Patent Trial and Appeal Board March 2020 casesYIN, Fenglin et al.Facebook, Inc.DYNAX CORPORATIONInternational Business Machines CorporationORACLE INTERNATIONAL CORPORATIONR. J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANYBartetzko, Anne et al.SOUND TECHNOLOGY INC.David M. Ogle et al.NORTHROP GRUMMAN SYSTEMS CORPORATIONWu, Margaret M. et al.Gindrat, Malko et al.Rita Parada et al.The Procter & Gamble CompanyScott Brown et al.James BongiornoVincent Rinaldi et al.Kelley, William A.BLUEBUSRivera, AdrianPaul W. AdamPrior, Gregory P. et al.TOMTOM TRAFFIC B.V. et al.QUALCOMM IncorporatedGeneral Electric CompanyArun Koormamtharayil et al.849,579 7 et al.Bin Zhang et al.Heffernan, John et al.Kazuhiro Mizude et al.Drexel, Claus-Peter et al.Wernikoff, DanielINTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONUnited Parcel Service of America, Inc.Alstom Renewable TechnologiesDouglas A. Bulleit et al.John D. CoatesWael Yared et al.9254865 et al.Wright, Robert J. et al.Raytheon CompanyNakada, Mark W. et al.LOCKHEED MARTIN CORPORATIONGiuseppe Capoia et al.William S. SuhrMasterCard International IncorporatedCARNEAL, James P. et al.DMK Deutsches Milchkontor GmbHApplied Materials, Inc.Brian F. Roberts et al.Facebook, Inc.Roche Diagnostics Operations, Inc.George Polson et al.Se-Kure Controls, Inc.Roeder, Ryan K. et al.Jørgen Hallundbæk et al.Eric Alden. Rumer et al.NEOPERL GMBHBeach et al. V. PadgettYuya Tanaka et al.Brigham Young UniversityAzfar Inayatullah et al.HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.Mestres, Xavier et al.John Evans' Sons, Inc.Junzhong LiangBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftFeronia Water, LLCSugarCRM Inc.Thomas W. HeeterTara Chand. SinghalIntersil Americas LLCMomin Mirza et al.Early Warning Services, LLCMarkus Krumme et al.Edward Livingston et al.Oracle International CorporationBLACK & DECKER INC.Global e-Ticket Exchange Ltd.Pakhchyan, EdwardLowe's Companies, Inc.Li, Ning et al.Avaya, Inc.Hamilton Sundstrand CorporationLyudmil Vladimirov. Antonov et al.MOTOROLA SOLUTIONS, INC.Yehuda BinderMicron Technology, Inc.GENENTECH, INC.Lenovo Enterprise Solutions (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Paul John. FergusonBruce Macher et al.Stanton GersonPaperBax, LLCNeal Patterson et al.Vaillancourt, Michael J. et al.Carr, Robert O. et al.Elanco US Inc.DePuy Synthes Products, Inc.Avaya, Inc.Sun, Yangyang et al.QIAGEN GmbHQuest Diagnostics Investments, Inc.Nyi Oo. Myo et al.Kabushiki Kaisha Kobe Seiko Sho (Kobe Steel, Ltd.)International Business Machines CorporationMATTEL, INC.Nishida, NorimasaAdest et al. V. Ledenev et al.Park, Kunsoo et al.Kumiko Ogino et al.Drevon, Nicolas et al.Wolf Peter. LudwigSchwan's Global Supply Chain, Inc.SUNCOKE TECHNOLOGY AND DEVELOPMENT LLC.Thompson, GarthBASF SEXie, Yuxuan et al.Brant CandeloreTRENCH AUSTRIA GMBHMedidata Solutions, Inc.CAREFUSION 303, INC.Tozzi, Christine Margaret.St. Jude Medical, Atrial Fibrillation Division, Inc.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.AUDI AGJames H. May et al.OnePatont Software Ltd.Andrew Francis. Page et al.Weibin Pan et al.Chinnappa, ShanmugamJain, KamalJoern Ihlenburg et al.DELTA ELECTRONICS, INC.CANTOR INDEX, LLCSingur, IgorIrwin O. Kennedy et al.Lutnick, Howard W. et al.Jung Hoon Lee et al.Angeliqueo E. Padilla et al.Tough Love Rings, LLCYates, James M.Unify GmbH & Co. KGMickey Iqbal et al.Motorola Mobility LLCSugarCRM Inc.Recce, Michael et al.ECKHARDT, Bartley J.Rosenblatt, Charles A. et al.Apple Inc.DePuy Synthes Products, Inc.Hirson, RonFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCMese, John