From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

GSI Technology, Inc. v. United Memories Inc.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN JOSE DIVISION
Jun 26, 2015
Case No.: 5:13-cv-01081-PSG (N.D. Cal. Jun. 26, 2015)

Opinion

Case No.: 5:13-cv-01081-PSG

06-26-2015

GSI TECHNOLOGY, INC., Plaintiff, v. UNITED MEMORIES, INC., et al., Defendants.


OMNIBUS ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

(Re: Docket Nos. 513, 521, 523, 527, 546, 556, 560, 563, 568, 570, 587, 594, 614, 618, 636)

Before the court are 15 administrative motions to seal hundreds of documents. "Historically, courts have recognized a 'general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including judicial records and documents.'" Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, "a 'strong presumption in favor of access' is the starting point." Parties seeking to seal judicial records relating to dispositive motions bear the burden of overcoming the presumption with "compelling reasons" that outweigh the general history of access and the public policies favoring disclosure.

Kamakana v. City & County of Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172, 1178 (9th Cir. 2006) (quoting Nixon v. Warner Commc'ns, Inc., 435 U.S. 589, 597 & n.7 (1978)).

Id. (quoting Foltz v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 331 F.3d 1122, 1135 (9th Cir. 2003)).

Id. at 1178-79.

However, "while protecting the public's interest in access to the courts, we must remain mindful of the parties' right to access those same courts upon terms which will not unduly harm their competitive interest." Records attached to nondispositive motions therefore are not subject to the strong presumption of access. Because the documents attached to nondispositive motions "are often unrelated, or only tangentially related, to the underlying cause of action," parties moving to seal must meet the lower "good cause" standard of Rule 26(c). As with dispositive motions, the standard applicable to nondispositive motions requires a "particularized showing" that "specific prejudice or harm will result" if the information is disclosed. "Broad allegations of harm, unsubstantiated by specific examples of articulated reasoning" will not suffice. A protective order sealing the documents during discovery may reflect the court's previous determination that good cause exists to keep the documents sealed, but a blanket protective order that allows the parties to designate confidential documents does not provide sufficient judicial scrutiny to determine whether each particular document should remain sealed.

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., 727 F.3d 1214, 1228-29 (Fed. Cir. 2013).

See id. at 1180.

Id. at 1179 (internal quotations and citations omitted).

Id.

Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. Gen. Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1210-11 (9th Cir. 2002); see Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c).

Beckman Indus., Inc. v. Int'l Ins. Co., 966 F.2d 470, 476 (9th Cir. 1992).

See Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179-80.

See Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(A) ("Reference to a stipulation or protective order that allows a party to designate certain documents as confidential is not sufficient to establish that a document, or portions thereof, are sealable.").

In addition to making particularized showings of good cause, parties moving to seal documents must comply with the procedures established by Civ. L.R. 79-5. Pursuant to Civ. L.R. 79-5(b), a sealing order is appropriate only upon a request that establishes the document is "sealable," or "privileged or protectable as a trade secret or otherwise entitled to protection under the law." "The request must be narrowly tailored to seek sealing only of sealable material, and must conform with Civil L.R. 79-5(d)." "Within 4 days of the filing of the Administrative Motion to File Under Seal, the Designating Party must file a declaration as required by subsection 79-5(d)(1)(A) establishing that all of the designated material is sealable."

Civ. L.R. 79-5(b). In part, Civ. L.R. 79-5(d) requires the submitting party to attach a "proposed order that is narrowly tailored to seal only the sealable material" which "lists in table format each document or portion thereof that is sought to be sealed," Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(B), and an "unreadacted version of the document" that indicates "by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version." Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1).

