Okla. Admin. Code § 165:5-13-3

Current through Vol. 42, No. 4, November 1, 2024

Section 165:5-13-3 - Hearings

(a)Conduct of hearing. Every hearing shall be conducted by the Commission, by an Administrative Law Judge or as provided at OAC 165:5-13-2.1. The Commission or Administrative Law Judge shall call the case for hearing, after which proceedings shall be had as provided in this Section.

(b)Scope of hearings. The Commission, Administrative Law Judge or Public Utility Referee may state the purpose and scope of the hearing, or the issues upon which evidence will be heard.

(c)Appearances. Each person appearing shall enter an appearance by stating their name and if applicable, the name of the party being represented. Thereafter, such person shall be deemed a party of record, unless specified otherwise.

(1) An individual may appear on his or her own behalf.

(2) A corporation may appear only by its attorney; provided, that a representative other than an attorney may appear on behalf of a corporation for the sole purpose of making a statement or indicating corporate policy. Such a representative may not assume an advocate's role or introduce evidence or examine witnesses in the proceeding.

(3) Should an attorney no longer represent the party of record, a withdrawal of appearance must be filed with the Court Clerk and provided to all parties of record and the party who was previously represented by the attorney. The withdrawal of appearance must include the name and last known address of the party.

(d)Protests.

(1) Except as otherwise permitted by this Chapter, any person desiring to protest the relief requested by the application shall file a notice of protest with the Court Clerk's office.

(2) Before the protest is filed or within a reasonable time thereafter, the protestant shall give notice to the applicant in a manner designed to advise the applicant of the protest prior to the scheduled hearing. Once filed, the written protest shall be provided to the applicant by regular mail, facsimile, electronic mail or in person.

(3) A protesting party initially may announce a protest to a case at the time of hearing, but shall subsequently file a written protest within a reasonable amount of time after the announcement of such protest.

(4) A protest form will be available on the Commission's website; however, such form is not required as long as the filed protest document contains the required information.

(5) A filed protest must contain the caption of the application and contact information of the protestant or the protestant's attorney.

(6) The provisions of this subsection shall not apply to cases filed on the PUD or OSF dockets.

(e)Preliminary matters. The following shall be addressed prior to receiving evidence:

(1) Unless otherwise ordered by the Commission or Administrative Law Judge, or unless otherwise required by these rules, all exhibits intended to be offered into evidence shall be sent by electronic mail to the court reporter and Administrative Law Judge at least one (1) business day prior to the opening of an uncontested hearing.

(2) The applicant, or staff counsel, may offer preliminary exhibits, including documents necessary to present the issues to be heard, notices, proof of publication and orders previously entered in the case.

(3) Ruling may be made on any pending motions, including requests pertaining to discovery.

(4) Stipulations of fact and stipulated exhibits shall be received. No stipulation, settlement, or agreement between the parties of record, their attorneys, or representatives with regard to any matter involved in any case shall be enforced unless it shall have been reduced to writing and signed by the parties of record or the representatives authorized by the rules of this Chapter to appear for them and thereafter made a part of the record, or unless it shall have been dictated into the record by them during the course of a hearing or incorporated into an order bearing their written approval. This Section does not limit a party of record's ability to waive, modify, or stipulate any right or privilege afforded by the rules of this Chapter, unless precluded by law.

(5) Parties of record may, in the discretion of the Commission or Administrative Law Judge, make opening statements where appropriate.

(6) Any other preliminary matters appropriate for disposition prior to presentation of evidence.

(f)Rules of evidence. The Commission and Administrative Law Judges shall follow the rules of evidence applied in the district courts of Oklahoma, except that such rules may be relaxed where the Commission or the Administrative Law Judge deems it in the public interest to do so. The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may exclude evidence upon objection made thereto, or the evidence may be received subject to final ruling by the Commission. An exception will be deemed to be preserved by a party of record objecting to evidence upon an adverse ruling thereon. The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may exclude inadmissible evidence on his own motion and may direct cumulative evidence be discontinued.

(g)Order of proof. The applicant or complainant who institutes a case may open and close the proof. Staff counsel may open and close a case instituted by the Commission or a staff member. Intervenors may be heard immediately following parties of record with whom allied in interest. In all cases, the Commission or Administrative Law Judge shall designate the order of proof.

(h)Examination of witnesses. Every witness shall be examined and cross-examined orally and under oath by not more than one attorney for each party of record. The Commission or Administrative Law Judge shall designate the order of examination and may limit the scope of examination and cross-examination.

(i)Adverse party. A party of record may call an adverse person or an officer or employee of an adverse person, in which case the witness may be impeached and otherwise cross-examined.

(j)Record. All testimony shall be taken on the record.

(k)Prepared testimony. Written testimony of a witness in form of questions and answers, or a narrative statement may be received in lieu of direct examination upon authentication by the witness under oath. In order to be received and relied upon at the hearing, such testimony and exhibits shall be filed and served upon all parties of record not less than five (5) days prior to the hearing, unless otherwise ordered by the Commission for good cause shown. The witness shall be subject to cross-examination. A written or oral statement by or a communication from any person, or a statement or resolution of a political subdivision, trade association, civic organization, or other organization may be received without cross-examination, but will be considered only as argument and not as proof of any recitation of facts contained therein.

(l)Documents.

(1) A photographic copy of a document which is on file as part of the official records of the Commission will be received without further authentication.

