewelry v. Am. Alliance Ins. Co.Rosenberg v. Helmsley Enters., Inc.N. Kruger, Inc. v. CNA Insurance Co.Chlor-Hedayatzadeh v. Ionics, Inc.Town of Beekman v. CooperPeople v. HoltonWarren v. Sheriff's Office, County of OrangePeople v. MillerMatter of LanderPeople v. CummingsJohnson v. BrownPeople v. GonzalezMeller v. Fisher-BrandveenSantucci Construction Corp. v. ErricoGalbreath Co., L.P. v. Kmart Corp.Lipiska v. RyanPeople v. JacksonPeople v. BarrinoPeople v. LeslieRockman v. BrosnanPeople v. DalgettyGlynn v. Un. House of Prayer for All PeopleMatter of Ashanti WPeople v. SimsHarry B. v. Leonora DPeople v. OgbudimkpaMatter of Crosta v. O'RourkePeople v. YepesPeople v. CabrejaBarclay's Business Credit v. StewartPeople v. DupreePeople v. MercadoPeople v. AvellanetAmedio v. Pyramid Champlain Co.Readdon v. La ClairFoti v. Town Board of Town of Amherst Matter of PottsMontilla v. AlcantaraPeople v. JunePeople v. DevonishWilliams v. Graphtech Group, LTDRandolph v. Nationwide Mutual Fire InsuranceForbes v. CityRescigno v. Key BankFoster v. AbramsDarvas v. DarvasShuman v. BowerMatter of Gathers v. CoombePeople v. ApontePeople v. SallittoFrazier v. Soc., Stage Dir. ChoreographersBrooks v. Harris Structural SteelAmabile v. City of BuffaloStern v. Jiab Realty Corp.People v. Barratt91st St. Co., v. RobinsonMatter of Nickels v. McCallAberbach Enters., Ltd. v. WeintraubKhodadadian v. WolffPagan v. GoordPeople v. JohnsonPeople v. GouldPeople v. MartinezMedina v. SenkowskiPeople v. Emtage1100 PARK AVE. COOP. v. TAX COMMN. OF NYCCRES JEWELRY FCTY. v. GOOD-LAND MGT. CORPStanton v. City of New YorkMatter of ZieleMatter of Medina v. SenkowskiGeorge v. Huber Hunt Nichols, Inc.People v. WrightPeople v. JenkinsGaskin v. FosterPeople v. StaudiglBurke v. GalliFrank v. FrankSpano v. RileyCutolo v. KhalifeIn re Rebecca AltieriMatter of Scalabrini v. ScalabriniL B 595 Madison, Inc. v. RavagnanCastrillon v. Erm-Northeast, Inc.People v. HarrisVLEESCHHOUWER v. UPSTAIRS/DOWNSTAIRS OF NYNorthberry Structures v. Northberry Corp.People v. BinnsLiberty Mutual Insurance Co. v. Fordham Preparatory SchoolPeople v. HairstonPeople v. WilliamsPeople v. SpikesDrattel v. Toyota Corp.People v. GlassMatter of Razi-Bey v. HuntMatter of Graham v. N.Y.C. Transit AuthPontoon v. GoordMatter of KabuyaAnthony G. v. City of New YorkMatter of Eagle Insurance Company v. GervaisClaim of FowlerPeople v. McCloudPeople v. AyalaPeople v. CoxonDOLA CONSTR. CORP. v. ROBERTSPeople v. MelendezPeople v. MackenzieBlake v. GoordPeople v. CalderonMatter of Vargas v. Water Front CommZimmerman v. Skate Key Roller Rink, Inc.People v. SanchezSUTTON E. ASSOCS. v. YOUNG MEN'S XN. ASSNSpano v. RileyKolassa v. RuizPeople v. ThomasPeople v. SloanMatter of Ziegler v. Chenango Self-InsurancePeople v. JonesSCHAFFEL v. NEW ROCHELLE YOUNG MEN'S XNPeople v. HarrisTaromina v. Presbyterian Hosp. City of N.YPeople v. BouzyPeople v. IppolitoLevi v. SmithRiley v. John W. Stickl Const. Co., Inc.Home Sav. of Am. v. AmorosRemark Elec. Corp. v. Manshul Const. Corp.Matter of HinmanMarine Midland Bank, N.A. v. YorukSharkey v. Battery Park City AuthPeople v. PollardPeople v. SmithIn the Matter of JohnsonHanley