From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Straber v. Schmaltz

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Nov 18, 1936
4 N.E.2d 593 (Ind. Ct. App. 1936)

Opinion

No. 15,517.

Filed November 18, 1936.

1. APPEAL — Proceedings for Transfer — Term Appeal — Defects in Security — Failure to Name Surety During Term. — Attempted term-time appeal held insufficient to give jurisdiction where trial court did not name and approve securities, nor fix the penalty of an appeal bond, during the term at which the motion for new trial was overruled. p. 630.

2. APPEAL — Proceedings for Transfer — Term Appeal — Failure to Perfect — Dismissal. — Where attempted term-time appeal was defective and no attempt was made to perfect a vacation appeal before the time therefor expired, the appeal was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction. p. 631.

From Ripley Circuit Court; Albert B. Wycoff, Special Judge.

Action by Noah C. Straber and another, doing business as S. S. Oil Company, against Steve Schmaltz and another. From a judgment for defendants, plaintiffs appealed. Appeal dismissed. By the court in banc.

Vernon M. Vahinger and Turner Woodfill, for appellants.

Wickens Wickens and Jackson Jackson, for appellees.


This is an attempted term-time appeal from a judgment rendered on February 16, 1934. The motion for new trial was overruled on March 2, 1935. Appellees have entered a special appearance and filed a motion to dismiss on the ground that appellants have not complied with the statute authorizing a term-time appeal nor was notice given as required to perfect a vacation appeal. The record discloses the following entry made on March 2, 1935: "And now said plaintiffs pray an appeal to the Appellate Court of Indiana, and ask thirty days to file appeal bond, and the court now grants said appeal, and said plaintiffs given ninety days to file bill of exceptions. Bond to be approved by the clerk in vacation."

In order to perfect a term-time appeal, a bond with the penalty fixed and sureties approved by the court in term must be filed within the time fixed by the court. As the court did not 1. name and approve any sureties or fix the penalty of the bond during the term at which the motion for new trial was overruled it follows that a term-time appeal was not perfected and this court has no jurisdiction under the attempted term-time appeal. Penn. Am. Plate Glass Co. v. Poling, Admx. (1912), 52 Ind. App. 492, 100 N.E. 83, and cases there cited. Coxe Bros. Co. v. Foley (1914), 58 Ind. App. 584, 107 N.E. 85; Tuttle v. Fowler (1914), 183 Ind. 99, 107 N.E. 674; Vancleave v. Wolf (1933), 98 Ind. App. 650, 190 N.E. 371.

The appellants' attempted term-time appeal therefore failed and no attempt having been made to perfect a vacation appeal 2. and the time for so perfecting having expired, this appeal is dismissed.


Summaries of

Straber v. Schmaltz

Court of Appeals of Indiana
Nov 18, 1936
4 N.E.2d 593 (Ind. Ct. App. 1936)
Case details for

Straber v. Schmaltz

Case Details

Full title:STRABER ET AL. v. SCHMALTZ ET AL

Court:Court of Appeals of Indiana

Date published: Nov 18, 1936

Citations

4 N.E.2d 593 (Ind. Ct. App. 1936)
4 N.E.2d 593

Citing Cases

Gentry v. Ragan

The record discloses that the judgment of the trial court did not become final until the 19th day of October,…