Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York January 1998 casesMatter of ShubaMassaro v. New York City Employees Ret. SysIn re the Estate of Yao You-XinPeople v. StrongLloyd v. McGrathWilson v. Hartford Accident and Indemnity Co.Cohen v. CallowayStern v. Ofori-OkaiZeltser v. BeckerMatter of JosephNewton v. NewtonFoster v. New Berlin Central School DistrictSupplement of Pompano Realty v. Tops MarketsManning v. Ardsley Union Free School DistNieves v. Union Hospital of the BronxPeople v. EdmondsPeople v. BreazielPeople v. AndersonMatter of McKayPeople v. BrownPeople v. RamsammyKuppersmith v. DowlingPeople v. IsmailMatter of Minchak v. McCallRotterdam Square v. Sear-Brown Assocs., P.CPiraeus Jewelry, Inc. v. Interested Underwriters at Lloyd'sRivera v. VieraDella Villa v. ConstantinoCohn-Frankel v. United Syn., Conser. JudaismMatter of Murolo v. SafirMatter of Machukas v. WagnerPeople v. CrisanoMatter of SilvermanDoe v. Commission on Judicial ConductPeople v. GunnPeople v. HowardKelly v. NEC Technologies, Inc.Protter v. Nathan's Famous SystemsPeople v. PowellPeople v. TurnerPeople v. HurdPeople v. GreavesPeople v. RemondPeople v. WashingtonMatter of Hudson Comm. Coalition v. RestianoMatter of Starchana BPeople v. RichardPeople v. GarciaPeople v. Phillips3777 Independence Corp. v. SternbergPeople v. WashingtonTrustco Bank, National Assoc. v. LabriolaZgoba v. Easy Shopping Corp.Hand v. Kenyon KenyonPeople v. EmilianoPeople v. HollidayPeople v. WardPeople v. PowellPeople v. KellerBodouva v. RossMatter of Pure Air Water v. DavidsenMatter of Barron v. Town of EsopusBragar v. BragarAEC Building Associates v. CrystalLevine Sons v. Physicians' Reciprocal InsPeople v. Maurerde Nunez v. BartelsIn re ParishvillePeople v. ZingaleMazur v. Rock-McGraw, Inc.Bentley Assocs., L.P. v. PHC, Inc.Matter of Prior v. Wegmans Food Markets, Inc.Matter of Sapadin v. B of E City of New YorkMorrison v. MorrisonWeber v. WelchCalderone v. Levites Realty Management Corp.People v. BurtPeople v. GoinsPeople v. KovzeloveMatter of Casimer GPeople v. AlfordMatter of Nataia JPeople v. HunterMatter of Triplett v. FarmerDiltz v. BowmanDelgado v. ConnollyDumont v. P. S. Griswold Company, Inc.People v. SerranoGoshen v. Mutual Life Ins. Co. of N.YBell v. BellFeuerman v. AchtarFischman v. GilmoreMatter of YoungMatter of Brooklyn Un. Gas v. Bd., R. PropLambos v. WeintraubPeople v. HollomanMatter of the Estate of LuongoMatter of Wesarg v. Board of TrusteesBlessinger v. Estee Lauder Companies, Inc.Matter of Calligros v. Great Meadow Cor. FacPeople v. LoftonPeople v. CoxMatter of David MMatter of Dippell v. HammonsRizzoli Intl. Publs., Inc. v. ParkSand v. ChapinReed's of Armonk Building Supply v. CurryBlue Ridge Farms v. New York Cty. S. ConstCarney v. Walgreen's CompanyMarpe v. DolmetschIn the Matter of Le'cet GSchalansky v. PurcellRivero v. 3065 Concourse AssocsBrown v. City Sam Restaurants, Inc.Marinaccio v. LeChambord RestaurantPeople v. FolksPeople v. ChedickLewis v. City of GloversvilleDemarest v. BaileyMatter of Raphael S. v. LeventhalIn re AmsterdamArgenio v. Cushman Wakefield, Inc.Pimental v. City of New YorkKaye