Patent Trial and Appeal Board September 2020 casesMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCSHINKO ELECTRIC INDUSTRIES CO., LTD.Makkapati, Vishnu Vardhan. et al.EMONSTER INCKOM Software, Inc.Yasuyuki Hoshi et al.Spin Master Ltd.Avaya Inc.Wisconsin Alumni Research FoundationMichelle FisherCytonome/ST, LLCAdobe Inc.Medtronic, Inc.Traxo, LLCLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Bal Seal Engineering, Inc.Harman International Industries, Inc.MacKay Memorial HospitalAUDI AGCRODA INTERNATIONAL PLCGuardian Glass, LLCKali Care, Inc.Agilent Technologies, Inc.MasterCard International IncorporatedUpfield US Inc.Seymour RAPAPORT et al.Great Circle Technologies, Inc.Google Inc.Wright Medical Technology, Inc.The Procter & Gamble CompanyLH Taylor Associates, Inc.Applied Materials, Inc.Texas Instruments IncorporatedLiebherr-Hydraulikbagger GmbHTownsend, Randolph G.Visa U.S.A. Inc.LIFESTYLES HEALTHCARE PTE. LTD.SONY CORPORATIONCisco Technology, Inc.SEVEN Networks, LLCSAS Institute Inc.Sascha SchneiderHewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.Barkan Wireless IP Holdings, L.P.Dareltech, LLCTokyo Electron LimitedCourtCall, LLCJulia Hoeng et al.VIACCESSUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONUNIFIED GRAVITY CORPORATIONClaus, Matthew W. et al.MAN DIESEL & TURBO SETribune Broadcasting Company, LLCApple Inc.Kaushik, Amrita et al.Kaushik, Akhil et al.Swan Athletic, LLCRobert D. Reany et al.Leslie, Steven J. et al.Tribune Broadcasting Company, LLCBAYER HEALTHCARE LLCInfineon Technologies AGRudolph Petrmichl et al.Carrier CorporationImagination Technologies, Ltd.Corning IncorporatedAPPLIED MATERIALS, INC.Exeltis USA, Inc.Intel CorporationInternational Business Machines CorporationCovidien LPFibar Group sp. z o.o.The Toronto-Dominion BankMotion Offense, LLCAvaya Inc.Image Processing Technologies, LLCJeffrey BrandstetterAndrew Clark et al.LINCOLN GLOBAL, INC.R. J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANYFord Global Technologies, LLCJoachim Jankowski et al.Wenming Zheng et al.LIFESTYLES HEALTHCARE PTE. LTD.Chargerback, Inc.GRUBE, GARY W. et al.HEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT LPCOMCAST CABLE COMMUNICATION, LLCKIM, Hyun-jin et al.Tribune Broadcasting Company, LLCINTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONVONAGE NETWORK LLCGregory Stokes et al.ARKEMA FRANCEMurata Manufacturing Co., Ltd.Petralia, Michael Thomas. et al.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONBreville USA, Inc.HARMAN INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRIES, INC.CommScope Technologies LLCSchweitzer Engineering Laboratories, Inc.UNITED PARCEL SERVICE OF AMERICA, INC.Raytheon BBN Technologies Corp.Motorola Mobility LLCForrest, Stephen et al.Scott Mace et al.Intel CorporationKYOCERA CorporationSCA HYGIENE PRODUCTS ABAnheuser-Busch InBev S.A.Scenera Mobile Technologies, LLCQUALCOMM IncorporatedPonsolle, Dominique et al.C2 DIAGNOSTICSRENISHAW PLCInternational Business Machines CorporationStefan Bassarab et al.Jay DeWitt et al.Splunk Inc.Dean Foods CompanyAnheuser-Busch InBev S.A.NINTENDO CO., LTD.Lear CorporationAurel Coza et al.THE BOEING COMPANYYAMAZAKI, Shunpei et al.Wenming Zheng et al.Wen Wang et al.PHARNEXTMatthew Casey Hyung Joon. Kim3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYC2 DIAGNOSTICSDeborah Bryan et al.Hamilton Sundstrand CorporationNestec SA3M Innovative Properties CompanyGlobe Motors, Inc.OptoTech Optikmaschinen GmbHSprinklr, Inc.NEC CorporationGeigtech East Bay LLCEdward Fuergut et al.Google Inc.Leslie, Steven J. et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONBAYER CROPSCIENCE N.V. (OWNER) et al.Merlin Technology, Inc.