Opinion
2012-07-12
Burton HETHERINGTON, Julian Milewski, David Zienkiewicz, Cynthia Zienkiewicz, Jason Milewski, Peggy Forgotch, Joseph Clews, Kelly Moran, David Seresky, Grace Glowacki, Charles Hampton, Anna Mae Hampton, John Anczarski, Joseph Clews, Raymond Smith, Cynthia Smith, David Hampton, Lynn Lentes, Debra Hampton, John Uroskie, David Banning, Robert Wise, Barbra Wise, Dale Kimmel, Lena Kimmel, John Rumbel, Michelle Rumbel, Cathy Shoup, Roger Shoup, Raymond Mishlanie, Carol Mishlanie, Debra Grow, Robert O. Ororco, Albert Breznik, Jr., Leon Trusky, Haley Dunlap, Mary Anczarski, Penny Brouse, Robert Wollyung, Leon Lowandowski, Nancy Stauffer, David Briggs, Edward Glembockie, Margret Hunsinger, James Ambrose, Susan Briel, Eileen Teeter, Dennis Teeter, Mary Milosh, Melissa McGruffie, Bobbie Jo Edmonson, Edward Sanchez, and Joseph E. Faust, Jr. v. William ROGERS, President, N.S.S.B., Jane Rapant, Vice President, N.S.S.B., Christine Heyer, Treasurer, N.S.S.B., Robert Wetzel, Former President, N.S.S.B., Phil Rapant, Robert Orth, John Motsney, Edward Balkiewicz, John Misiewicz, and Mark Semanchik, Esq. Appeal of William Rogers, Jane Rapant, Christine Heyer, Robert Wetzel, Phil Rapant, Edward Balkiewicz, John Motsney, and Mark Semanchik, Esq. Burton Hetherington, Julian Milewski, David Zienkiewicz, Cynthia Zienkiewicz, Jason Milewski, Peggy Forgotch, Joseph Clews, Kelly Moran, David Seresky, Grace Glowacki, Charles Hampton, Anna Mae Hampton, John Anczarski, Joseph Clews, Raymond Smith, Cynthia Smith, David Hampton, Lynn Lentes, Debra Hampton, John Uroskie, David Banning, Robert Wise, Barbra Wise, Dale Kimmel, Lena Kimmel, John Rumbel, Michelle Rumbel, Cathy Shoup, Roger Shoup, Raymond Mishlanie, Carol Mishlanie, Debra Grow, Robert O. Ororco, Albert Breznik, Jr., Leon Trusky, Haley Dunlap, Mary Anczarski, Leon Lowandowski, Nancy Stauffer, David Briggs, Edward Glembockie, Margret Hunsinger, James Ambrose, Susan Briel, Eileen Teeter, Dennis Teeter, Mary Milosh, Melissa McGruffie, Bobbie Jo Edmonson, Edward Sanchez, Joseph E. Faust, Jr. v. William Rogers, President, N.S.S.B., Jane Rapant, Vice President, N.S.S.B., Christine Heyer, Treasurer, N.S.S.B., Robert Wetzel, Former President, N.S.S.B., Phil Rapant, Robert Orth, John Motsney, Edward Balkiewicz, John Misiewicz, and Mark Semanchik, Esq. Appeal of John Misiewicz.
Appeal from the Order of the Commonwealth Court, Nos. 70 MAP 2011, 71 MAP 2011, at Nos. 1448 C.D. 2009, 1430 C.D. 2009, dated September 27, 2010, Affirming the Judgment of the Schuylkill County Court of Common Pleas, Civil Division, at No. S–3295–2008, dated June 25, 2009, 6 A.3d 6 (Pa.Cmwlth.2010), D. Michael Stine, Judge. Stuart Lee Knade, PA School Boards Association, Inc., for Amicus Curiae Pennsylvania School Boards Association. Victor Paul Stabile, Dilworth Paxson, L.L.P., for Rogers, W., Rapant, J., Heyer, C., Wetzel, R., Rapant, P., Balklewicz, E., Motsney J., Semanchick, M.
Appeal from the Order of the Commonwealth Court, Nos. 70 MAP 2011, 71 MAP 2011, at Nos. 1448 C.D. 2009, 1430 C.D. 2009, dated September 27, 2010, Affirming the Judgment of the Schuylkill County Court of Common Pleas, Civil Division, at No. S–3295–2008, dated June 25, 2009, 6 A.3d 6 (Pa.Cmwlth.2010), D. Michael Stine, Judge.
Stuart Lee Knade, PA School Boards Association, Inc., for Amicus Curiae Pennsylvania School Boards Association. Victor Paul Stabile, Dilworth Paxson, L.L.P., for Rogers, W., Rapant, J., Heyer, C., Wetzel, R., Rapant, P., Balklewicz, E., Motsney J., Semanchick, M.
Lloyd R. Hampton, Hampton & Hampton, for Herington, Milewski, Ziekiewicz, Forgotch, Clews, Moran, Seresky, Glowacki, Hampton, et al.
Michael D. Kristofco, Wisler, Pearlstine, LLP, for John Mislewicz.
CASTILLE, C.J., SAYLOR, EAKIN, BAER, TODD, MCCAFFERY, ORIE MELVIN, JJ.
ORDER
PER CURIAM.
AND NOW, this 12th day of July, 2012, the Court being evenly divided, the Order of the Commonwealth Court is AFFIRMED.