Patent Trial and Appeal Board April 2020 casesSai ShankarApplied Materials, Inc.Wallace, Darius et al.Curtis Ling et al.Ball Horticultural CompanyLindoff, Bengt et al.COHEN GANOR, Shlomo et al.McDonald Cassidy, PamelaVidhyalakshmi Karthikeyan et al.COMMONWEALTH SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH ORGANISATION et al.Genzyme CorporationRoald van BorselenRobin Wallace. GloverSundaresan, NeelakantanLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY L.P.Xencor, Inc.RENISHAW PLCHoward W. Lutnick et al.Infineon Technologies Austria AGKIC LLCAvago Technologies International Sales Pte, LimitedMayfield PenningtonMuriel Cohen et al.ARKEMA FRANCEJohn Weldon. Nicholson et al.Hess, Thomas et al.NIKE, INC.International Business Machines CorporationINTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONUltimems, Inc.Parris, Eric et al.LEVEL 3 COMMUNICATIONS, LLCWESTINGHOUSE ELECTRIC COMPANY LLCOridion Medical 1987 Ltd.Covidien LPFortney, Paul Matthew. et al.den Hoed, RobertAgee, Richard et al.HEGNA, STIAN et al.Rational AktiengesellschaftRyther, Robert J. et al.Zachary L. Helgeson et al.Xing Yi et al.Kenneth R. Davenport et al.Philip Scott. LyrenUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftCureVac AGArnold Wesley. CrossSonoco Development, Inc.Zietchick Research Institute, LLCSven DoblerChicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.Intercontinental Exchange Holdings, Inc.Alcatel-Lucent USA Inc.Dieter Homoelle et al.Michael A. BriereErik Eidt et al.Bj¿rn Schurad et al.Michel Engelhardt et al.5280 Prosthetics LLCNOBEL BIOCARE SERVICES AGDerek S. Lam et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONAmazon Technologies, Inc.Clifford J. Weber et al.Givaudan S.A.Cray Inc.Albano, Fabio et al.Unhoch, Michael J. et al.Petersson, Sture et al.McLaughlin, MichaelMOORE, Jeremy et al.INTRA-CELLULAR THERAPIES, INC.Vidhyalakshmi Karthikeyan et al.AKTIEBOLAGET SKFUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONUnited Technologies CorporationThe Boeing CompanyKothe, Kyle William. et al.Timothy J. Throndson et al.Ford Global Technologies, LLCATLASSIAN PTY LTDOFS Fitel, LLCMERCK PATENT GMBHAC (Macao Commercial Offshore) LimitedCOVIDIEN LPCovestro LLCVALVE CORPORATIONFord Global Technologies, LLCGaston Mazzaferro et al.MIYAZAKI, HiroakiRobert TerbrueggenRavi Chakravarthi. Kumar et al.BTD Wood Powder Coating, Inc.Caldwell, John Ryan.HALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.Jaguar Land Rover LimitedLeto R&D CorporationMarc Aoun et al.SIEMENS INDUSTRY, INC.Reveel Inc.Nvidia CorporationMolz, Ronald J. et al.Jill Fain. Lehman et al.Maoni Stephens et al.Robert Bosch GmbHThe Johns Hopkins UniversityRafael Wiemker et al.Apple Inc.United Technologies CorporationGeng Zhu et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONTimothy M. Martin et al.Al Chakra et al.Marie-Claude Bezenger et al.Guardian Glass, LLCBigLever Software, Inc.Hewlett-Packard Development Company, L.P.Anurup Singhal et al.FUJIFILM CORPORATIONTodd Burke et al.CommScope Connectivity Belgium BVBA et al.James J. Radigan et al.Noven Pharmaceuticals, Inc.Delphi Technologies, Inc.Judd, Thomas D. et al.Adobe Inc.Sysmex CorporationHalo International Sezc LtdKapur, Shashi et al.Frank Laske et al.Lawrence ShermanJulie Nicole. Hamblin et al.Inteva Products, LLCEvgeny Beskrovny et al.Kyojiro KanekoOliver Lei et al.Wu, Lih-Chiu et al.Minson, JohnContinental Reifen Deutschland GmbHSteven Glenn. Keener et al.Poole, John et al.PPG Industries Ohio, Inc.WEBASTO SEDale W. MalikKibbar, Amir et al.Cyberonics, Inc.Spils, Gregory R. et al.FLUOR TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONPourfallah, Stacy et al.