v. L.B. Russell Chemicals, Inc.People v. SherrodPeople v. TaylorBarax v. BaraxRappy's 2207-09 7th Realty Corp. v. WaltersMatter of Koch v. AndresPeople v. OliverasCardone v. CardoneMatter of Richardson v. Saratoga SpringsPeople v. BelloAlexander v. Tap Electrical Contracting Service, Inc.People v. HarrisADAMS v. CAFE VIVA, INCPeople v. ForbesIn re Brian TT.Stahlbrodt v. Commissioner, Taxation FNelson v. 1683 Unico, Inc.Scharkopf v. Cadbury Schweppes, Inc.Matter of Winglovitz v. Agway, Inc.Matter of OlitskyLoMagno v. KohPeople v. BurgosRivera v. 999 Realty ManagementMatter of Town of Carmel v. P.E.R.BSchwartz v. GersonPlantamura v. Penske Truck Leasing, Inc.Board of Education v. Lomasney CombustionPeople v. LibbyMatter of GiocoliMadden v. New York HospCushman & Wakefield, Inc. v. Northeastern Industrial Park, Inc.Chai & Tantrakoon, Inc. v. Royal Realty Corp.Puchalsky v. RidleyPeople v. GibbsPeople v. RamdatMatter of CuevasMatter of ThomasChianese v. MeierPeople v. BonapartePeople v. RodwellMatter of Shaneek NPeople v. CrooksPeople v. BushatiMatter of Johnson v. SelskyPeople v. GarrickSpeirs v. LefferPeople v. SipasCody v. Anthony Fabiano and Sons, Inc.People v. ShabazzSiemens Solar Indus. v. Atlantic RichfieldFraser v. Park Newspapers of St. LawrenceNivens v. New York City Housing AuthorityIdle Hour Tavern, Inc. v. Chairman of the New York State Liquor AuthorityChen v. GoldsteinElkman v. Southgate Owners Corp.Leonard v. GrimesValinoti v. Sandvik Seamco, Inc.Isaacs v. IsaacsRuffolo v. Garbarini ScherFiremen's Ins., Wash., D.C. v. 860 W. TowerFrazier v. CampbellPeople v. RedcrossKenig v. KenigFlores v. BuenoMatter of Theone McRPeople v. EstrellaPeople v. GuzmanCornelius v. Friends of Crown Hts. Day CareAbdalla v. YehiaCanario v. City of New YorkPeople v. OrsiniPeople v. GonzalezPeople v. WalkerPeople v. MirandaFOTI v. ARCTIC OCEAN STEAM SHIP CO., LTDPeople v. HeaterMurphy v. Huntington HospitalPeople v. SawinskiPeople v. GonzalezSims v. Waldbaum, Inc.Evergreen Bank, N. A. v. DashnawPeople v. HardyMoses-Ludington Hospital, Inc. v. AshruffNorth Shore Funding Corp. v. DelligattiPeople v. SmithPeople v. RiveraPeople v. BannerPeople v. GriffinWilliams v. AlianoMatter of Sims v. SiegelsonRios v. Skaters World Roller Rink, Inc.Seidman v. UngarAlmond v. Town of MassenaGoldman, Bernardini Vomero, v. GoldmanPeople v. Donald PIn re the Dissolution of Pickwick Realty, Ltd.People v. MarkiewiczMcNeil v. Wagner CollegePeople v. GaylePeople v. BoatengPeople v. HookPeople v. ThomasMatter of Johnsen v. State Po. F. Ret. SysBader v. Gill Abstract CorporationMatter of Pedro v. Liberty Lines ExpressMatter of Sandy JMatter of Hodges v. MurphyMatter of ParkerPeople v. HammPeople v. SandersPeople v. DegnanMatter of Rakowski v. McCallMatter of Antoine McKPeople v. MarinoPeople v. KingstonPeople v. WallaceHubbard v. Town of Sand LakePeople v. GarciaNelson v. StateFacilities Development Corporation v. MilettaMatter of Roma v. RuffoJudarl, L. L. C. v. Cycletech, Inc.Sega v. StateJohnson v. CabreraChalmers v. StateM. Gold Son, Inc. v. A.J. Eckert, Inc.Schlick v. American Business Press, Inc.People v. TaftPeople v. MarquezMatter