With these standards in mind, the court rules on the instant motions as follows:

Motion

Document to be Sealed

Result

Reason/Explanation

Docket No. 513-4

GSI's Reply in Support of Docket No. 478

Designations highlighted in blue SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 513-6

Exhibit A to GSI's Replyin Support of Docket No.478

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No.521-4

ISSI's Opposition to GSI's Motion to Compel ISSI to Produce 30(b)(6) Witness

Page 3: last line starting after "responsible for" through the end of the page; page 4: first word until "He had subsequently"; third whole paragraph after "UMI transferred toISSI" until "GSIquestioned him "; after "ISSI's Atris design"until "Ex. Q at 273-276"SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 521-6

Exhibit O to ISSI'sOpposition to GSI's Motion to Compel ISSI to Produce 30(b)(6) Witness

UNSEALED.

Unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 521-9

Exhibit Q to ISSI'sOpposition to GSI's Motion to Compel ISSI to Produce 30(b)(6) Witness

UNSEALED.

Unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 521-12

Exhibit S to ISSI'sOpposition to GSI's Motion to Compel ISSI to Produce 30(b)(6) Witness

UNSEALED.

Unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 523-4

GSI's Opposition to ISSI's Motion to Strike"Non-Trade Secret"Schematic Claim

Bottom of page 1 through top of page 2: only bold italicized text SEALED. Blue highlighted designations at bottom of page 2 to top of page 3 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 523-6

Exhibit B to GSI's Opposition to ISSI's Motion to Strike "Non-Trade Secret" Schematic Claim

Exhibit B at 7:2-8:17SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 527-4

GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

Designations highlighted in yellow on page 2 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information and supported by a declaration.

Docket No. 527-5

Exhibit B to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 527-7

Exhibit C to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

Designations highlightedin yellow SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Much of what ISSI requests to be sealed, in particular pages 291-295, is not attached toGSI's motion.

Docket No. 527-8

Exhibit D to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 527-9

Exhibit E to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 527-10

Exhibit F to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 527-11

Exhibit G to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 527-12

Exhibit H to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 527-14

Exhibit J to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 527-16

Exhibit K to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 527-18

Exhibit L to GSI's Reply Brief Seeking Order to Compel ISSI to Produce a Privilege Log and Documents ImproperlyWithheld

Designations highlightedin yellow SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-3

GSI's Opposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder ByUMI

Designations highlightedin yellow at 17:3-23, 26-29; 18:1-10 SEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information and supported by a declaration.

Docket No. 546-5

Exhibit 2 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 546-6

Exhibit 3 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-7

Exhibit 5 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 546-8

Exhibit 6 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-9

Exhibit 7 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-10

Exhibit 8 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 546-11

Exhibit 9 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-12

Exhibit 10 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-13

Exhibit 11 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-14

Exhibit 12 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-15

Exhibit 13 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-16

Exhibit 14 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-17

Exhibit 15 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-18

Exhibit 16 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-19

Exhibit 17 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 546-20

Exhibit 18 to GSI'sOpposition to ISSI's Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order and Joinder By UMI

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No.556-4

ISSI's Reply in Support of its Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 556-6

Exhibit J to ISSI's Reply in Support of its Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

Docket No. 556-8

Exhibit K to ISSI'sReply in Support of its Rule 37(b) Motion Re: GSI's Non-Compliance with Court Order

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-5

ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-7

Exhibit A to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-9

Exhibit B to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Unredacted version does not contain portions of the document which ISSI seeks to seal (pages 168-184); and otherwise is not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-11

Exhibit C to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

Docket No. 560-13

Exhibit D to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

Deposition Exhibits 502, 503, 504, 515 and 518 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-15

Exhibit E to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

53:7-54:23; 55:1-7; 55:18-56:18; 57:5-14; 57:23-58:2 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-17

Exhibit F to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

108:1-7; 108:21-109:10; 121:25-123:6; 124:10-125:1; 160:3-10; 162:5-22; 298:8-14; 299:7-24; 311:7-20; 311:22-25; 313:3-315:2; 315:24 SEALED; DepositionExhibits 349 and 353SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-19

Exhibit G to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

Deposition Exhibits 104, 113 and 116 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-21

Exhibit H to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Deposition Exhibit 307 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Remaining portions of the unredacted version do not contain some of the material which ISSI seeks to seal (for example, page 134) and do not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-23