C. et al.Kochevar, Peter D. et al.Nicholas R. Voelz et al.Warren YoungOCUSPECTO OYNami KhademhosseiniDantressangle, Patrick et al.Joseph M. Asher et al.Bassett, Douglas E. et al.Neeraj Bhatia et al.Simon Phillips et al.GETAC TECHNOLOGY CORPORATIONMarcus AnderssonJ¿r¿me Lagarde et al.Medidata Solutions, Inc.3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYMark D. WieczorekEndura Technologies LLCFedorov, Andrei G. et al.The Boeing CompanyChad Amborn et al.Chen et al. V. Furutani et al.Simon Butler et al.Noviello, Joseph C.DAN, ASIT et al.Adobe Inc,Sandholm, Tuomas W.MasterCard International IncorporatedMatti KoskinenHOLTEC INTERNATIONAL, INC.Cheng, Christopher Thomas. et al.HomeAway, com, Inc.Vijay K. PillaiElectronics and Telecommunications Research Institute et al.Kaskoun, Kenneth et al.AGONAFER, Dereje et al.THE BOEING COMPANYLee AmaitisWei Zhang et al.Sullivan, Joseph et al.LEVEL 3 COMMUNICATIONS, LLCBringuier, Anne Germaine. et al.PICCIONELLI, GREGORY A. et al.Amichai Sanderovich et al.Akira InoueYAZAKI CORPORATIONPirelli Tyre, S.p.A.Yazaki CorporationYehuda Binder et al.Capital One Financial CorporationSugarCRM Inc.SOCKET MOBILE, INC.Richard Lee. HartmanReuther, Phyllis et al.Eric Thelen et al.Knowles Electronics, LLCRamin Zanbaghi et al.Barnett Outdoors, LLCLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Unify GmbH & Co. KGPulse Technologies, Inc.Rajaram, Giridhar et al.Eric Liu et al.SMITHS MEDICAL ASD, INC.CAFFEINATION CREDIT MANAGER (SERIES 1 OF CAFFINATION SERIES,LLCStefano Corazza et al.Nathan John. Berry Ann et al.Samuel Billot et al.Guido Hiertz et al.James BongiornoMUSC Foundation for Research DevelopmentPaPa Squat Port A Pot, LLCPankaj V. KaloreTECRES S.P.A.Rambus Inc.HAMILTON, RYAN et al.Medtronic, Inc.O'Neill, Daniel D.Ivory Wellman. Knipfer et al.Palazzolo, Christopher K. et al.Theresa Chang et al.EXCALIBUR IP, LLCSUMITOMO HEAVY INDUSTRIES, LTD.SHINCRON CO., LTD.Francisco Maturana et al.Maria DalkoMichael Grass et al.Apple Inc.Carl Zeiss Microscopy GmbHZhihua Guo et al.Richard J. Lukes et al.Hideki Takehara et al.SATURN LICENSING LLCKevin Clare. EichhorstElanco Tiergesundheit AGEvgeniy Bart et al.Jason M. Bush et al.Nathan W. Levin et al.Sony CorporationVisa International Service AssociationShoot-A-Way, Inc.Level 3 Communications, LLCDeshpande, Ajay Ashok. et al.Gracenote, Inc.Luc Boivin et al.FRANCE CHIRURGIE INSTRUMENTATION SAS (FCI)Hiromitsu Tamura et al.Katscher, Ulrich et al.Goldman, Steven A. et al.Corning IncorporatedFord Global Technologies, LLCLutnick, Howard W. et al.Paul D'Arcy et al.Buchmann, DanielWHIRLPOOL CORPORATIONDePuy Synthes Products, Inc.Strand, Ross et al.ARMSTRONG WORLD INDUSTRIES, INC.Byung Hoon Ko et al.Unify GmbH & Co. KGRamerth, Brent D. et al.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCGIGA SOLAR MATERIALS CORP.David Coblentz et al.General Electric CompanyMyine Electronics, Inc.James C. JohnsonDriscoll, James R. et al.Nokia Technologies Oy1QB INFORMATION TECHNOLOGIES INC.Shimpi, Anirudha et al.Dennis Bushmitch et al.Greenstein, MarkGodewyn, Charles et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONImmersion CorporationINTUIT INC.MyWorld, Inc.Parkdale, IncorporatedBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftPirelli Tyre, S.p.A.Visa International Service AssociationNakano, Masatoshi et al.SONY CORPORATIONBabak Robert. Shakib et al.LUTNICK, Howard W.Michael R. AboumradCarole Justine et al.Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCSAS Institute Inc.Sachit KamatTHE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLONMasterCard International IncorporatedAlan HoweWoods, RosannDavid Colvin et al.Dwayne B. Mercredi et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Poletti, Steven J. et al.ATLAS COPCO AIRPOWER, N.V.Bin Yin et al.CFPH, LLCIsabelle Debecker et al.Kazmi, Muhammad Ali. et al.Risto H. Jokinen et al.Apple Inc.Koninklijke Philips N.V.Univation Technologies, LLCCarrier CorporationGanesh Balakrishnan et al.Jia Li et al.Karlsruher Institut f¿r TechnologieGalamba, Steven M.Lenovo Enterprise Solutions (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.eBay Inc.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Crawford, James Thomas. et al.Keeling, Peter et al.Barry Rimler et al.International Business Machines CorporationWilliam S. Bailey et al.Atul Asthana et al.Nico CorporationHELLER, Jonathan et al.LG CHEM, LTD.UNITY OPTO TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. (ASSIGNEE) et al.Milliken & CompanyGeorges-Henri MollAmaitis, Lee M. et al.PayWithMyBank, Inc.Ivan E. Brown et al.ResMed LimitedSchool OutfittersUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONDaqing WuWilliam J. Michie et al.Yair Goldfinger et al.David Gerard. LedetAkshay Mathur et al.Statoil Petroleum ASMichael A. RacusinPATHEON SOFTGELS INC.Colar, Gerald D. et al.RIEDL, Bernd et al.Ramesh Chandrasekharan et al.CHEN, YING et al.KIM, Eun-Yong et al.OPOWER, INC.Keith C. Hullfish et al.Jonathon P. Baker et al.Consumer Safety Technology, LLCSteingart, Robert et al.Priya N. Vaidya et al.Chan, Simon Siu-Sing. et al.Yilmaz, Esat et al.Boyer, Stephen Wayne. et al.Joris Vermeesch et al.Chevron Phillips Chemical Company, LPMichael Prencipe et al.Mondo Jacobs et al.Hongwei Liu et al.International Business Machines CorporationSonia Reed et al.Sheldon Chang et al.AKTANA, INC.Zhijun Cai et al.Andre' Roger et al.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONJochen Peters et al.Hadi ElzeinBlair, Edward Tilden. et al.Salm, Jacob Andrew. et al.Eric Lee et al.David Selinger et al.Anant Nambiar et al.General Electric CompanyVahit Hakan. HacigumusChristopher Roderick. Olson et al.Toby James. Morris et al.BEST, JOHN et al.Aldo P. Della Sera et al.Sony Corporation et al.Dow Global Technologies LLCHeckenlively, StevenLYCORED LTD.Koninklijke Douwe Egberts B.V.Akutagawa, KeizoTara Chand. SinghalStephanie Von Der Fecht et al.Christopher ScheibAlexander, Daniel Lewis. et al.International Business Machines CorporationTsu-I Wang et al.MasterCard International IncorporatedMaloney, Venda Porter. et al.iBoss, Inc.Reza B'Far et al.Facebook, Inc.Apple Inc.SONY CORPORATIONMedtronic, Inc.Volterra Semiconductor LLCHewlett Packard Enterprise Development LPHoward W. LutnickJens Werner et al.Earley, MatthewDaniel F. Gruhl et al.Haumont, Serge Rene. et al.Tocagen Inc.Anthony Edward. Dzikowicz et al.WODA, Juliana Megan. et al.Cardiac Pacemakers, Inc.The Boeing CompanyGary W. King et al.AT & T Intellectual Property I, L.P.Yehuda BinderSTRATOVAN CORPORATIONSpan-America Medical Systems, Inc.Pedersen, BradKristina KingCARL ZEISS SMT GMBHBATMARK LIMITEDWORKSHARE, LTD.MasterCard International IncorporatedNuwan Senaratna et al.PIERBURG PUMP TECHNOLOGY GMBHUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONThe Nielsen Company (US), LLCAdam J. Overton et al.Hall, William E. et al.Texas Instruments IncorporatedMartin Feuersaenger et al.David L. JuzswikMelissa Ann. Seely et al.Craig Langdon. ReinhartFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCStefan Sch¿tzlRehrig Pacific CompanyFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCHUAWEI DEVICE CO., LTD.ORTOMA ABGeorge A. Castineiras et al.Edelson, AriGarcia, Louie Daniel. et al.Milwaukee Electric Tool CorporationNISSIN FOODS HOLDINGS CO., LTD.Patrice Guillaume et al.