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCToru Nakajima et al.ELECTROLUX HOME PRODUCTS, INC.Ryan McEneany et al.Thomas CASTLE et al.Lieven Baert et al.Fisher, Michelle SAREEN, Jatin et al.Facebook, Inc.Menarini Silicon Biosystems S.p.A.VIACCESSBAYER CROPSCIENCE NV et al.Semiconductor Energy Laboratory Co., Ltd.EXCELEROMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCBAYER CROPSCIENCE NV et al.JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.Applied Materials, Inc.MasterCard International IncorporatedVMWARE, INC.Ethicon Endo-Surgery, LLCWaters Technologies CorporationApple Inc.Sauder Manufacturing Co.RON BARAK et al.DISNEY ENTERPRISES, INC.PIONEER HI-BRED INTERNATIONAL, INC.AVAYA INC.KYOCERA CORPORATIONPradeep Kumar et al.CYPRESS LAKE SOFTWARE , INC. (PATENT OWNER) et al.HITACHI METALS, LTD.Splunk Inc.Bains, Kuljit Garland Industries, Inc.Laskin, Hardy A. et al.NXP B.V.Sound View Innovations LLCTierney, Timothy CAMERON INTERNATIONAL CORPORATIONEvangelia ARVANITIDOU et al.Boston, Neville et al.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONGeigtech East Bay, LLCXEROX CORPORATIONNESTEC S.A.Applied Materials, Inc.Rochester Institute of Technology DOOSAN MACHINE TOOLS CO., LTD.Edmundo Van DoesburgVeninger, Albert et al.Capital One Services, LLCThe Board of Regents of the University of Texas System[24]7.ai, Inc.Bitingduck Press, LLCCenturyLink Intellectual Property LLC International Business Machines CorporationGo Daddy Operating Company, LLCNEC CorporationFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCCOVIDIEN LPYousef DaneshvarInternational Business Machines CorporationVONAGE NETWORK LLCCorning IncorporatedHewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.FUJITSU LIMITEDHoneywell International Inc.Regal Beloit America, Inc.Tirkkonen, Olav et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Ling TangE. I. DU PONT DE NEMOURS AND COMPANY et al.ELEMICA, INC.Virginia Ursin et al.Ryan McEneany et al.Intel CorporationQUALCOMM IncorporatedSchlangen, Jacob Rein Tech, Inc.Varel Europe S.A.S.Waters Technologies CorporationIOENGINE, LLCInternational Business Machines CorporationInternational Business Machines Corporation 8730191 et al.MTU Aero Engines AGAngelo Mascia et al.Zebra Technologies CorporationJan Smith et al.MasterCard International IncorporatedZEMACH, Shai Hamilton Sundstrand CorporationLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Lakshman Chandrasekaran et al.ASK Chemicals LLCSIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFTTHE BOEING COMPANYMegiddo, Nimrod Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America, Inc.Rudolf FuchsLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.International Business Machines CorporationTYR Sport, Inc.Kevin Cherveny et al.Donald WilsonACell, Inc.McTaggart, IngridUniversity of Virginia Patent FoundationE. I. DU PONT DE NEMOURS AND COMPANY et al.COVIDIEN LPKABUSHIKI KAISHA KOBE SEIKO SHO (KOBE STEEL, LTD.)BEIJING APOLLO DING RONG SOLAR TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD .TYCO ELECTRONICS CORPORATIONMurata Manufacturing Co., Ltd.BAYER HEALTHCARE LLCBLATCHLEY, Timothy Noah. et al.Lotan, Yalon et al.NGK Insulators, Ltd.SAUDI BASIC INDUSTRIES CORPORATION et al.Van Seggelen, Rob et al.United Technologies CorporationBal Seal Engineering, Inc.COGNANT LLCJan Smith et al.Ulrich Bley et al.United States Department of EnergyHoneywell International Inc.MacKay Memorial HospitalCERNER INNOVATION, INC.Datonics, LLCEric FogleBell Northern Research, LLC, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Hilco Patent Acquisition 56, LLC, which is owned by both Hilco IP Merchant Capital, LLC, and Hilco, Inc.Laskin, Hardy A. et al.Microsoft CorporationNOVOZYMES A/SSteven B. Homes, Inc.Google Inc.United Technologies CorporationFAIR ISAAC CORPORATIONKazmaier, Gerrit Simon. et al.Medtronic, Inc.OTIS ELEVATOR COMPANYHamilton Sundstrand CorporationSeymour RAPAPORT et al.Epicenter Experience, LLCJean-Francois Chartrel et al.Lovevery, Inc.