Exhibit I to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

Deposition Exhibits 262,264, 269 and 275SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Remaining portions of the unredacted version do not contain some of the material which ISSI seeks to seal (for example, pages 119, 126 and 158) and do not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R.79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-25

Exhibit J to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Unredacted version does not contain some of the material which ISSI seeks to seal (pages 212, 218 and 219) and does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-27

Exhibit K to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

Deposition Exhibits 6, 7,8 and 9 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Remaining portions of the unredacted version do not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-29

Exhibit L to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

31:8-32:8; 32:17-21; 34:4-24; 36:8-11; 36:25-37:10; 38:15-17; 39:14-16; 39:22-25; 43:21-44:13; 44:25-45:5; 46:1-47:7; 47:13-25; 51:25-9; 57:2-53:13; 83:1-9; 83: 12-19; 84:1-17; 85:17-25; 105:21-23; 116:1-12. SEALED; deposition Exhibits 454 and 458SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-31

Exhibit M to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

50:2; 75:13; 75:16-20; 75:24-76:3; 148:2-19; 149:22-150:5; 150:12-15; 150:20-22; 151:2-8; 151:22-152:22; 156:7-9; 156:17; 180:3-9; 182:15-19; 185:7-10; 187:17-188:13; 253:9-16 SEALED; depositionExhibits 57, 72, 73, 74, 76 and 88 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-33

Exhibit N to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

Deposition Exhibits 186and 203 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information. Remaining portions of the unredacted version are not narrowly tailored to confidential business information, do not contain some of the material which ISSI seeks to seal (for example, pages121, 126, 269, 273 and276) and do not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-35

Exhibit O to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-37

Exhibit P to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-39

Exhibit Q to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

261:1-22 SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-41

Exhibit R to ISSI'sMotion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

Docket No. 560-43

Exhibit V to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-45

Exhibit W to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information, does not contain some of the material which ISSI seeks to seal (pages 275, 276,291 and 292) and theunredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D).

Docket No. 560-47

Declaration of Anand Bagchi to ISSI's Motionfor Summary Judgment

Paragraph 11 to the declaration SEALED; declaration Exhibits A, B, C, D, E and F SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-49

Declaration of Theresa Chen to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Declaration Exhibits A and B SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-51

Declaration of Ky Han to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Paragraphs 4, 7, 8 and 9 to the declaration SEALED; declarationExhibits A, B, C, D, E, F, G and H SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-53

Declaration of Scott Howarth to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Paragraph 4 to the declaration SEALED; declaration Exhibits A, B and C SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-55

Declaration of Ron Kalakuntla to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Declaration Exhibits A, B, C, D and E SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

Docket No. 560-57

Declaration of Scott Wu to ISSI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Paragraphs 8, 9, 10 and 11 to the declaration SEALED; declarationExhibits A, B and C SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-4

UMI's Motion for Summary Judgment

Highlighted portions at 2:20; 3:17-22; 4:7-18; 6:21-23; 6:13-16, 25-26; 8:1-14, 18-28; 9:1, 8-15; 10:27-28; 11:21-22; 13:1-5, 7-16, 21, 27-28; 14:1-16, 23-24, 26-27;15:26-27; 16:9-11SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-6

Exhibit 2 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-6

Exhibit 3 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED as in DocketNo. 194.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-7

Exhibit 5 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-7

Exhibit 6 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-7

Exhibit 7 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-7

Exhibit 8 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-8

Exhibit 15 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED as in DocketNo. 202.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-8

Exhibit 16 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-8

Exhibit 17 to Ramos Declaration

175:16-25; 241:9-11; 242:4-12, 21-22; 243:2-5, 9-11, 19-21; 264:6-24; 265:4-5, 7-13; 314:2-14; 336:6-11, 25 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 19 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED as in DocketNo. 130.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 20 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 21 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 22 to Ramos Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 23 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 24 to he Ramos Declaration

