Section R23-20-6 - Expedited Appeals-Free Speech Activities(1) Claims eligible for expedited appeal. The following determinations of claims regarding a free speech activity may be appealed as provided in Section in R23-20-6. (a) A determination by the managing agency that a proposed event or activity is a commercial activity and not exempted as a free speech activity;(b) A claim by an applicant that the managing agency's denial, or condition of approval, of a proposed route, time or location for a free speech activity constitutes a violation of this rule or an unlawful time, place, or manner restriction; or(c) Any other claim by an applicant that any action by the state regarding the proposed free speech activity impermissibly burdens constitutionally protected rights of the applicant, sponsor, participants, or spectators.(2) Process for Expedited Appeal: (a) The state acknowledges an obligation to process appeals regarding a free speech activity promptly to not unreasonably inhibit or unlawfully burden constitutionally protected activities. Any time limit stated in Section R23-20-6 may be lengthened if agreed to by the appellant and the managing agency. (i) As soon as reasonably possible, but no later than two working days after receipt of a completed registration, the managing agency shall issue a determination, which may include lawful conditions, or notice of denial of the registration application.(b) The managing agency may deny the requested activity if: (i) the requested activity does not comply with the applicable rules;(ii) the registrant attempts to register a free speech activity, but the managing agency determines that it is a commercial activity;(iii) the event would disrupt, conflict, or interfere with a state sponsored activity, a time or place reserved for another free speech activity, the operation of state business, and such determination is in accordance with applicable constitutional provisions; or(iv) the event poses a safety or security risk to persons or property and such determination is in accordance with applicable constitutional provisions.(c) The managing agency may place conditions on the approval that alleviates such concerns, and such conditions are in accordance with this rule and applicable constitutional provisions. (i) If the applicant disagrees with a denial of the request or conditions placed on the approval, the applicant may appeal the managing agency's determination by delivering the written appeal and reasons for the disagreement to the managing agency.(ii) Within three working days after the managing agency receives the written appeal, the managing agency may modify or affirm the determination.(iii) If the matter is still unresolved after the issuance of the managing agency's reconsideration determination, the applicant may appeal the matter, in writing, within ten calendar days to the Executive Director of the Department of Government Operations who will determine the process of the appeal and provide for a determination within five working days.(e) If the applicant for a free speech activity needs a more expeditious process of an appeal, upon written request of the applicant, the Attorney General or designee may advise the Executive Director of the Department of Government Operations or the managing agency of the need to make an immediate consideration of the appeal.Utah Admin. Code R23-20-6
Amended by Utah State Bulletin Number 2023-04, effective 2/8/2023