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.Lenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.NXP B.V.Gama Sonic USA, Inc.Delaney, John et al.VMWARE, INC.Fibar Group sp. z o.o.Visa International Service AssociationMark Magidson et al.THE BOEING COMPANYEvangelia ARVANITIDOU et al.Avaya Inc.Altierre CorporationNEC CorporationNOVASTERILIS INC.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Agilent Technologies, Inc.MUKHOPADHYAY, Aveek et al.Philip Morris USA Inc.Swan Athletic, LLCOptis Wireless Technology, LLCSELECTO, INC.Image Processing Technologies LLCAccelergy CorporationIPA Technologies Inc., which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Wi-LAN Technologies Inc., which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Wi-LAN Inc., which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Quarterhill Inc.Gaurav Banga et al.Steven B. Homes, Inc.Robert D. Reany et al.Britax Child Safety, Inc.Mueller Martini Holding AGRuizhang Technology Limited CompanyAnders Stråhlin et al.United Technologies Corporationadidas AGJeffrey BrandstetterSAS Institute Inc.DePuy Synthes Products, Inc.Hamilton Sundstrand CorporationGearbox, LLCTHE WESTERN UNION COMPANYHEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT LPCARGILL, INCORPORATEDUNIVATION TECHNOLOGIES, LLCSIEMENS AKTIENGESELLSCHAFTJoanne DiPaolo et al.CERNER INNOVATION, INC.Kutella, James D.Daniel FlammNadgir, Devaprasad K. et al.Safeway Inc.Corning IncorporatedAbhijit Bose et al.QUALCOMM IncorporatedCovidien LPGS Yuasa International Ltd.J&M SHULER, INC.ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS INC.QUALCOMM IncorporatedCTC Analytics AGMARTINEZ, Jose-Luis Celorio. et al.Uniloc 2017 LLCGree, Inc.GIESECKE & DEVRIENT GMBHQUALCOMM IncorporatedMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCPHILIP MORRIS PRODUCTS S.A.Daly, Christopher N.Pradeep Kumar et al.International Business Machines Corporation Tetsuya TaniguchiLisa Brilliant et al.Aavid Thermalloy LLCATIEVA, INC.Smart SKUs Inc.BSH Hausgeräte GmbHUniloc 2017 LLCKevin Cherveny et al.PROTEAN ELECTRIC LIMITEDLAM RESEARCH CORPORATIONJens Kjelsbak et al.Adobe Inc.Ayman Hammad et al.Jaan Leemet et al.Diamond, Steven et al.COGNANT LLCTheresa Altman et al.Motorola Mobility LLCFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCSchlumberger Technology CorporationDallas/Fort Worth International Airport BoardLakshman Chandrasekaran et al.Lockheed Martin CorporationMaytex Mills, Inc.The Procter & Gamble CompanyCYPRESS LAKE SOFTWARE , INC. (PATENT OWNER) et al.Wayne SokolyTexas Instruments IncorporatedMatthias KLEINHANS et al.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCFord Global Technologies, LLCSascha SchneiderELECTROLUX HOME PRODUCTS, INC.Facebook, Inc.NOVOZYMES A/SVirginia Ursin et al.Bo Olde et al.Bhaktavachalam Thiyagarajan et al.VineSleuth, Inc.International Business Machines CorporationApplied Materials, Inc.RENISHAW PLCSarah Andrews et al.C.R. BARD, INC.