Supreme Court of West Virginia December 1999 casesState v. ShabazzHartman v. Morningstar Bldg. Co., Inc.State ex rel. Department of Health & Human Resources v. SchwabState v. PaynterIn re PetreyKirby v. FoxCMC Enterprise, Inc. v. Ken Lowe Management Co.Crispen v. West Virginia Secondary Schools Activities CommissionOak Cas. Ins. Co., v. LechliterThacker v. Workers' Compensation DivisionState v. RichardsState v. PalmerState v. ClineFlint v. Bd. of Educ. of County of HarrisonIn re Travis WMcGraw v. Combs ServicesLipscomb v. Tucker County Com'nHicks v. Hicks