Appellate Division of Massachusetts September 2009 casesMcCarthy v. Quirk NissanKaren v. Kelly BeattyNRT New England, Inc. v. IndicianiDebettencourt v. ThomasGosselin v. Colonial Shopping CenterOhrenberger v. RyanHaynes v. KevinMichael v. Hanover Ins. Co.Joseph v. KarenJohn v. Commerce Ins. Co.Pennsylvania v. Halpern