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCKING SHOW GAMES, INC.Augusta University Research Institute, Inc.Gordon PooleMichelle FisherAnton Aleksandrov et al.Michael Stefan. Skurich et al.Mao, Yinian et al.HALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.Finkbeiner, GerhardJelmer Jongsma et al.PAYIT, LLCJha, Vikas et al.Christopher Joseph. Lochner et al.Hospital Housekeeping Systems, LLC.Kazunori MototsuBartko, Peter et al.Zhu Wen et al.Level 3 Communications, LLCMerlin Technology, Inc.Lutnick, Howard W. et al.Gang Ji et al.Chen, Gao et al.iHEARTMEDIA MANAGEMENT SERVICES, INC.Pieter Van Zee et al.My World, Inc.Wickham, HenryOVONIC BATTERY COMPANY, INC.ATG R&D LIMITEDX Development LLCJoey Ray. Grover et al.Josh C. Swenson et al.Arie Tzvieli et al.Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.UNITY OPTO TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. (ASSIGNEE) et al.SanDisk Enterprise IP LLCYoshinori IshikawaKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.SonicWALL, Inc.Bamberg, Joachim et al.Joaquin Torsiello et al.Endologix, Inc.Robert Bosch GmbHBhandari, Muthulakshmi et al.Krishna Vitaldevara et al.Jorge A. Arroyo et al.University of DundeeLaderer, Tonya et al.Oleg Serebryanov et al.Xtera Communications, Inc.SK GLOBAL CHEMICAL CO., LTD. et al.Realtek Semiconductor Corp.Andries Don. Sebastian et al.Veronique Chevalier et al.Ligand Pharmaceuticals, Inc.Deutsche Börse AGCirrus Logic, Inc.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCOvard, LLCDavid Edward. Braginsky et al.Xiaohong Nina. Duan et al.UNITY OPTO TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD. et al.Zhang, Wenhao et al.Rick A. Hamilton et al.BANSAL, SHEFALI et al.Mark S. Knighton et al.Adam Joseph. Elliott et al.BUY IT MOBILITY NETWORKS INC.Tihamer Orban et al.Alcatel LucentLewis, Donald C.Wolter, James F.Philip HewinsonXianghua Wang et al.Beaumier, Francois et al.Unify GmbH & Co. KGCantor Index, LLCChristoph M. Greiner et al.Stephanie PaskoYasuo Fujishima et al.TOSHIBA MITSUBISHI-ELECTRIC INDUSTRIAL SYSTEMS CORPORATION et al.Tower Semiconductor Ltd.Michael A. Meltsner et al.COLGATE-PALMOLIVE COMPANY et al.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCAbbVie Deutschland GmbH & Co., KGJames R. Driscoll et al.Glen David. Wordekemper et al.LEVEL 3 COMMUNICATIONS, LLCPadam Kafle et al.Perego, Gabriele et al.Nico CorporationAnderson, Noel Wayne.Patricia Chan et al.Jun Okabe et al.United Technologies CorporationSiemens AktiengesellschaftTogawa, NaoyukiMACHINES CORPORATION, INTERNATIONAL BUSINESSLECO CorporationYoung, Kenneth L.Marioff Corporation OyImagination Technologies LimitedMitsubishi Electric CorporationFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCSang-Kyu CHOI et al.Lutnick, Howard W. et al.Saudi Arabian Oil CompanyITAP MENU, LLCSinghal, Tara Chand.Doxey, RyanREINHART, PeterAdobe Inc.Ziv Wolkowicki et al.Massimo Pignatelli et al.International Business Machines CorporationFUNG, HENRY H. et al.AVIGILON ANALYTICS CORPORATIONZaffir A. ChaudhryIncept, LLCHanz, Ezra et al.Carl BrightAT&T INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY I, LPHadley, Kevin et al.Daniel John. DilorenzoNicolas Dupuis et al.Martin, Douglas Raymond. et al.Gatto-Weising, Gina M.C-Scape Consulting CorporationTatsuya Shouji et al.Henri Paradowski et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.EBAY INC.