40:12-22; 41:4-14; 160:3-15; 162:5-24; 198:7-14 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-9

Exhibit 25 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-10

Exhibit 27 to Ramos Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-10

Exhibit 28 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-11

Exhibit 31 to Ramos Declaration

1:6-8:18 SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 33 to Ramos Declaration

3:20-4:9; 4:27-6:13; 7:1-20:3; 20:8-25:18; 28:21-31:4; 31:12-32:27SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 34 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 35 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 36 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 37 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 38 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 39 to Ramos Declaration

3:15-5:16; 5:25-7:7; 7:10-19:24; 20:6-25:23; 27:6-29:10; 31:8-18; 31:22-36:4; 38:3-39:19; 39:28-40:2; 40:17-19; 40:24-42:17; 42:22-43:24; 45:4-20; 45:27-46:16; 46:21-47:7 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-12

Exhibit 40 to Ramos Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

563-13

Exhibit 43 to Ramos Declaration

SEALED as in DocketNo. 109-3.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-5

Partial Motion for Summary Judgment against UMI

Highlighted portions at 1:9-13; 9:6-21; 10:1-20, 23, 27-28; 11:1-3; 14:15-16; 17:8-15; 18:4-7 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information and supported by a declaration.

568-7

Exhibit 1 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 48:19-25; 52:3- 53:10;53:23-25; 62:23-25;76:10-23; 76:25-77:8; 86:1-88:25; 104:1-105:1; 108:16-20; 140:21-141:5; 162:15-163:17; 257:15-258:2; 258:7-18; 259:20-260:25.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information and supported by a declaration.

568-8

Exhibit 2 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-9

Exhibit 3 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-11

Exhibit 4 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted designations sealed.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-12

Exhibit 6 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-13

Exhibit 7 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-14

Exhibit 8 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-15

Exhibit 9 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-16

Exhibit 10 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-17

Exhibit 11 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-18

Exhibit 12 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-20

Exhibit 14 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Portions sought to be sealed are not present in the document.

568-21

Exhibit 15 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-22

Exhibit 16 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-23

Exhibit 17 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-24

Exhibit 18 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-25

Exhibit 19 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-26

Exhibit 20 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-27

Exhibit 21 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-28

Exhibit 22 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-29

Exhibit 23 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-30

Exhibit 24 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-31

Exhibit 25 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-32

Exhibit 26 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-33

Exhibit 27 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-34

Exhibit 28 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-35

Exhibit 29 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-36

Exhibit 30 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential information.

568-37

Exhibit 30 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential information.

568-38

Exhibit 30 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential information.

568-39

Exhibit 31 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-40

Exhibit 32 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-41

Exhibit 33 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-42

Exhibit 34 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-43

Exhibit 35 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-44

Exhibit 36 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-46

Exhibit 37 to Kim Declaration

89:1-25 SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-47

Exhibit 39 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-48

Exhibit 40 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-49

Exhibit 41 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-50

Exhibit 42 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-51

Exhibit 43 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-52

Exhibit 44 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-53

Exhibit 45 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-55

Exhibit 46 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 60:2-14; 60:17-18; 60:20-25; 256:1-25 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-57

Exhibit 47 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 93:13-14; 93:19-21; 94:3-6; 94:18-20; 94:23-25; 104:16-22; 105:13-20 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-58

Exhibit 48 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-60

Exhibit 49 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-61

Exhibit 50 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-62

Exhibit 51 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-63

Exhibit 52 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-64

Exhibit 53 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-66

Exhibit 54 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 26:20-25; 28:1-15; 29:8-10, 17-25; 100:1-3, 10-11 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-67