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCRichard Lasota et al.United Technologies CorporationBlackBerry LimitedNXP B.V.InVue Security Products Inc.Barkan Wireless IP Holdings, L.P.VMWARE, INC.Texas Instruments IncorporatedKraeutler, Wilhelm et al.adidas AGROCKWELL AUTOMATION TECHNOLOGIES, INC.Hammond Development International, Inc.Polaris PowerLED Technologies, LLCApple Inc.APPLIED MATERIALS, INC.KAIFI LLCJaan Leemet et al.PROTEAN ELECTRIC LIMITEDVasona Networks Inc.McElfresh, Charles et al.Intel IP Corporation Suresh N. Chari et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.WEATHERFORD TECHNOLOGY HOLDINGS, LLC et al.Acoustic, L.P.Panasonic Intellectual Property Management Co., Ltd.YAMAZAKI, Shunpei et al.Lutron Technology Company LLCSemiconductor Energy Laboratory Co., Ltd.Disney Enterprises, Inc.International Business Machines CorporationELECTROLUX APPLIANCES AKTIEBOLAGROCKWELL AUTOMATION TECHNOLOGIES, INC.SLEEP NUMBER CORPORATIONCovidien LPArtur BergmanSALESFORCE.COM, INCNXP B.V.NANOPTEK CORPORATIONBASF Coatings GmbHMerlin Technology, Inc.TYCO ELECTRONICS CORPORATIONApple Inc.Burgess, James E. et al.Petralia, Michael Thomas. et al.HIGI SH HOLDINGS INC.International Business Machines CorporationGuardian Glass, LLCAirWatch LLCIOENGINE, LLCDelaney, John et al.THE WESTERN UNION COMPANYHEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT LPPharmacyclics LLCRobert AkinCapital One Services, LLCTHE BOEING COMPANYAutel Robotics USA LLCUlrich Bley et al.AJINOMOTO CO., INC.QUALCOMM IncorporatedApple Inc.Go Daddy Operating Company, LLCThe Boeing CompanyIntel IP CorporationGOOGLE INC.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCFMC CorporationTHE BOEING COMPANYDharendra Goswami et al.Apple Inc.The Procter & Gamble CompanyRusert, Thomas et al.Milliken & CompanyZEMACH, ShaiQUALCOMM IncorporatedJiang Liu et al.OERLIKON TRADING AG, TRUBBACHAngelo Mascia et al.Sprinklr, Inc.MAINSOFT R&D LTD.Nohbo, LLCNXP B.V.United Technologies CorporationGUPTA, Akhil et al.Square, Inc.Imagination Technologies LimitedINTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONGkinosatis, DimitrisC.R. BARD, INC.HITACHI METALS, LTD.Apple Inc.Agilent Technologies, Inc.Kurt Rudahl et al.CRODA INTERNATIONAL PLCAVAYA INC.SEB S.A.Command Alkon IncorporatedRegents of the University of MinnesotaVeninger, Albert et al.NITTO DENKO CORPORATIONFacebook, Inc.Hussmann CorporationComcast Cable Communications, LLCDonald Wheatley et al.The Procter & Gamble CompanyFOX SPORTS PRODUCTIONS, INC.NITTO DENKO CORPORATIONJames Nial. Hynes et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONCaavo IncMasterCard International IncorporatedHammond Development International, Inc.United Technologies CorporationOmnex Systems, LLCFord Global Technologies, LLCHarman International Industries, Inc.Schlumberger Technology CorporationEaton CorporationGregory Stokes et al.Flow Pharma, Inc.Ponsolle, Dominique et al.Imagination Technologies, Ltd.FigureFun LLCDonald WilsonMotorola Mobility LLCVMWARE, INC.Nestec SAColgate-Palmolive CompanyLighthouse Consulting Group LLCTELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET L M ERICSSON (PUBL)MUSASHI ENGINEERING, INC.Traeger Pellet Grills, LLCMaria SINGSONCA, INC.Hachtmann, Bruce et al.Hammond Development International, Inc.Raytheon BBN Technologies Corp.IndraTech LLCBEIJING APOLLO DING RONG SOLAR TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD .Daniel Opalacz et al.Lenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Colgate-Palmolive CompanyFLOORING TECHNOLOGIES LTD.THE FLORIDA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY BOARD OF TRUSTEESStefan Bassarab et al.DoDots Licensing Solutions, LLCDharendra Goswami et al.Hammond Development International, Inc.Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONUNITED PARCEL SERVICE OF AMERICA, INC.JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.HARMAN INTERNATIONAL INDUSTRIES, INC.THOMAS JEFFERSON UNIVERSITYOmnex Systems, LLCCourtCall, LLCPHILIPS LIGHTING HOLDING B.V.Institute For Information IndustryBAYER CROPSCIENCE NV et al.TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON (PUBL)MIM Software Inc.Master International IncorporatedApple Inc.CBS Interactive Inc.ENTIT SOFTWARE LLCLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Philip Morris USA Inc.Wisconsin Alumni Research FoundationInternational Business Machines CorporationNOVEN PHARMACEUTICALS, INC.J&M SHULER, INC.United Technologies CorporationGlobe Motors, Inc.Lott, Roger K.Wallentin, Pontus et al.Ron KIMMEL et al.Christopher, Diana Michaels.TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET LM ERICSSON (PUBL)HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.TECAN TRADING AGTSUJI, Ryosuke James Nial. Hynes et al.SCA HYGIENE PRODUCTS ABCisco Technology, Inc.Dell Products L.P.ARKEMA FRANCEFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCMark Ronald. Sikkink et al.Yousef DaneshvarThomas CASTLE et al.OTIS ELEVATOR COMPANYOBIHIRO UNIVERSITY OF AGRICULTURE AND VETERINARY MEDICINE et al.Aaron FishATIEVA, INC.Ellin, Alexander David Scott. et al.BAYER CROPSCIENCE N.V. (OWNER) et al.IMS SOLUTIONS, INC.KABUSHIKI KAISHA KOBE SEIKO SHO (KOBE STEEL, LTD.)Kutella, James D.Gree, Inc.Gary W. Grube et al.BAYER CROPSCIENCE NV et al.Facebook, Inc.eBay Inc.Xu, Lidong et al.OSSEO IMAGING, LLCEdmundo Van DoesburgArtur BergmanSkychase Holdings CorporationGreat Circle Technologies, Inc.Hyung Joon. KimRichard Lasota et al.MasterCard International IncorporatedAltierre CorporationIntel IP CorporationChristian Kersten et al.QUALCOMM IncorporatedVMware, Inc.NINTENDO CO., LTD.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.TEXAS INSTRUMENTS INCORPORATEDSALESFORCE.COM, INCAdobe Inc.Amazon Technologies, Inc.J&M SHULER, INC.KIM, Hyun-jin et al.KYOCERA CorporationImagination Technologies LimitedRuizhang Technology Limited CompanyLANTIQ DEUTSCHLAND GMBHINTEL IP CORPORATIONTatiana Egorova-ZachernyukRobert FarnanInternational Business Machines CorporationELECTROLUX APPLIANCES AKTIEBOLAGLotan, Yalon et al.Robert AkinFord Global Technologies, LLCBarkan Wireless IP Holdings, L.P.DYNAMICS INC.Nohbo, LLCChristopher, Diana Michaels.Caavo IncMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCGearbox, LLCCorduneanu, Adrian Dumitru. et al.Gama Sonic USA, Inc.Bruce MeratiPoeze, Jeroen et al.Corduneanu, Adrian Dumitru. et al.St. Jude Medical International Holding S.a. r.l.Citrix Systems, Inc.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.Isola USA Corp.Jantz et al. V. GALETTO et al. V. Jantz et al. V. Jantz et al.Texas Instruments IncorporatedGoogle Inc.Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America, Inc.Symrise AGCNH Industrial America LLC et al.Dragheim, Marianne et al.Command Alkon IncorporatedBritish Telecommunications Public Limited CompanyBoozarjomehr Faraji et al.Apple Inc.Traxo, LLCAT&T INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY I, LPNew Dent AGElwha LLC Calvin HsiaBritish Telecommunications Public Limited CompanyDouglas Brenhouse et al.Microsoft CorporationMcElfresh, Charles et al.NXP B.V.Visa International Service AssociationElwha LLCCalvin HsiaMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCIntel CorporationRelationship Capital Technologies Inc.PROTEAN ELECTRIC LIMITEDIrit TURBOVICHImagination Technologies LimitedApple Inc.iRobot CorporationTolga Oral et al.International Business Machines CorporationHEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT LPPHARNEXTSony Corporation et al.SAREEN, Jatin et al.