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCLennart Bjorkesten et al.James R. Bowes et al.Valton, Julien et al.MuSigma Business Solutions Pvt. Ltd.Karl Storz Imaging, Inc.Adam Steel et al.Larnholm, Per-Reidar et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Rubin, Alexander M. et al.DENDEL, Joseph W. et al.Arash Mofakhami et al.SanDisk Enterprise IP LLCHONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.LIFELINE SCIENTIFIC, INC.Facebook, Inc.Rontal, MichaelChikashi YajimaSheng FangKurt A. Burkhart et al.Ali Ashour. Al-JafarWisconsin Alumni Research FoundationShahriar Khosravani et al.George L. Diaz-SantiagoCree, Inc.Bruno, Nicolas et al.HELLMAN, ROBERT B. et al.Novartis AGFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCPATHEON SOFTGELS INC.Anatoly Starostin et al.Robert C. SteinerHEWLETT PACKARD ENTERPRISE DEVELOPMENT LPBrent Mccurdy et al.ROGERS CORPORATIONShashank Potnis et al.Louis M. Spoto et al.Robert E. SmithSAP AGNikolaj HviidLoren Veltrop et al.Dominik StefanowiczInternational Business Machines CorporationFREEPORT MINERALS CORPORATIONMichael Edward. Badding et al.GYRODATA, IncorporatedRoeger-Goepfert, Cornelia et al.GLOBAL PAYMENTS INC.Anthony Mark. Phillips et al.Krig, Scott et al.BOONE, JAMES HUNTER. et al.Halliburton Energy Services, Inc.ULMERT MED FIRMA FLOCELL, HansBlue Planet, Ltd.Surendra KhambeteRolf Madsen et al.Garcia, Frederic et al.Simon J. Godsill et al.Wollner, Mark R. et al.Nabil LawandyKouji Oono et al.Cranfill, Elizabeth Caroline Furches. et al.Dugan, Benedict R. et al.Integral Development Inc.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONCox Media Group Digital Development, Inc.Keller, Peter et al.LESCH, Hanna P. et al.Level 3 Communications, LLCFARO Technologies, Inc.Robert Bosch GmbHCirrus Logic, Inc.Unify GmbH & Co. KGMIPS Tech, LLC.Keiichi Chono et al.Micro-Hybrid Electronic GmbHSmythe, Robert Michael. et al.Claude Willemin et al.AHLSTROM-MUNKSJ¿ OYJItay ShermanHeiko RoehmJohn P. Matonick et al.Yulun Wang et al.Jun Yang et al.Ciena CorporationPREDICTION BIOSCIENCES S.A.S.Graziano Mirichigni et al.Derwin G. Hawley et al.Will John. TempleJennifer L. Sample et al.Denis Gagnon et al.INOUE, KozoDidier Attaix et al.Ezell, DanielNeturen Co., LTD.VlZn Energy Systems, Inc.CABOT CORPORATIONJaycobs, Rich et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONVisa International Service AssociationGrieder, Ralph et al.Debasish Banerjee et al.Arslan, Haydar et al.Will John. TempleROGERS, BRANDON JEREMY. et al.International Business Machines CorporationCisco Technology, Inc.Len CechCompton, David L. et al.Richard Scott. Robinson et al.John J. Roach et al.Robert A. Pyles et al.Arthur Lansky Levine & Associates, Inc. d/b/a Lansky SharpenersMark Joseph. MathisLee Amaitis et al.Werner Laber et al.Hohensee, Reinhard et al.RENISHAW (IRELAND) LIMITEDThe Goodyear Tire & Rubber CompanyKIM, Phillip et al.Wang, XiandongBORTOLIN KEMO S.P.A.ALSTOM Technology LtdUlrich BischofbergerShih-Hsien HuBell Helicopter Textron Inc.Chen, Lin et al.FIDE PBCRichard A. Vaughan et al.Chen-Shan Chin et al.Li, Hongqi et al.LABORATOIRES URGOChad Evert. Esselink et al.Biju Jacob et al.Rohr, Inc.Jean KrutmannMDX Medical, Inc.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.¿ssur hfSORKIN, Felix L.Greenspan, David L. et al.Zuck, James C. et al.Yassa, FathyStasiewicz, Paul H. et al.Monika Gupta et al.Storm, Brian F.Javier Palomar-Moreno et al.Jeffrey Daniel. Hillman et al.Nipun MathurBASF SERoytman, Anatoly et al.Winters, Kelly et al.Takuro Watanabe et al.TRANS UNION LLCMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCSK GLOBAL CHEMICAL CO., LTD. et al.