of Land of the Free v. Unique SanitAndersen v. Suska PlumbingWinfield v. GarenaniMatter of Bullock v. Essex Co. Bd. of SupvrAlmada v. Long Island Lighting CompanyTartan Oil v. Taxation DeptFlynn v. DebonisPeople v. WilderPeople v. SedaMatter of Joyce v. GoordLolik v. Big V Supermarkets, Inc.People v. McMaster222 Bloomingdale Road Assoc. v. Nynex PropKlein v. Academy of Model AeronauticsMatter of Evans v. FrancoPeople v. JohnsonMatter of PostPeople v. MarreroMatter of Velez v. State Division of ParolePeople v. EversleyMatter of Town of Northumberland v. StermanStephenson v. Hotel Employees & Restaurant Employees Union Local 100Thompson v. LudovicoVan Wert v. Black & Decker, Inc.Torah v. Kesher International Trading Corp.Matter of Brown v. SchulmanWarren v. Town of HempsteadMatter of Roth v. S H Grossinger, Inc.Coleman, Grasso and Zasada App. v. ColemanPeople v. AdamsWasserstein Enterprises v. Zurich Ins. Co.Empl. Bd. v. Christian BrosIn re EzonPeople v. GilmoreRinaolo v. Werbel McMillin CarneluttiElm Shade Maint. v. Elm Shade Ests. Inc.Matter of Borrell v. HanophyMatter of Stalin Jesus OLittle Prince Productions v. ScoullarHedrick v. Genesee Management, Inc.KRUP v. KRUP'S KITCHEN BATH, LTDPeerless Insurance Company v. Ford Motor Co.Matter of Gonzalez v. GoordMatter of FarrellPeople v. StinsonPeople v. TaylorPeople v. BrownPeople v. PughPeople v. JacksonWilliams v. Environmental Defense FundPeople v. DiazMatter of FrancisPeople v. PaganPhilipstown Dirt Roads Ass'n v. Town BoardAgens v. LittleDavis v. New York City Housing AuthorityHenne v. LefrakBarber v. BarberVogel v. LymanMatter of MalkensonReed's of Armonk Building Supply v. CurryPeople v. AwosikaPeople v. KasiemMatter of Berta v. BennettPeople v. WearingTawfik v. County of NassauMatter of Nicholas X.RMatter of FalcoLanfranchi v. PolatschBuran v. PeryeaCowen Company v. PetersenSeavey v. Meliak Mobile Court, Inc.Matter of RabinPeople v. McFaddenMatter of Kapusinski v. FittsBuehler v. State Farm Insurance CompanyPardee v. PardeeSchleifman v. Prime Hospitality Corp.Suffolk County Correction Officers Ass'n v. New York State Public Employment Relations BoardPeople v. CorreaPeople v. DavisPeople v. CruzPeople v. La FranceMatter of Armonas v. Board of Zoning AppealsPeople v. HodgesPeople v. FarrellIn re Up State Federal Credit UnionMatter of HoltzPeople v. RossDaniel Gale Associates, Inc. v. O'ConnorSanchez v. United Rental Equipment Co., Inc.Bish v. GoordAlava v. City of New YorkMatter of Travelers Ins. Co. v. LianidesPeople v. MikePeople v. HoisingtonMatter of Tawfik v. County of NassauPeople v. JohnsonPeople v. ChaparroKlimowicz v. FurerRockefeller Univ. v. Tishman Const. Corp.Weber v. Sekapi, Inc.Chaney v. Abyssinian Baptist ChurchPeople v. FaulkensonZalondek v. LaudatoCalavano v. New York City Health HospitalsSnyder v. PerezMatter of Ernst v. New York State Exec. DeptDeitsch v. FischerMatter of Parolee S.V. v. CalabreseDancer v. BergmanMRI BROADWAY RENTAL v. U.S. MIN. PRODSBurke v. Village of MalonePeople v. RiveraPeople v. WilliamsBush v. Lamb-Grays Harbor CompanyKoppelman v. Liddle, O'Connor, FinkelsteinIn re Nina J.People v. ChedickPeople