Supreme Court of New York December 2019 casesNYCTL 2017-A Tr. v. SizeBeckford-Campbell v. Saljanin99 Sutton LLC v. N.Y.C. Loft Bd.Marcum LLP v. Fazio, Mannuzza, Roche, Tankel, Lapilusa, LLCCountry-Wide Ins. Co. v. BarryTopping v. Cab E. LLCBank of N.Y. Mellon v. MillerHaufe v. Liberty Mut. Ins. Co.Goldszmidt v. 589 Fifth Tic I, LLCVista Pointe, LLC v. Waterfront Resorts, Inc.Dunn-Cantatore v. AvalosProgressive Advanced Ins. Co. v. TalmadgeOld Crompond Rd., LLC v. Cnty. of WestchesterSundack v. The Cnty. of WestchesterCSC 4540, LLC v. 4528 Vernon Realty LLCSigmund v. PorrecaCreif Lender LLC v. Lucky of 195 Madison St. Roofing & Contr. Inc.Delaluz v. WalshOsias v. KwinterDeluca v. Gen. Utils.Pelton v. LacorataLorenzo v. FineChiagkouris v. 201 W. 16 Owners Corp.Brewer v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.Ripka v. StenzlerHenry v. GarciaWesco Ins. Co. v. Travelers Prop. Cas. Co. of Am.Favillo v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Onativia v. DeleonThompson v. 95 Sackman, LLCNRT N.Y. LLC v. Ann Holdings, LLCKolman v. GallinaAlcantara v. AnnucciPeople v. SteiningerLamarre v. SullivanPeople v. SimmonsDoe v. Good Samaritan Hosp.Commerford v. SchettkoeVelazquez-Guadalupe v. Ideal Builders & Constr. Servs..Rabasco v. Buckheit & Whelan, PCWilliamsburg United LLC v. Myoung Ja KimRose v. City of N.Y.Gatling v. Amchem Prods. Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Kerrigan v. Wei ShenTri-City, LLC v. N.Y.C. Taxi & Limousine Comm'nDamian v. DamianDavies v. S.A. Dunn & Co.Herald Square Hotel Partners, LP v. Life Hotel PartnersAmsterdam Nursing Home Corp. v. WalkinPeople v. BrownCaverly v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co.Valentine v. Collins Bros. Moving Corp.Ramsey v. StephensHawkins v. Prohealth Care Assocs.Filip v. JohnsonE. 51st St. Dev. Co. v. HFZ E. 51, LLCFriedman v. SeyunJridi v. MinajHawkins v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.Lim v. MTA Bus Co.Genao v. Bronx Lebanon Hosp. & Noemi C. BaloghEavenson v. Trs. of the Columbia Univ. in N.Y.Wright v. SmithBrighton Grassroots, LLC v. Town of Brighton Planning Bd.Brown v. ZhengObiagei Chukwu v. DefendanPeople v. WojciechowskiHaley v. ABB, Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Application of Feldman v. HarariMitchell v. 423 W. 55th St., LLCHavison v. Port Auth. of N.Y.Blatt v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Jimenez v. CrawfordBennett v. HirschAlmonte v. MedardoSmalls v. Cipriano Excavation Inc.Burdier v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.Country-Wide Ins. Co. v. Great Am. Assurance Co.Alkes v. F.J. Sciame Constr. Co.Farsakh v. Town Sports Int'l, LLCDiaz v. Combe Inc.Dig. Warehouse USA Inc. v. HasanOnewest Bank, FSB v. CookMarkham v. Math Holdings LL, LLCPeople v. LoraKaston v. G.T.I. Roll Transp. Servs. Power v. Olympic Reg'l Dev. Auth.Agbabiaka v. N.Y.C. Dep't of Educ.Singh v. 911 LLCPension Inv'rs 99, LLC v. Broad St. Plaza Assocs.City of N.Y. v. Airbnb, Inc.Yupa v. AdamowiczPruden v. 133 W 145 LLCLuna v. PSEG Long Island, LLCSatterfield v. VStock Transfer, LLCMack v. 330 Hudson St., LLCMTGLQ Inv'rs, LP v. BakshOakes v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Allen v. Pasha Fashion Ltd.Pierre-Brunot v. Skinson Realty Corp.Cregan v. BlacknerManna Amsterdam Ave. LLC v. W. 73rd Tenants Corp.Real World Holdings, LLC v. ClarkAnderson v. SinghSingapore Airlines, Ltd. v. Gen. Elec. Co.Feng Li v. ShihGutierrez v. 610 Lexington Prop., LLCJPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. NERA Prop. Holding LLCF.F. ex rel. Y.F. v. StateMandarino v. JP Morgan ChaseBiigrami