From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Smith v. Furniture Co.

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1942
19 S.E.2d 17 (N.C. 1942)

Opinion

(Filed 4 March, 1942.)

Appeal and Error § 38 —

When the Supreme Court is evenly divided in opinion, one Justice not sitting, the judgment of the lower court will be affirmed without becoming a precedent.

APPEAL by plaintiff and by defendant copartnership from Bone, J., at December Special Term, 1941, of McDOWELL. Affirmed.

G. F. Washburn and Paul J. Story for plaintiff, appellant.

George A. Shuford for defendant McDowell Furniture Company, appellee.

Proctor Dameron for defendants, J. H. L. Miller and Fred C. Morris, partners, trading as Builders Supply Company, appellees and appellants.


Civil action to recover damages for personal injuries resulting from an automobile-truck collision in which the defendant copartnership alleges a counterclaim against plaintiff and a cross action against defendant McDowell Furniture Company for property damages sustained as a result of the said collision. (See Smith v. Furniture Co., 220 N.C. 155.)

The court, on motions made at the conclusion of the evidence, entered judgment of nonsuit both as against plaintiff and as against defendant copartnership on its counterclaim and cross action. Plaintiff and defendant copartnership excepted and appealed.


One member of the Court, Schenck, J., not sitting, and the remaining six being evenly divided in opinion, the judgment of the Superior Court is affirmed in accord with the usual practice in such cases, and stands as the decision in this case without becoming a precedent. Howard v. Coach Co., 216 N.C. 799, 4 S.E.2d 449; Pafford v. Construction Co., 218 N.C. 782, 11 S.E.2d 548.

Affirmed.


Summaries of

Smith v. Furniture Co.

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Mar 1, 1942
19 S.E.2d 17 (N.C. 1942)
Case details for

Smith v. Furniture Co.

Case Details

Full title:GEORGE W. SMITH v. McDOWELL FURNITURE COMPANY, A CORPORATION; WILLIAM E…

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Mar 1, 1942

Citations

19 S.E.2d 17 (N.C. 1942)
19 S.E.2d 17

Citing Cases

Warehouses, Inc., v. Burker Co.

The Court, Schenck, J., not sitting, being evenly divided on the merits of this assignment of error, which…

Smith v. Furniture Co.

The case was here again at Spring Term, 1942, on plaintiff's appeal from a judgment of nonsuit as to both…