(2) A photographic copy of a public record certified by the official custodian thereof will be received without further authentication. A written statement by such custodian of records that no record or entry of described character is found in his records shall be received as proof of absence of such record.

(3) A photographic copy of a document may be substituted for the original at the time the original is offered in evidence.

(4) A document may not be incorporated in the record by reference except by permission of the Commission or Administrative Law Judge. Any document so received must be precisely identified.

(5) The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may require that documents such as rate compilations, statistical or technical data, and tabulated material be filed at a designated time prior to the hearing.

(6) The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may require that additional copies of exhibits be furnished for use by the Commission, staff counsel, and other parties of record.

(7) When evidence is offered which is contained in a book or document containing material not offered, the person offering the same shall extract or clearly identify the portion offered.

(8) The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may permit a party of record to offer a document as part of the record within a designated time after conclusion of the hearing.

(m)Exhibits. All exhibits shall be identified by docket type and case number on the first page of each exhibit prior to submitting to the Commission. All pages of each exhibit shall have continuous pagination. Each exhibit shall conform to the following requirements:

(1) all exhibits must be legible;

(2) the font must be no smaller than a size 10 font;

(3) if multiple colors are used, the colors shall be sufficiently distinguishable; and

(4) data shall be included on each exhibit to support the relief requested.

(n)Summary exhibits. An exhibit consisting of a compilation or summary of evidence, records, data, statistics, or other similar information may be received in evidence in addition to or in lieu of the evidence summarized, provided:

(1) The evidence summarized has been admitted in evidence, or is admissible; and

(2) If the evidence summarized has not been admitted, the person offering the summary exhibit has made the evidence summarized available for inspection by all other parties of record, or the information is published in a generally recognized publication which is available to all parties of record. It shall be the responsibility of a person offering a summary exhibit to comply with this subsection in advance of the hearing, and failure to make the evidence summarized available for inspection shall be grounds for refusal to admit the exhibit.

(o)Closing the record. The record shall be closed when all parties of record have had an opportunity to be heard and to present evidence, and the Commission or Administrative Law Judge announces that the record of testimony and exhibits is closed. Unless a decision is then announced, the matter will be taken under advisement for later decision.

(p)Briefs. The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may require or allow the filing of briefs by the parties of record, and may designate the order and time for filing briefs and reply briefs.

(q)Reopening the record. Any person may file and serve, by regular mail, facsimile or electronic mail on all parties of record a motion to reopen the record for further hearing or to offer additional evidence. The Commission, at any time prior to final order in the case, may, upon such motion or upon the motion of the Commission, order the record to be reopened for the purpose of taking testimony and receiving evidence which was not or could not have been available at the time of the hearing on the merits or for the purpose of examining its jurisdiction. A motion to reopen shall be filed and served in the same manner as provided in OAC 165:5-9-2(b). The motion and notice shall include a statement that if the Administrative Law Judge grants the motion, the record may be reopened the same day or on some other day as the Commission may determine.

(r)Corrections to transcript. Except as provided in OAC 165:5-13-1(d), an official reporter shall make a stenographic and electronic record of the hearing. Errors claimed to be in a transcription of either a contested or uncontested hearing shall be noted in writing and suggested corrections may be offered to the Commission or Administrative Law Judge who presided at such hearing within ten (10) days after the transcript is filed, unless the Commission or Administrative Law Judge shall permit suggested corrections to be offered thereafter. Suggested corrections shall be served in writing upon each party of record and the Commission or Administrative Law Judge. If not objected to within twelve (12) days after being offered, the Commission or Administrative Law Judge shall direct that such suggested corrections be made and the manner of making them. In the event that parties disagree on suggested corrections, the Commission or Administrative Law Judge, with the aid of argument and testimony from the parties of record, shall then determine the manner in which the record shall be changed, if at all.

(s)Preparation of report or order. The Commission or Administrative Law Judge may permit or direct any party or parties of record to prepare a proposed report or order in any protested case. In unprotested cases, the applicant shall prepare and submit a proposed Commission order.

(1) Orders regarding non-emergency applications shall be submitted to the Administrative Law Judge within thirty (30) calendar days of the date the Administrative Law Judge announced the recommendation unless the Administrative Law Judge directs otherwise.

(2) Proposed orders regarding emergency applications shall be submitted to the Administrative Law Judge within ten (10) business days of the date the Administrative Law Judge announced the recommendation unless the Administrative Law Judge directs otherwise.

(3) Failure to submit a proposed order to the Administrative Law Judge within the time frame required by this subsection may result in the Administrative Law Judge reopening the record, with five (5) business days' notice to the party or parties of record, and the application being recommended for dismissal unless good cause is shown for the failure to supply the proposed order as required. Notice to the party or parties of record may be provided via electronic mail.

Okla. Admin. Code § 165:5-13-3

Amended at 17 Ok Reg 2299, eff 7-1-00; Amended at 27 Ok Reg 2098, eff 7-11-10

Amended by Oklahoma Register, Volume 31, Issue 24, September 2, 2014, eff. 9/12/2014

Amended by Oklahoma Register, Volume 34, Issue 24, September 1, 2017, eff. 9/11/2017

Amended by Oklahoma Register, Volume 36, Issue 21, July 15, 2019, eff. 8/1/2019

Amended by Oklahoma Register, Volume 37, Issue 24, September 1, 2020, eff. 10/1/2020

Amended by Oklahoma Register, Volume 40, Issue 24, September 1, 2023, eff. 10/1/2023