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCBrulotte, KristopherMasahiko Sekimoto et al.James E. Ross JR. et al.Thierry Huque et al.Akeson, Mark A. et al.Voesh CorporationNaresh Sundaram. Iyer et al.Dearing, Stephen M. et al.D. Swarovski KGLex Machina, Inc.St. Jude Medical, Atrial Fibrillation Division, Inc.5280 PROSTHETICS LLCWitham, Cole et al.HOLMES V. Gopinath et al. V. ArlingBaranovski, Viatcheslav E. et al.SUNDERMEYER, Ken et al.HOLMES V. Gopinath et al. V. ArlingEftekhari, Amir et al.Eric Randell. SchmidtSARONG SOCIETA' PER AZIONISampson, Jeffrey R. et al.SEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCFacebook, Inc.Clifford J. Weber et al.Manickababu Muthugopalakrishnan et al.Dean L. Knuth et al.THE TORO COMPANYComcast Cable Communications LLCARISTA NETWORKS, INC.Adobe Inc.GUNARATNAM, Vasanthan et al.Scott A. KrigSriram Sankar et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONDavid Hamilton et al.Friedman, Arie et al.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONSamuel Lessin et al.G. WhitemanecoATM, LLCOptcapital, LLCSYMBOL TECHNOLOGIES, INC.Corning Incorporated et al.Tufts UniversityMarais, Leroux et al.Nicira, Inc.BASF SEC. R. Bard, Inc.Pharmaceutical Manufacturing Research Services, Inc.Schuhmann, Michael et al.Silberg, Barry Neil.Mani, Senthil Kumar. et al.Mark Edward. Harriman et al.CORELOGIC SOLUTIONS, LLCUnited Technologies CorporationTELECOM ITALIA S.p.A.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.Angela Richards. JonesSteven Christian et al.DALI SYSTEMS CO. LTD.Schirmer, Andrew L. et al.Atieva, Inc.Song LiFacebook, Inc.Noha Elmouelhi et al.Timothy D. Sellis et al.Zelton Dave. Sharp et al.Sanders, Dr. Brett et al.Smith, Gregory Paul.Facebook, Inc.COOPERVISION INTERNATIONAL HOLDING COMPANY, LPDavid K. RobertsAndre Ehrhardt et al.Citrix Systems, Inc.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.Awadh B. PandeyCreamer, Thomas E. et al.Heinz Vogt et al.Coupons.com incorporatedMorris, James T.Level 3 Communications, LLCHala Farouk. El-Hmayssi et al.3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYAirWatch LLCPPG Industries Ohio, Inc.Stehle, Gerhard et al.Google LLCMy World, Inc.Taya Kotlyar et al.Valinge Innovation ABMISONIX, INCORPORATEDMark Leroy. Walker et al.The Boeing CompanyDENSO CORPORATION2266170 Ontario Inc.Meritor Heavy Vehicle Braking Systems (UK) LimitedFord Global Technologies, LLCAsif Zia et al.VIACOM INTERNATIONAL INC.J. Landon. Gilkey et al.Vasylyev, SergiyLee Amaitis et al.Lenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Takeshima, Shigeki et al.Senzaki, Kenta et al.PGS Geophysical ASBartko, Peter et al.Kelly, DanielLeif Hakman et al.CenturyLink Intellectual Property LLCFenton, Patrick C.Kidde Graviner LimitedAmitabh SethVidhyalakshmi Karthikeyan et al.PROFOUND MEDICAL INC.Facebook, Inc.SRI InternationalHarmannus Vandermolen et al.KSB AKTIENGESELLSCHAFTWolfgang Steinle et