v. CastaldoPeople v. PenaMatter of Washington v. CoombePeople v. AngesMatter of Colleen S.People v. TonyPeople v. CoxHewitt v. PoleoMatter of Duane DPeople v. JohnsonHidalgo v. Heights Investment GroupFlour City Architect. Met. v. Sky-LiftIn re Kara M.Matter of ForbesPeople v. TiradoMatter of Henshaw v. McCallPeople v. DixCowen Co. v. HowePeople v. AndujarPeople v. WigganPeople v. BrockettMendez v. ReynoldsMatter of Sanchez v. LeonardoMatter of Olin BLebron v. WalkerShiel v. TerminiPeople v. SerranoPoveromo v. Avis Rent-A-Car System, Inc.Fuller v. BradyPeople v. MarchPeople v. BerryPeople v. MayberryMatter of Meyers v. HalladayMatter of Nogueras v. CoombePatterson v. Anderson Avenue AssociatesMatter of Brooks v. State Dpt., Corr. ServPeople v. BrunelleMatter of Colon v. VaccoCole v. Mandell Food Stores, Inc.Waljoy Realty Co. v. New York State Division of Housing & Community RenewalMRI Broadway Rental, Inc. v. United States Mineral Products Co.People v. SidesReohr v. Golub Corp.People v. BryantPeople v. AdkinsEidelman v. HochauserBurros v. Village of DansvilleLabodin v. State of New YorkPoole v. Consolidated Rail CorporationMatter of Ocasio v. GoordGovas v. BorkowPeople v. HarperPeople v. BacchusMenges v. HogyaPeople v. AlvarezKindzierski v. FosterLindville Housing Co., Inc. McGannPeople v. HidalgoLamonica v. LamonicaPeople v. TorresPeople v. DonovanPeople v. PujolsMassey v. NychaZdzinski v. North Star Construction, Inc.Matthew S. v. Angela W.Perry v. WingIn re EvangelistaPeople v. JonesMatter of Taylor v. SelskyPeople v. DorseyMatter of Messina v. Bellmore F. Dist. CommCentral Fed. v. 405 W. 45th St., Inc.People v. LanePeople v. CarterParis v. ReissPeople v. BrownPeople v. NaegeleJupiter v. PetersPeople v. ThomasAmer. Trans. Ins. v. Val-Roc Trking, Inc.People v. PhillipsPeople v. WilliamsNatl. Union Fire Ins. Co. v. WeinstockPeople v. BoothBinghamton Plaza, Inc. v. Fashion Bug #2470 of Binghamton, Inc.People v. FelicianoPeople v. SanchezPeople v. DayPeople v. MillerJoyce v. Joplex Constr. Corp.Matter of Thorpe, v. ErlbaumKarrow v. MehtaPeople v. BridgewaterPeople v. WilsonIn re GoodmanCicero v. Genesee Hosp3 W. 35th Realty Corp. v. Courtland MFGGrabowski v. KrausMatter of OlivieroMatter of Samuels v. GoordPeople v. Bolden BanksPeople v. RobinsonPeople v. RodriguezMatter of Estate of ZieleNaughton-General v. NaughtonPeople v. CashPerez v. PerezHayden v. Bruni Construction Co., Inc.Matter of QuinnS.A.B. Enterprises v. Stewart's Ice Cream Co.6 Davis Assoc., Inc. v. Rye Castle Apt. OMatter of Fastag v. Chemical BankIsnardi v. Genovese Drug Stores, Inc.Midamerica Federal Savings Bank v. GaonFrattalone v. FreundMatter of ConiglioChulla v. DiStefanoMatter of 789 St. Marks Rlty. Corp. v. CommrPeople v. HolmesOlson v. Kehoe Component Sales, Inc.Barrett v. New York State Div. of ParoleHampton I Realty Corp. v. Travertine Corp.People v. ScottPeople v. MoodyPeople v. WorrolZambanini v. Otis Elevator CompanyIn re RemmelinkMatter of Montalalou v. CoombePeople v. BlackPeople v. SmithHarris v. HarrisMatter of N.Y. Cen. Mut. Fire Ins. Co.People v. HillMatter of Mosley v. GoordJLA CREDIT CORP. v. EFREMOVReliance Ins. Co., N. Y. v. Chemical