v. BlairPeople v. GonzalezTrustco Bank, Natl. v. Cannon Bldg. of TroyArgumedo v. 303 Tenants Corp.J. Randazzo, Inc. v. Sea Fresh, Inc.People v. Warden, Otis Bantum Corr. FacEdwards-Samouge v. Brookdale Hospital Medical CenterHargett v. Karco-Davis, Inc.People v. RivasMatter of Jamel JMatter of Gilson v. National Union Fire Ins. Co.People v. RileyMoses Singer L. L. P. v. ColenPeople v. ThompsonPeople v. PierceThomas v. RoachMatter of BarnesPeople ex Rel. Liotti v. EatmondMandelman v. Mayflower Tr., Inc.McSherry v. Hawthorne SchoolBrown v. City of New YorkPeople v. PerkinsMatter of Edmonson v. CoombeMatter of Stankavich v. Duanesburg Plng. Bd.Aetna Casualty Surety Company v. McCarthySandcham Realty Corp. v. SonnenschinePeople v. FordBooska v. BooskaMatter of D'Amato v. Dept., Hsg. PreserMelo v. Consolidated Edison Co.People v. ThorntonPeople v. GonzalezPeople v. PickettPeople v. BarrettIn re Steven XX.Matter of Odom v. GoordMatter of Christian v. GoordPeople v. FioreMatter of Adams v. Putnam Lk. Vol. Fire DeptMatter of Marvin SPeople v. MorelMatter of SheldrakePeople v. BryantCoan v. Long Island Rail RoadSaraceno v. First National SupermarketsRudansky v. RudanskyPeople v. PerezLevine v. HowardMatter of LoPrestoPeople v. KeitaMatter of IllerbrunPeople v. StonisBeplat v. City of New YorkMotor Vehicle Acc. Indem. v. Travelers Ins. Co.Wenck v. ZilliouxFishman v. BeachManfredi v. PrestonMatter of Wilson v. Town of MohawkMatter of Rosario v. GoordMatter of City Coal. v. GuilianiPeople v. YearwoodTown of Oyster Bay v. DyottComparetto v. Massachusetts Bay Ins. Co.Evans v. Junior's RestMiro-Quesada v. Two Trees Management Co.Matter of GreenwaldPeople v. KingPeople v. VelasquezMatter of Ruschina MPeople v. DodellMatter of CanalePeople v. DarlusPetrillo Realty Dev. Corp. v. Recyco, Inc.Matter of Diana YSchorsch v. SchorschPerry v. City of New YorkMatter of ParrishMatter of Chaya S. v. Herbert LPeople v. WeatherlyLugo v. Mt. Sinai HospitalIn re Nathan PP.Matter of M.I.V. v. Manuel Antonio BDwelling Quest Corp. v. Greater New York Savings BankMatter of Shabazian v. ShabazianMatter of Morrissey v. State Educ. DeptRaval v. State Dept. of Taxation FMerrill Lynch Equity Mgmt., Inc. v. KleinmanFouad v. RiserMatter of Grover v. WingMatter of Dinger v. K-Mart Corp.Matter of Scarola v. MorgenthauPetretti v. Jefferson Valley Racquet ClubCoastal Broadway Associates v. RaphaelCybex International v. Fuqua EnterprisesMatter of BohmovaMatter of Bartfai v. Dept., Agri. MarketMatter of Paublo CPeople v. JuliusPeople v. StreetMatter of RichardsonMegally v. 440 West 34th Street Co.Matter of Mamakating v. State Board, R. PropBullard v. CoulterMatter of Raqiyb v. GoordHannie v. SmithPeople v. WebbPeople v. SwinsonPeople v. PerezMatter of Friedlander v. Health and HospitalsPeople v. MoranSalop v. City of New YorkPeople v. SosaAmerican Manufacturers Mutual Insurance v. CMA Enterprises., Ltd.Serbalik v. General Motors CorporationSamuel v. KhalidMatter of ChariffBesco Steel Erectors v. Mecho Shade SystemsPeople v. MoralesMercado v. Slope AssociatesColicchio v. Port Authority of N.Y. N.JSicari v. First Fidelity BankMatter of Adler