Exhibit 55 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-68

Exhibit 56 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-69

Exhibit 57 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-70

Exhibit 58 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-71

Exhibit 59 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-72

Exhibit 60 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-73

Exhibit 60 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-74

Exhibit 61 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-75

Exhibit 62 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-76

Exhibit 63 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-77

Exhibit 64 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-78

Exhibit 65 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-79

Exhibit 66 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-80

Exhibit 66 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-81

Exhibit 66 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-82

Exhibit 67 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-83

Exhibit 68 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-84

Exhibit 69 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-85

Exhibit 70 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-86

Exhibit 71 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-87

Exhibit 72 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-88

Exhibit 73 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-89

Exhibit 74 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-90

Exhibit 75 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

568-91

Exhibit 76 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

568-93

Exhibit 79 to Kim Declaration

87:1-88:2; 88: 7-13; 88:18-20; 88:25- 89:25SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-5

Motion for Partial Summary Judgment

Highlighted portions at 3:11-12, 15-19, 27; 4:1-16, 18-20, 26; 5:1-6, 23-24; 6:7-12, 14-18, 21-24; 7:3-8, 15-21; 8:1-12, 14-18, 22-23; 9:3-17, 19-22; 10:1-11, 13-15, 17-19, 24; 14:7-17, 26-27; 16:11-16, 18-23; 17:1, 22-23; 20:18-19 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information and supported by a declaration.

570-6

Exhibit 1 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-8

Exhibit 2 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 49:1-25; p. 272:1-15 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information and supported by a declaration.

570-9

Exhibit 4 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-10

Exhibit 5 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-11

Exhibit 6 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-12

Exhibit 7 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-13

Exhibit 8 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-14

Exhibit 9 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-16

Exhibit 10 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-18

Exhibit 11 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-20

Exhibit 12 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 259:20-260:25 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information.

570-21

Exhibit 13 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-22

Exhibit 14 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-23

Exhibit 15 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-24

Exhibit 16 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-26

Exhibit 17 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 93:3-14, 19-21; 94:3-6; 94:18-20, 23-25; 174:7-176:13; 177:19-178:13; 260:1-25; 273:17-275:25; 279:1-25;280:2-25 SEALED; remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information.

570-27

Exhibit 18 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-28

Exhibit 19 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-29

Exhibit 20 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-30

Exhibit 21 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-31

Exhibit 22 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-32

Exhibit 23 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-33

Exhibit 24 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-35

Exhibit 25 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 44:10-16; 46:11-17; 47:15-18; 48:21-24; 49:18-21; 50:3-6; 50:13-51:5; 51:8-11; 52:7-8, 23-25; 53:11-14, 21-23; 54:1-5; 55:12-17; 56:8-12; 57:13-16; 59:20-24; 63:3-10; 66:3, 7-9; 70:8-11, 17-18; 71:5-7, 16-18; 72:5-6, 12-23; 74:13-20; 75:21-25; 76:3-25; 77:3-11, 21-25; 78:1-18; 80:24; 82:6-20;82:24-83:22; 84:9-10, 18-19, 22-23; 85:6-25;86:1, 5-17, 21-25; 87:1-89-21; 91:1-92:25; 366:1- 367:25 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information and supported by a declaration.

570-36

Exhibit 26 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-37

Exhibit 28 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-38

Exhibit 29 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-39

Exhibit 30 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-40

Exhibit 31 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-41

Exhibit 32 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-42

Exhibit 33 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-43

Exhibit 34 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-45

Exhibit 35 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 96:1-15; 98:10-23; 103:1-15, 24-25; 126:1-24; 272:7-8, 13-25 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information and supported by a declaration.

570-46

Exhibit 36 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-47

Exhibit 37 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-48

Exhibit 38 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-49

Exhibit 39 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declaration filed.

570-50

Exhibit 40 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-51

Exhibit 42 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-52

Exhibit 43 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-53

Exhibit 45 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-54

Exhibit 46 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-55

Exhibit 47 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-57

Exhibit 48 to Kim Declaration

Highlighted portions at 89:1-25; 172:1-173:14 SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portions narrowly tailored to confidential information and supported by a declaration.