BankPeople v. TinsleyBrookman Brookman v. Galvin PalmerFirst Trust National Association v. ChiangBank of Utica v. Oriskany Manor, Inc.Weston v. GoordMatter of Eileen PaulPRINCE STUDIO CORP. v. TAX COMMN. OF NYCPeople v. GilesMatter of Thomas QIn re BedellVillage of Tarrytown v. Woodland Lake EstatesPeople v. NaqviMatter of Aetna Life Casualty v. GramazioKlein v. LevinPeople v. SmithTonawanda School Employees Federal Credit Union v. ZackLester v. WatermanEurogen, Inc. v. Kalman CensorJemiolo v. ZielinMatter of Desiree BMatter of Burns v. GoldsweigCelnick v. FreitagBaker v. Getty Oil Co.Matter of New York City Asbestos LitigMatter of Danielle TPeople v. BarnettDumet v. Sherman Estates, Inc.Endres v. Mingles Restaurant LTDPeople v. FerrerGordon v. GuarreraPeople v. AbbottPeople v. JacksonPeople v. MooreMiller v. SteinFromm v. CapelloPeople v. KennedySeptoff v. La Shellda Maintenance Corp.Matter of Colleen A. SPeople v. AlmonteCoffee Trade Servs., Inc. v. Albany Ins. Co.Schorsch v. SchorschSchioppa v. PallottaPeople v. TuckerPeople v. CrumplerWilliams v. TeDave Enterprises, Inc.Matter of CarterSchel v. RothWheeler v. Social Servs CommrPeople v. CranePeople v. ReedRook v. 60 Key Centre, Inc.Matter of Boomer v. WalkerJackson v. Attorney-General, of N.YCSEH v. NEW YORK CITY TR. AUTHMatter of Reese v. PokorskiMatter of Edward WFiedler v. Inc. Village of Massapequa ParkRomay v. 400 E. 77th Owners, Inc.Home Fed. Sav. Bank v. Rock Video IntlPeople v. Church-FordPeople v. SmithPeople v. TalaveraSawyer v. SawyerJulius Nasso Concrete v. New York Conv. CTRPeople v. SantiagoMatter of McDonaldMatter of Jaffer v. MccooeMatter of Madalyn R. v. City Com., Soc. SerVan Denburg v. SchumakerNormandy Owners v. Aquarius Int. Rty. AssocMatter of James v. CityMatter of SistiPeople v. GizaPeople v. ThomasIn re WalesKelley v. Inforite Corp.People v. AlburyJemiolo v. ZielinPeople v. CortesPeople v. MachovoePeople v. PenaPeople v. SimsPitcher v. Town of LysanderMcKeon v. Sears Roebucks&sCo.Liverpool v. Xerox CorporationMatter of ScarlettPeople v. OrmsbyThorn v. ThornPeople v. KimboroughGellman v. LatimoreNatl. Union Fire v. ClairmontProgressive Cas. Ins. Co. v. HuertasMassella v. Partner Industrial ProdPeople v. DuranClemente v. 225 Broadway Co.People v. UpshawPeople v. HaywoodRMJ Sec. Corp. v. KirwinRizzo v. Brodcom W. Dev. Co.People v. BakerBreslof v. HammonsPeople v. AlfordMatter of LloydPeople v. ZakRobertson v. BozzaPeople v. DincaMatter of HughesPeople v. DillonMatter of EichenbaumPeople v. AlbertoTutuianu v. N.Y. Dept. of Social ServPeople v. RodriguezPeople v. AlvarezKendle v. August Bohl Contracting Co.In re Ron J.Charter Rlty. Dev. v. Rotterdam Mall AssocMatter of RothmanCooper v. CooperPeople v. BazilPeople v. FelicianoMeta-Lite Inc. v. Zollo Construction Corp.Harbin Med. Health v. Import Sys. IntlPeople v. BermudezPeople v. EisemannMatter of Benton v. CoombePeople v. SantiagoPeople v. BurrtsIsrael v. IsraelSpratt v. General Electric CompanyFrank v. FrankNation's Bank Mortgage Corp. v. JonesPeople v. CohenDahroug v. TrifonPeople v. SirmonsColonie Const. Prod. v. Titan Indemnity Co.Golding v. DowlingBerkeley Fed. B. T. v. 229 E. 53rd St. A.