al.KEPPEL OFFSHORE & MARINE TECHNOLOGY CENTRE PTE LTDNiall Joseph. Dalton et al.Lyubomir Georgiev. Zagorchev et al.Rolls-Royce CorporationMcJames, William Charles.JX Nippon Mining & Metals CorporationBoby, Dylan T. et al.Billstein, Stephen Anthony. et al.THE BOEING COMPANYBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftTuval, Yossi et al.General Electric CompanySweeney, ShaunGroupon, Inc.SAP SEErnest James. Dale et al.Emory UniversityCharles R. Hill et al.SUKRUANGSAP, ApichatROCKWELL AUTOMATION TECHNOLOGIES, INC.Massachusetts Institute of TechnologyUdo Ausserlechner et al.VESTAS WIND SYSTEMS A/SMasterCard International IncorporatedAlexander Schoenen et al.Schaaf, HansgeorgYuichi KinoshitaSULZER METAPLAS GMBHVMware, Inc.Drance, Kaiann et al.BATTELLE MEMORIAL INSTITUTEChicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.NetSuite Inc.Horizon Systems, Inc.Mark A. Hayes et al.Raghavan RajagopalanCatherine Lin-HendelScott Alfred. Rogers et al.GW Pharma Limited et al.CureVac GmbHAl-Ali, AmmarRobert C. Brooks et al.AirWatch LLCMUSCO FAMILY OLIVE COMPANYUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONUnited Technologies CorporationShadi E. Albouyeh et al.Wearwell, Inc.Panagiota Iliopoulou et al.LG Display Co., Ltd.Mitchell R. SwartzYun, Anthony Joonkyoo. et al.van de Burgt, Stephanus Pieter. et al.CFPH, LLCArno Refke et al.Joanna Ng et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.David Huelke et al.Daly, Curtis N.MIDIGATOR LLCADOBE INC.ArcelorMittalXEP, INC.Evgeny Beskrovny et al.Mattel, Inc.Sense Labs, Inc.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCSEMICONDUCTOR COMPONENTS INDUSTRIES, LLCLinkedln CorporationJorgensen, EricGriffin, Richard A.Ralf Keller et al.Cerner Innovation, Inc.Meola, Ralph M. et al.Hoffman, Daniel D. et al.Kuhmann, Karl et al.Yossef Brandes et al.United Technologies CorporationThin Film Electronics ASATimothy A. Dennis et al.Aitken, Stuart et al.Ultimems, Inc.Feinstein, Jeffrey A. et al.Tatsuhiro Sato et al.Satzger, Wilhelm et al.Carl W. Riley et al.Siemens Healthcare Diagnostics Products GmbHUniversity of Utah Research FoundationBal Seal Engineering, Inc.Kimberly DunwoodyXencor, Inc.Rajeev Jayavant et al.Elsevier, Inc.Sony CorporationAmazon Technologies, Inc.SANDVIK INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY ABNur, Israel et al.Saudi Arabian Oil CompanyGutierrez, Richard et al.AutoAlert, LLCDavid M. Masarik et al.ONCURA PARTNERS DIAGNOSTICS, LLCMotorola Mobility LLCTHE REGENTS OF THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIATHESMAN, DEBRAJiaming Zhang et al.Ford Global Technologies, LLCCallahan Cellular L.L.C.Imagination Technologies LimitedDora Ricci et al.Benjamin T. WallachVAANANEN, Mikkoadidas AGMontgomery, Scott et al.Lumenis Ltd.Arthur Rogers et al.Seshadri Sundaram et al.ALFRED MILLER CONTRACTING COMPANY et al.James H. Laros et al.Vidhyalakshmi Karthikeyan et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Google Inc.Raytheon CompanyShimano Inc.Ginsberg, Philip M. et al.Tieh-Chiang Wu et al.CFPH, LLCHoneywell International Inc.INTUIT INC.Hall, JanThomas J. Gilg et al.David Owen. WehmeyerMehmet Ersin. YumerSeonil Yu et al.Novartis AGPAUL WURTH S.A.Sarada MohapatraAcquisio Inc.BIO-RAD LABORATORIES, INC.Shuster, Gary Stephen.BMC SOFTWARE, INC.James