v. County of NassauMatter of Monique Twana CMatter of Sadoff v. Ithaca City School DistMuhl v. Ardra InsuranceKonrad v. 136 East 64th Street Corp.Smith v. SmithMastromonica v. ConklinDouglass v. St. Joseph's HospitalParisi v. LevineMcGee v. Family Care ServicesSayad v. New York City Transit AuthorityWalton v. Eastern Analytical Labs, Inc.Matter of Fragola v. Alfaro-FragolaNadler v. NadlerShevell v. EpsteinCapital Holding Co. v. StavrolakesPeople v. FranklinWarner v. University Hospital at StonybrookBrooks v. City of New YorkMatter of Fiore v. AndrewsPeople v. SmallsMatter of Vlepakis v. DillonPorcelli v. BlockCheng v. Leader Jewelry Corp.Darnet Realty v. 136 East 56th St. OwnersAllen v. BrooksKaddoura v. Arab BankPeople v. DanielPeople v. NeutzelPeople v. MazzaCherco, Inc. v. Town Square Mall Assoc., Inc.People v. BrownPeople v. BrownPeople v. DixonPeople v. JenkinsSeltel, Inc. v. ChoyPeople v. SmithPeople v. MartinezPeople v. RobertsPearce v. Clinton Community CollegePeople v. MatthewsMatter of the Claim of GarciaPeople v. HernandezMatter of Russo v. HRT, Inc. of Orange CountyMatter of Flecha v. TravisPeople v. EnglishGomez v. City of New YorkBrodsky v. Neurological Associates of L.IMatter of General Accident Ins. Co. v. TranHudson's Bay New York, Inc. v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co.FOUR STAR HOLDING CO. v. ALEX FURS, INCAm Don International Inc. v. Unlimited Brokerage Corp.Matter of Clukey v. CluteBellofatto v. FrengsLawyers' Fund, Client Prot. v. Chemical BKPeople v. SmithManning v. Ardsley Union Free School Dist20 East 17th Street Llc. v. 4 M Dev. Co.People v. BrockBlair v. Nynex Corp.Corp. of Lloyd's v. FunkMatter of IngberPeople v. HenriquezSimpson v. SinhaCottone v. Real Estate Industrials, Inc.Lawyer v. Albany Medical Center Hosp. Inc.Petito v. Verrazano Contracting Co.Matter of Silva v. City of New YorkSanchez v. Javind Apt. Corp.Lewis v. Newsday, Inc.People v. NormanPeople v. MedinaDinkle v. LagalaPeople v. Rivera71 Main Street Associates v. GrossoWatson v. Starrett City, Inc.Matter of Atlantic Ref. Mktg. v. AssessorPeople v. McKieverVollbrecht v. VollbrechtPeople v. AllawayMallet v. MalletMatter of PreiserDonohoe v. Town of BabylonPeople v. ColonMalott v. International Prop. PartnershipMatter of Volin v. GoordIn re HurdGoldman v. BernardiniDurinda v. Kokosing Construction CompanyLustyik v. ManaherMatter of Podszus v. Cty., Mt. Vernon D.P.SManning v. Ardsley Union Free School DistHuff v. C.K. Sanitary Systems, Inc.Domingo v. EpsteinNational Ent. v. Dechert Price RhoadsDeMayo v. 1000 Northern of New York CompanyHydell v. North Atlantic Life Insurance Co.Del Vecchio v. StateMatter of Melendez v. RodriquezThomas v. PhillipsNorth Babylon U.F.S. v. Brentwood U.F.SPeople v. BrockStout v. Christie, Manson Woods Intn'lPeople v. CabanMatter of Herrera v. New York State Bd., PGreen v. GreenWalston v. JohnsonPeople v. McLeanProperty Clerk v. CarterBrady v. HelmsleyCohen v. CohenRecuppio v. RecuppioPeople v. HedgepethMatter of ChikofskyDoyne v. Barry, Bette & Led Duke, Inc.People v. SantosMatter of Mark Lavon SPeople v. JonesDinkle v. LagalaPeople v. SmallBishop