v. Cnty. of NassauKarlsson v. Westchester Cnty. Health Care Corp.People v. HendersonBarnes v. BarnesVolpe v. N.Y.C. Dep't of Bldgs.Telesky v. PerrinoZelik v. RubashkinCrisafulli v. Southbridge Towers, Inc.Nick's Garage, Inc. v. State Farm Fire & Cas.Rousso Apparel Grp. v. Seaco Am. LLCBazaar v. VishnuVerizon N.Y., Inc. v. Altz Grp.Moore v. A & C Supermas, Inc.Kornblau v. SauterOnly Props., LLC v. Sylvia Wald & Po Kim Art GalleryIn re Congregation Sfard & Talmud Torah of FlatbushZehn-NY LLC v. N.Y.C. Taxi & Limousine Comm'nGottbetter v. CKR Law LLPCiancarelli v. RosalesAhmed v. N.Y.C. Health & Hosp. Corp.Iacovacci v. Brevet Holdings, LLCAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. Acupuncture Works P.C.Manhattan Beer Distributions LLC v. Biagio Cru & Estate Wines, LLCCitigroup Glob. Mkts. Inc. v. SCIP Capital Mgmt.Gibson v. Batia Realty Corp.Cole v. UgarteS. Shore D'Lites, LLC v. First Class Prods. Grp.927 Atl. Inv'rs LLC v. Brookland Capital LLCOrejuela v. City of N.Y.Sergeev v. Land-O-Fun Inc.Riordan v. GarcesPuppies Behind Bars, Inc. v. DoolenArias v. Allen J. Reyen, Inc.Salcedo v. 906 Holding LLCSullivan v. Med. Liab. Mut. Ins. Co.Citizens Bank, N.A. v. PerkinsBil-Man Asset Mgmt. LLC v. M & T 99 Lafayette Inc.Verizon N.Y., Inc. v. Nat'l Grid USA Serv. Co.Marks v. 79th St. Tenants Corp.300 W. 48th St. Assocs. v. 306 W. 48th St. Condo.Vega v. City of New YorkColonial Funding Network, Inc. v. Long Island Hosp. Mgmt.Florio v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Ford Models, Inc. v. Wilhelmina Models, Inc.Decatus v. City of New RochelleFleurisma v. MontenesKarlsson v. Westchester Cnty. Health Care Corp.Cruz v. 451 Lexington Realty, LLCPenaloza v. Adeia Assocs.People v. GreenYong Jun Li v. A.Z.N. Realty LLCInbar Grp. v. St. Mark's World, Inc.James v. Kensington Assocs.Fresco v. Plainview Hosp.People ex rel. James v. Exxon Mobil Corp.Beers v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Beckford v. Diaz320 W. 115 Realty LLC v. Avant Capital 318-320 W. 115th St. LLCIn re N.Y.S. Office of Victim Servs. ex rel. HernandezTramontano v. 106 Rivington Enter., L.L.C.Haley v. ABB, Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Leishman v. SchulmanYusupov v. Mekhtiyev Law Firm PCElizon Master Participation Tr. I, U.S. Bank Tr. N.A. v. ClarkeGalluzzo v. Town & Vill. of HarrisonFrancis v. BowesRivera v. The Roman Catholic Archdioces of N.Y.Appleyard v. Russel G. Tigges, Orthopedic Assocs. of Dutchess Cnty., P.C.Beer v. Equinox Holdings, Inc.Burry v. Wayne Cnty. Bd. of SupervisorsBank of N.Y. Mellon v. OzenVargas v. S.F. Assocs. Ltd.United Hay, LLC v. HarounianSmith v. CooperEng v. NYU Hosps. Ctr.Schlenk Metallfolien GMBH & Co. v. Dexter Sales Inc.Emic Corp. v. BarenblattEnglish v. McGrathFlores v. Broome Prop. Owner JV, LLC66-68 E. 3rd St. Tenants Ass'n v. City of N.Y.Pritsler v. Zamansky LLCFerraro v. Good Samaritan Hosp. Med. Ctr.St-Cyr v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Greenwood v. Nicola Design Studio, Inc.Itria Ventures LLC v. Provident BankBowerman v. Brightview LandscapingKegerreis v. S. Huntington Pub. LibraryHorizon at 61 Rivington LLC v. 143 Allen St. LLCHuvepharma, Inc. v. Zoetis, LLCTribeca Space Managers, Inc. v. Tribeca Mews Ltd.Skabo v. OkoronkoDe Leon v. 2 Thayer St. Realty Corp.PB-7 Doe v. Amherst Cent. Sch. Dist.Country-Wide Ins. Co. v. WilliamsShapiro v. EttensonMarks v. RieckhoffWeinstein v. LevitinStevens v. 56 W. LLCO P Sols., Inc. v. Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney P.C.Schirmer v. PiazzaJean-Baptiste v. Robert Richard, Bobby Cab Corp.Elango Med. PLLC v. Trump Palace Condo.Wesco Ins. Co. v. MoncrieffeKing Constr. v. CerussiWells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. BarberaAlaverdi v. BuiMiliotto v. CianoKarlsson v. Westchester Cnty. Health Care Corp.Mangat v. GittGarden City Park, LLC v. Frog Hollow Props., LLCGreater N.Y. Mut. Ins. Co. v. State Nat'l Ins. Co.Rosenberg v. Judlau Contracting, Inc.Arbelo v. KapicaFive E. 44th LLC v. Douglas Elliman, LLCWilk v. Tax Comm'n of N.Y.Allcare Homecare Agency v. LokshinGreenberg v. N.Y.C. Dep't of Consumer AffairsSudano v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Gallina v. MTA Capital Constr. Co.Okere v. BroisBd. of Managers of Strivers Gardens Condo. v. Moore214 Lafayette House LLC v. Akasa Holdings, LLCAllen v. GaronMartinez v. City of N.Y.Leckie v. City of N.Y.Ochs v. Ascape Landscaping & Constr. Corp.Baines v. Daily News, L.P.Kurland v. AgrestiBesen v. DoshiBd. of Managers of the Brighton Tower II Condo. v. Brighton Builder, LLCMaddali v. AnnamaneniN. Manhattan is Not for Sale v. City of N.Y.City Nat'l Bank v. Sparkling Jewels (USA) LLCCorning v. Elms Realty Corp.Chang v. Balfour Owners Corp.Ram v. Good Samaritan Hosp.Metro. N.Y. Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Am. v. Ics Found., Inc.Slonim v. Altman Stage Lighting Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Leben v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)J.G. v. MarrimonWestchester Portfolio LLC v. Parkway Vill. Equities Corp.Friends Pres v. N.Y. State Dep't of Envtl. Conservation112 W. 35th St. Co. v. Java Indus., Inc.Valdez v. City of N.Y.N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig. Joan Ambrosini v. Products188-190 Hous. Dev. Fund v. ViolaAscani v. JM & AM Realty Holdings, LLCWESCO Ins. Co. v. A1 Constr. Serv.Motta v. VenturaBrown v. DileoGluckstern v. Arklow-FBF LLCC & F Second Ave., LLC v. Comptroller of N.Y.Pickett v. Fin. Indus. Regulatory Auth.Wengui v. NunbergArthur v. 1809-15 7th Ave. Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.Ortegon-Leon v. Restrepo Constr.Amirova v. JND Trans Inc.Rodriguez v. City of N.Y.Perelshtein v. DykhneEdelman Arts v. N.Y. Art World, LLCPeople v. OsekreAktiv Assets LLC v. Centerbridge Partners, L.P.Arias v. KonnehBd. of Managers of 50 W. 127th St. Condo. v. KiddAltin Realty Corp. v. S.H. Zell & Sons, LLCBrown v. City of AlbanyEspada v. Townhouse Operating Co.McArthur Inc. v. FieldsDoe v. MacfarlandCalvacca v. Town of BabylonEdoo-Rajotte v. KendallCieszkowski v. BaldwinBitteto v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Vailes v. Molloy Coll.Pepper v. JenningsBank of Am., N.A. v. GiwaPrincipis Capital LLC v. WTC Victor, LLCSeiden v. DoriaPV Holding Corp. v. Anesthesia Servs.Kim v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Selective Ins. Co. of N.Y. v. St. Catherine's Ctr. for ChildrenDoshi v. BesenKomiak v. A.O. Smith Water Prods., Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Anderson v. SinghSitomer v. HirschKoszta v. Pavane & Kwalbrun Consulting Eng'rsHidalgo v. HawkinsTaffet v. WexlerLing Lin v. O'NeillBest v. DCG Dev. Grp.269-273 14th St NY Corp. v. SteinFolchetti v. FreeseIsaac v. Atl. Yards B2 Owner, LLCAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. SinghHylan Ross LLC v. 2582 Hylan Boulevard Fitness Grp.Falsetta v. ABB, Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Malfetano v. Westchester Cnty.Rutella v. Nat'l Sec. Corp.Detection Control Sys. v. Colliers Tri-State Mgmt.Martinez v. Jerome Med., PLLCQuadracci v. KleinHill v. PauloseKarlsson v. Westchester Cnty. Health Care Corp.Samuels v. FordCaldera Holdings Ltd. v. Apollo Glob. Mgmt.Blue Seabreeze LLC