J. ZenniClive P. Bosnyak et al.Thales Canada Inc.Waldron, Michel Simon.Oracle International CorporationWalter Dees et al.Biomet Sports Medicine, LLCXencor, Inc.SHELL OIL COMPANYLee, Eugene M.Ethicon Endo-Surgery, LLCEdelson, AriEngip LLCAPPLE INC.Ping Zhang et al.Erdogan, Ozgun Ali. et al.United Technologies CorporationThomas MeyerMACRONIX INTERNATIONAL CO., LTD.The Boeing CompanyMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCFacebook, Inc.Karl Storz Imaging, Inc.Andries Don. Sebastian et al.SCHWEINFURTH, RalfVisa International Service AssociationKoji MurayamaThe Procter & Gamble CompanyRogers, Timothy A. et al.Gosselin, Daniel Albert. et al.Adden, Nina et al.Mirlay, Ram Srikanth.Wincor Nixdorf International GmbHMedtronic, Inc.Christophe Chevance et al.Rosenblatt, Michael et al.Pandit, Purvin Bibhas. et al.Xin Feng et al.Adobe Inc.SANOFI PASTEUR LIMITED et al.Evonik CorporationLevel 3 Communications, LLCGeneral Electric CompanyKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONSAMSUNG ELECTRONICS COMPANY, LTD.HALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.BLACKBERRY LIMITEDFuturewei Technologies, Inc.Dipanjan Sen et al.Jayant Kotalwar et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Ricardo Ehrenpfordt et al.DEBREGEAS ET ASSOCIES PHARMASanders, Dewayne E.Lutnick, Howard W. et al.Altaimano, Inc.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.John Channing. BousfieldLeBlond, Nicolas et al.Nahi HalmanneVideo IncorporatedOkuniewicz, Douglas M.Steven C. Goss et al.Robert Baldemair et al.HOLZER, AsherReceptor Logic, Inc.Daniel Morris et al.CONVATEC TECHNOLOGIES INC.Singhal, Tara Chand.Tilo Poth et al.Colleen M. Kavanagh et al.SmithGroupJJR, Inc.Perego, GabrieleHoneywell International Inc.Saudi Arabian Oil CompanyFacebook, Inc.QUALCOMM IncorporatedPhilipp Stoessel et al.Sengun, Mehmet Z. et al.Avaya Inc.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCPhillips, HeatherYAZAKI CORPORATIONAmazon Technologies, Inc.Level 3 Communications, LLCFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Hamilton Sundstrand CorporationInternational Business Machines CorporationHamilton Sundstrand CorporationLander, KirtPiccionielli, Gregory A.Microsoft CorporationNibaldo C. Inestrosa et al.William A. NazaretDamola, Ayodele et al.Julie LernerMAGNA ELECTRONICS INC.Elias Sardonis et al.Integrated Systems Excellence CorporationBurroughs, Susannette et al.Alex Stenzler et al.Versata Development Group, Inc.VISA INTERNATIONAL SERVICE ASSOCIATIONAhmed H. El-Mahdy et al.Karanbir Singh et al.Ryan James. Goss et al.Hoff, Vincent et al.RADHAKRISHNAN, Arun et al.HERBSOMMER, Juan A. et al.Valeant Pharmaceuticals International, Inc.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCJean Christophe. LeMAX OUT GOLF, LLC et al.COOLEY, BRADFORD et al.CommScope Technologies LLCSitePro, Inc.Blum, KennethTrane International Inc.Platzer, Andrew Emilio. et al.International Business Machines CorporationSerbin, Vitaly et al.MASTERCARD INTERNATIONAL INCORPORATEDJamie AbrahamsonKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V. et al.Avaya Inc.Ye-Kui Wang et al.FORTRESS STABILIZATION SYSTEMSLee J. Monsrud et al.AVANTOR PERFORMANCE MATERIALS, LLCAnthony Sgroi et al.Axioma, Inc.SONY MOBILE COMMUNICATIONS INC.Albert D'Alisa et al.Sony CorporationRESEARCH DEVELOPMENT FOUNDATIONNICA, Anisoara et al.Lee, JuifengFlockhart, Andrew D. et al.Al Chakra et al.COUTURE, Pierre et al.