v. New York State Department of Social ServicesPines at Setauket, Inc. v. Retirement Management Group Inc.KAM W. 60TH ST. ASSOCS., L.P. v. NAFTALYPeople v. HoldenMATTER OF DeBLASIO v. CITY DEPT. OF HWYSMorin v. PriorMaynard v. WaitAltman v. AltmanIn re Rose BB.O'Sullivan v. Atrium Bus Co., Inc.Gasho of Japan v. Taisei Constr. Co.Transglobal Mktg. Corp. v. Derfner MahlerMatter of Torres v. National Union Fire Ins. Co.Fontana v. FortunoffMillard v. MillardGemma Construction Co. v. City, New YorkPeople v. McNishPeople v. MorrisPeople v. LopezPeople v. LeivaPeople v. OyebanjiGordon v. Phipps Houses Services, Inc.Aviv Knitwear Corp. v. Greiner Maltz Co.Matter of Glenn v. BosworthPeople v. GordonPeople v. ReddenMatter of Benjamin LJanssen v. Ryder Truck Rental, Inc.Greenblatt v. New York Surety CompanyMatter of Guarneri v. BrattonPark Ave. Props. Assocs. v. SassowerPeople v. StoutBernardo v. P. J. Edwards, Inc.People v. NallsPeople v. Infinite AllahCooper v. BogelPeople v. MorganIonescu v. BrancoveanuMatter of WallaceMiranti v. Brightwaters Racquet & Spa, Inc.Domingo v. C. True Building Corp.Glens Falls Communication Corp. v. New York State Public Service CommissionMatter of Kurzon v. KurzonYankana v. City of New YorkMurphy v. Broadway 48-49th Street AssocArnav Indus., Inc. v. M.H.B. Holdings, Inc.Matter of Lloyd LMatter of Monko v. SelskyFallek v. Becker, Achiron IsserlisMatter of Donald P. v. PalmieriMatter of Jason LMatter of Velez v. McGinnisPeople v. SmallPeople v. LippolisMatter of McReynolds v. AngioneRostuca Holdings, Ltd. v. PoloPeople v. BrownMatter of Chmielewsky v. State Div. of ParoleJulien v. LiebertMatter of Cohen v. Department, Hsg. PreservMatter of Mendez v. Great Meadow Corr. FacPeople v. OrtizPeople v. RushJarosz v. 3135 Johnson Tenant Owners Corp.People v. WashingtonMatter of Whitcomb v. Xerox CorporationCarroll v. BeneMatter of Giorgio v. BucciNew York State Electric Gas Corp. v. AllenNorthridge Ltd. v. SpencePeople v. RiddickMatter of Coneen v. SelskySchwartzreich v. E.P.C. Carting Co., Inc.Matter of Female NPeople v. LewisAT&T GLOBAL INFORMATION SERVS. v. ZINNProvident Life Casualty Ins. Co. v. HerskoMatter of YarisRigo v. LudkeSpodek v. FeibuschBazbaz v. State of New York Division of Housing & Community RenewalPeople v. MunozPeople v. HernandezPeople v. GauthierMatter of Saglibene v. BaumPeople v. JimenezPeople v. HudsonMatter of Tate v. SaksMatter of Williams v. RecoreMatter of WatsonPeople v. MaconMatter of Palevsky v. City Board of EducMental Hygiene Legal Servs. v. FordMatter of Burgos v. GoordCentury Business Credit Corp. v. North Fork BankHowell v. BrozzettiQuantum Corporate Funding v. L.P.G. AssocMatter of SykesPeople v. HillG.C. Fortune Management Co. v. Stockade Mobile Home Park, Inc.People v. McLaughlinMatter of Zaida MannettaMenard v. Carl Thomas Construction Corp.People v. OteroPeople v. HudgenPeople v. TrumbachSteinberg v. AbdulMatter of Morrison v. SelskyMatter of Momah v. RogersPeople v. MarshallPeople v. MoralesMatter of Houck v. HouckPeople v. GonzalezOquendo v. New York City Transit AuthorityPeople v. CollinsMatter of DampmanBrown v. NwakammaPeople v. Fuentes