As amended through November 12, 2024
Rule 32.4 - Sentencing Referrals to Three-Judge Panel(a)Referral to Panel. If the trial judge finds that extraordinary circumstances exist under AS 12.55.165, the case shall be transferred forthwith to a three-judge sentencing panel of the superior court. All pertinent files, records and transcripts shall be transmitted to the sentencing panel by the clerk of the court within 30 days of the date of the order transferring the case.(b)Appointment of Panel. Three judges of the superior court shall be appointed by the chief justice to be the regular members of the sentencing panel. Two other judges of the superior court shall be appointed by the chief justice as first and second alternate members of the sentencing panel. At least one of the three regular members and one of the two alternate members of the sentencing panel shall reside outside of Anchorage. The term of appointment of the regular and alternate members of the sentencing panel shall be two years, except that the first three regular members appointed shall serve staggered terms of one, two, and three years. The chief justice may appoint additional alternate members of the sentencing panel to serve on a case-by-case basis in the event of the disability or disqualification of more than two judges.(c)Repository of Documents. The chief justice shall appoint one of the three regular members to be administrative head of the sentencing panel and his or her office shall serve as the administrative repository for all papers and documents pertaining to cases submitted to the sentencing panel.(d)Challenge of Panel Member. Both the prosecuting attorney and the defendant may exercise in a timely fashion a challenge for cause, or a peremptory challenge if not previously exercised, to one judge on the sentencing panel in accordance with AS 22.20.022 and Criminal Rule 25(d)(1). In the event that a judge on the sentencing panel is the same judge who made the finding under paragraph (a) of this rule, that judge shall be automatically disqualified.(e)Time for Decision. Within 60 days from the date that the case was transmitted to the sentencing panel, the sentencing panel shall either sentence the defendant or remand the case to the judge who referred the case to the sentencing panel. The sentencing panel shall provide a written statement of its findings and conclusions in support of any order remanding a case to the referring judge.(f)Hearing. If the sentencing panel elects to take testimony or sentence the defendant under AS 12.55.175(b) or (c), both the prosecution and the defendant shall have the right to be present in court during the proceedings. The defendant shall have the right to address the sentencing panel personally before sentence is imposed. The proceedings shall be held in a location best suited to the convenience of the parties and the court as determined by the sentencing panel.(g)Further Sentencing Proceedings. If the sentencing panel imposes sentence on the defendant, proceedings relating to sentence modification under Criminal Rule 35(a) shall be assigned to the sentencing panel sitting at the time such action is ready for decision. All other post-sentencing proceedings shall be assigned to the judge who referred the matter to the sentencing panel for consideration. The referring judge may impose any sentence which the sentencing panel would be empowered to impose, except that the referring judge may not reduce a sentence imposed by the sentencing panel.(h)Right to Bail. The right to bail of a convicted defendant is neither conferred nor enlarged by this rule.Added by SCO 1136 effective 7/15/1993