v. Allied Telesis HoldingsMagid Setauket Assocs. v. Town of Brookhaven Bd. of Zoning AppealsAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. CamilleCedeno v. Able Health Care Serv.Am. Transit Ins. Co. v. SeguraSchmied v. City of N.Y.Denison v. 300 E. 57 St., LLCHNY Club Suites Owners Ass'n v. VassosAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. CespesdesItria Ventures LLC v. Provident BankJohn Doe v. City of New YorkSordoni Constr. Co. v. Chartis Ins. Co. of CanadaMalone v. EllnerMitchell v. N.Y.C.Furze v. StapenKim v. SantosWright v. LiaoAnderson v. SinghAm. Transit Ins. Co. v. ThomasNYCTL 2018-A Tr. v. Father Realty Corp.Wilmington Sav. Fund Soc'y v. OmarChain Sales Mktg., Inc. v. RoachDyer v. Amchem Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Econ. Alchemy LLC v. Byrne POH LLPShouldis v. StrangeVasquez v. City of N.Y.Lanza v. Am. Biltrite, Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Knopp v. RNG NAP Revocable Tr.Caceras v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalGov't Emps. Ins. Co. v. BMW of N. Am., LLCZylyftari v. GleasonMoonachi Inc. v. Aurora Loan Servs.Bessemer Tr. Co. v. HartMathias v. HaleTuohy v. Osprey Workshops, LLCGrace Carting Corp. v. City of N.Y.Latorre v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Groben v. Sacred Heart of Jesus Sch.Shemia v. E. Works LLCJimenez v. MXJOIn re ARoness v. City of New YorkSierra Club v. Dep't of Parks & Recreation of City of N.Y.390 Park Prop. LLC v. WI/BSREP III 390 Park LLCN.Y. State Office of Victim Servs. ex rel. Hernandez v. RodriguezDiaz v. City of N.Y.Brown v. PetitHanniford v CarrascoBasile v. Simon Props.Khan v. LismanBastone v. GaranNichols v. Livingston Cnty.Tompkins 183 LLC v. FrankelBerkowitz v. Kiop Meadowbrook L.P.McCormack v. D. Castillo TruckingBarbato v. 200 Park, L.P.Andreoli v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Thomas v. HalveyHogue v. Bd. of Educ. of City Sch. Dist. CGI Techs. & Solutions, Inc. v. N.Y.S. Office of Mental HealthG Family Holdings, LLC v. Washington-West 11th St. Owners Corp.Howell v. City of N.Y.Lam Pearl St. Hotel, LLC v. Golden Pearl Constr., LLCBush v. StanfordBlank v. PetrosyantsWorld Glob. Capital, LLC v. Sahara Rest. Corp.Kochan v. Louis G. Prumbs, M.D.Smith v. UddinCapacity Grp. of NY LLC v. DuniLileika v. Estate of DeRosaBarone v. Bausch & Lomb, Inc.Anderson v. SinghMcDermott v. McDermottEddy v. PersaudKhalique v. City of N.Y.Avila v. VVFJ Realty, LLCArdent Harmony Fund Inc. v. BarrickTrepel v. HodginsGilpin v. Mut. Redevelopment Houses, Inc.Sivanesan v. YBF LLCMajuc v. N.Y. Cnty. Dist. Attorney's OfficeMuniz v. Chimienti Realty Assocs., Inc.Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. v. SewerPhila. Indem. Ins. Co. v. Par Plumbing, Co.Allen v. Consol. Edison of N.Y., BH 520 W 175, LLCRivera v. Slade Indus.Cabral v. 229 W. 43RD St. Condo., Bre/Nyt, LLC.People v. SuncarPeople v. PortorealKalendarev v. Planet Wings Inc.Ciccone v. One W. 64th St.|People ex rel. Laukam v. KrossGulotta v. HartBrownstein v. WassermanNYCTL 1998-2 Tr. v. 70 Orchard LLCGerrity v. Gerard Taxi Inc.Brummer v. WeyBDJ Equities LLC v. Archimedean Sols. LLCLazar v. LorichMurphy v. Westchestrr One, LLCGarcia v. BarrowGarcia v. BatallaLiberty Mut. Ins. Co. v. OudkerkSlonim v. Altman Stage Lighting Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Bellstell 7 Park Ave. LLC v. Seven Park Ave. Corp.Am. Home Mortg. Acceptance Inc. v. LubontyBennett Capital Mgmt. v. AndersonDelmar v. Burger King Corp.Fabian v. 1356 St. Nicholas Realty LLCLanzilli v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Fernandez v. City of New York