570-58

Exhibit 49 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-59

Exhibit 50 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-60

Exhibit 51 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-61

Exhibit 52 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-62

Exhibit 53 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-63

Exhibit 54 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-64

Exhibit 55 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-66

Exhibit 56 to Kim Declaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-67

Exhibit 57 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-68

Exhibit 58 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-69

Exhibit 59 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-70

Exhibit 60 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-71

Exhibit 61 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-72

Exhibit 62 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-73

Exhibit 63 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-74

Exhibit 64 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-75

Exhibit 65 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-76

Exhibit 66 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-77

Exhibit 67 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-78

Exhibit 68 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-79

Exhibit 69 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-80

Exhibit 70 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-81

Exhibit 71 to Kim Declaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored to confidential business information.

570-82

Exhibit 72 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-83

Exhibit 73 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-85

Exhibit 74 to KimDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-86

Exhibit 75 to KimDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-87

Exhibit 77 to KimDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-88

Exhibit 78 to KimDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

570-89

Exhibit 79 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-90

Exhibit 80 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-91

Exhibit 81 to KimDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

570-92

Exhibit 82 to KimDeclaration

7:18-8:5 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-93

Exhibit 83 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-94

Exhibit 84 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-95

Exhibit 85 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-96

Exhibit 86 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

570-97

Exhibit 87 to KimDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

587-4

Exhibit A to BaskinDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

587-6

Exhibit B to BaskinDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

594-4

Opposition Brief toISSI's Motion to Strike

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

594-6

Declaration of Robert J.Murphy

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

594-8

Exhibit 1 to MurphyDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

594-9

Exhibit A toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-10

Exhibit D toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-12

Exhibit E toDharnidharkaDeclaration

Highlighted portions at256:5-12, 256:22-257:4SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-13

Exhibit F toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-15

Exhibit G toDharnidharkaDeclaration

Highlighted portions at200:13-15; 201:7-202:13SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-17

Exhibit I toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

594-18

Exhibit K toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

594-19

Exhibit L toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-20

Exhibit M toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

594-21

Exhibit N toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

614-3

Opposition of GSI toUMI's Ex Parte Letter toCourt

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

614-4

Declaration of BrookeKillian Kim

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

618-4

Motion to Amend CaseManagement Order andfor Leave to File ThirdAmended Complaint

Highlighted portions at1:21-26; 3:27-28; 4:11-15, 17-22; 7:9-16;11:21-23; 11:27-28;12:26-28; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation and supportedby a declaration.

618-5

Exhibit A toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

618-6

Exhibit C toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-7

Exhibit D toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-8

Exhibit E toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-9

Exhibit F toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-10

Exhibit G toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-11

Exhibit H toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-12

Exhibit I toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-13

Exhibit J toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-14

Exhibit M toDharnidharka Declaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

618-15

Exhibit N toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

618-17

Exhibit O toDharnidharkaDeclaration

Highlighted portions at7:24-8:4; 8:26-28; 10:1-4; 11:4-6; 11:11-12:3;13:7-9; 13:12-14:12;14:14-22; 18:6-10;22:11-21 SEALED;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-19

Exhibit Q toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-20

Exhibit S toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

618-21

Exhibit V toDharnidharkaDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

618-22

Exhibit W toDharnidharkaDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

618-24

Exhibit X toDharnidharkaDeclaration

Highlighted portions at13:23-14:2; 15:5-15:8;16:13-23, 26-28; 17:22-25; 18:4-14, 16-26;19:3-4; 19:6-20:2;21:18-28; 22:1-3; 26:12-23; 28:8-18; 28:23-24;29:22-25; 34:22-24;37:17-20; 37:26-38:10;39:1-3, 14-22; 40:1-3, 6-9, 13-18; 41:1-2, 11-13;42:1-3, 9-12, 19-22;43:15-23; 43:27-44:2;44:7-10, 14-16;remainder UNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation and supportedby a declaration.

636-4

UMI's Opposition to GSIMotion for PartialSummary Judgment

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-6

Exhibit B to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

636-8

Exhibit C to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-9

Exhibit C to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-10

Exhibit C to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-12

Exhibit D to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-14

Exhibit E to RamosDeclaration

77:1-8; 178:1-9; 178:18-180:3; 181:1-12;181:20-182:21; 183:6-25SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation and supportedby a declaration.