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.BOSTON SCIENTIFIC SCIMED, INC.Mitsubishi Shindoh Co, Ltd.Healionics CorporationShuichi Yasuda et al.Covidien LPCrowley, RichardBlack Hills IP Holdings, LLCUnited Technologies CorporationKiciman, Emre Mehmet. et al.Hada, Hiroyuki et al.3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYStrock, Christopher W. et al.Cree, Inc.Adobe Inc.PRECISION PLANTING LLCDumant, Bruno et al.MASTERCARD INTERNATIONAL INCORPORATEDEin-Gal, MosheRohde, Harald et al.CNH Industrial Canada, Ltd.John A. ChewoianErnest James. Dale et al.Saturn Licensing LLCChad FriehaufGundel, Douglas B.Brian Blank et al.MX Technologies, Inc.National University of Ireland GalwaySTOXX Ltd.Kohn, Jeffrey1910852 Ontario Inc.MELTON, Hayden Paul.Kun Liu et al.Murata Manufacturing Co., Ltd.Rune Fisker et al.MOTOROLA MOBILITY LLCDePuy Mitek, LLCGeorgetown UniversityNIKE, INC.GOJO Industries, Inc.International Business Machines CorporationOracle International CorporationTribune Broadcasting Company, LLCWilliam P. Clinton et al.Koji Sakahashi et al.Kouno, Yoshihiro et al.Matthew Robert. Teskey et al.SABIC Global Technologies B.V.CCDI COMPOSITES, INC.Lethin, Douglas T.Ehud (Udi) DaonTarkeshwar Chandrakant. PatilJackson, Markus Wayne.Thomas Spankowski et al.HITACHI CHEMICAL COMPANY, LTD.Taylor, Mary Theresa. et al.Laurent, Mathilde et al.Bruner, ErwinTelefonaktiebolaget L M Ericsson (publ)HANGAR CO., LTD.Younghak Oh et al.Citrix Systems, Inc.Michael E. Globe et al.Imagination Technologies LimitedGoogle Inc.Seahorse BioscienceKarl Storz GmbH & Co. KG et al.Toru Aihara et al.The Board of Regents of the University of Texas SystemSK Planet Co., Ltd.Leeds, Douglas D. et al.Hill-Rom Services, Inc.Steven A. Sell et al.Anderson Copper and Brass Company LLC d/b/a Anderson FittingsDavid Rondeau et al.Fei Zhou et al.SPLUNK, Inc.Allstate Insurance CompanyMONSHEIMER, Sylvia et al.Ford Global Technologies, LLCLynam, Joe M. et al.SAHA, SubhasisCELLECTISSugarCRM Inc.THE CHEMOURS COMPANY FC LLCWEZAG GmbH WerkzeugfabrikFathy YassaO'Brien, John-Allen et al.CANON KABUSHIKI KAISHAKarl L. Hasel et al.EKOS CORPORATIONInternational Business Machines CorporationInternational Business Machines CorporationFacebook, Inc.GPCP IP Holdings LLCGeorges-Henri MollHill-Rom Services, Inc.Dolby Laboratories Licensing CorporationAcxiom CorporationDantressangle, Patrick et al.Michael Edward. Hogard et al.MasterCard International IncorporatedWU, PETER et al.THE BOEING COMPANYORCAM TECHNOLOGIES LTD.Stephane H. MaesGENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANYMasahiro Aoshima et al.PRYSMIAN S.P.A.CPAP COMFORT COVER, LLCSYRAL BELGIUM NVTelefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (publ)8523926 et al.Richard LangKarl Storz Imaging, Inc.Angela Anh. Doan et al.Michael Patrick. Schneider et al.Diane C. Salmon et al.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONOuimet, Kenneth J. et al.Ford Global Technologies, LLCKatch, LLCLETHIN, Douglas T.Linear Technology LLCCardiac Pacemakers, Inc.Tobias Mann et al.Rami Nachab¿ et al.Michel, KennethIlan SadehLe Bemadjiel DjerassemJohn R. Bass et al.Chicago Mercantile Exchange, Inc.