636-16

Exhibit F to RamosDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-18

Exhibit G to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

636-23

Exhibit I to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-25

Exhibit J to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

636-26

Exhibit J to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

636-27

Exhibit J to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

636-29

Exhibit K to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

No supporting declarationfiled.

636-31

Exhibit L to RamosDeclaration

36:15-37:4; 38:11-18;39:16-40:1; 40:12-22;41:4-12; 42:2- 10; 46:4-23; 47:21-48:6; 48:12-19: 48:25-49:17; 50:17-51:5; 51:16-52:4; 53:3-19; 53:22-54:5; 54:6-15;54:16-25; 63:3-16;64:21-66:1; 66:9-66:25;69:6-10; 69:14-24;70:25-71:8; 72:20-25;73:1-6; 73:17-74:4;75:15-23; 75:25-76:22;77:10-25; 78:14-80:12;80:18-81:25; 82:1-83:4;84:22-85:7; 86:17-87:13; 87:23-88:2; 88:7-13; 88:18-20; 88:25-89:20; 91:12-19; 91:24-92:2; 92:11-21; 92:22-93:3; 94:2-8; 94:11-95:17; 96:5-14; 97:4-98:11; 101:6-12; 107:5-15; 107:21-25; 108:1-7;108:21-109:10; 114:12-115:19; 121:25-123:7;124:10-125:1; 129:6-19;129:21-130:3; 130:7-131:10; 131:16-23;155:23-156:3; 160:3-15SEALED; remainderUNSEALED.

Only sealed portionsnarrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-33

Exhibit M to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-36

Exhibit O to RamosDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-38

Exhibit P to RamosDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-40

Exhibit Q to RamosDeclaration

SEALED.

Narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-42

Exhibit R to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

636-44

Exhibit S to RamosDeclaration

UNSEALED.

Not narrowly tailored toconfidential businessinformation.

The unredacted version does not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D). The court nevertheless considers the motion in the interest of judicial economy.

GSI's certificate of service (Docket No. 530) does not indicate that GSI served its declaration on Cisco (the designating party) as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(e). As such, Cisco may file a declaration in support of documents referenced in Docket No. 527 by July 13, 2015.

The unredacted versions of the documents in Docket No. 556 do not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D). Additionally, GSI filed its declaration (Docket No. 567) in support of ISSI's motion to seal (Docket No. 556) more than four days after ISSI served GSI with the motion, violating Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Despite these deficiencies, the court considers both ISSI's motion and GSI's declaration in the interest of judicial economy.

The court notes, however, that GSI did not file a declaration to support sealing direct quotes from Exhibit K contained in ISSI's reply brief.

The unredacted versions of the documents in Docket No. 560 do not "indicate, by highlighting or other clear method, the portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version" as required by Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(D). Additionally, GSI and Cisco's declarations in support of ISSI's motion to seal (Docket Nos. 578 and 608) were both filed more than four days after ISSI served its motion, violating Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). Despite these deficiencies, the court considers both ISSI's motion and the supporting declarations only where in the interest of judicial economy. --------

SO ORDERED.

Dated: June 26, 2015

/s/_________

PAUL S. GREWAL

United States Magistrate Judge


Summaries of

GSI Technology, Inc. v. United Memories Inc.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN JOSE DIVISION
Jun 26, 2015
Case No.: 5:13-cv-01081-PSG (N.D. Cal. Jun. 26, 2015)
Case details for

GSI Technology, Inc. v. United Memories Inc.

Case Details

Full title:GSI TECHNOLOGY, INC., Plaintiff, v. UNITED MEMORIES, INC., et al.…

Court:UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA SAN JOSE DIVISION

Date published: Jun 26, 2015

Citations

Case No.: 5:13-cv-01081-PSG (N.D. Cal. Jun. 26, 2015)