Opinion
September 12, 1962.
November 15, 1962.
Criminal Law — Sentence — Sentence of minor by court of quarter sessions to Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill — Recommendation of sentencing judge that prisoner be kept at industrial school until twenty-one years of age — Subsequent parole and violation of parole — Service of remainder of original sentence — Transfer to State Correctional Institution at Graterford.
1. In a habeas corpus proceeding, in which it appeared that, although relator was only seventeen years of age at the time of sentence, after pleading guilty to a charge of receiving stolen goods, because of a long history of serious delinquency and prior commitments to institutions, he was sentenced in the court of quarter sessions to the Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill; that, in imposing sentence, the court recommended that relator be kept there until twenty-one years of age; and that relator was released by the Board of Parole about two years later, was again arrested for receiving stolen goods and sentenced to jail, and was thereafter committed to the State Correctional Institution at Graterford; relator's contentions that he should be released because (a) he was sentenced to imprisonment only until he was twenty-one years of age and was now over that age, (b) the sentence was for only three years, and he had served all of that time, and (c) he was being confined at the Graterford institution instead of the industrial school, to which he had been sentenced, were Held to be without merit.
2. In such case, it was Held that, although his original commitment to the industrial school as a juvenile expired under the Juvenile Court Law when he became twenty-one years of age, he was not thereafter serving under the juvenile court commitment but under the sentence imposed in the court of quarter sessions, the sentence being for a maximum term of five years — the maximum penalty for the offense for which he was sentenced.
3. It was Held that the statement of the sentencing judge was not an attempt to limit the sentence to the industrial school to the time of the convict's minority, but was merely a recommendation to the authorities charged with parole that they should not release the prisoner on parole until he became twenty-one years of age; and the prisoner, having been paroled and having violated his parole, could be legally imprisoned until he had served the five year sentence.
4. The prison authorities have the power to transfer prisoners from the Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill to the State Correctional Institution at Graterford.
Before RHODES, P.J., ERVIN, WRIGHT, WOODSIDE, WATKINS, MONTGOMERY, and FLOOD, JJ.
Appeal, No. 310, Oct. T., 1962, from order of Court of Common Pleas of Clearfield County, Feb. T., 1962, No. 37, in case of Commonwealth ex rel. Harry Phillips v. David N. Myers, Superintendent. Order affirmed.
Habeas corpus.
Order entered dismissing petition, opinion by PENTZ, P.J. Relator appealed.
Harry Phillips, appellant, in propria persona.
David S. Ammerman, Assistant District Attorney, and Eugene G. Kitko, District Attorney, for appellee.
Submitted September 12, 1962.
This is an appeal from the order of the Court of Common Pleas of Clearfield County refusing a writ of habeas corpus sought by a prisoner now being detained in the State Correctional Institution at Graterford.
The prisoner was transferred to Graterford from the Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill, to which he was sentenced on July 29, 1958, after pleading guilty to the charge of Receiving Stolen Goods. The prisoner was only 17 years of age at the time of this sentence, but because of a long history of serious delinquency and prior commitments to institutions, including the Pennsylvania Industrial School, he was sentenced in the court of quarter sessions. The record shows that in imposing the sentence the court said, "It is the recommendation of the court that he be kept there [the Pennsylvania Industrial School] until 21 years of age." He was released, however, by the Pennsylvania Board of Parole on September 23, 1960. See Act of August 6, 1941, P.L. 861, § 31, as amended, 61 P. S. § 331.31. The following month he was again arrested for receiving stolen goods and sentenced to six months in jail. He was thereafter committed to the Graterford institution as a parole violator, and is now serving the remaining part of the sentence imposed July 29, 1958.
He petitioned for his release on the ground that he was sentenced to imprisonment only until he was 21 years of age and that he is now over that age; on the ground that the sentence was for only 3 years, and he has served all of that time, and on the ground that he is now being confined at the State Correctional Institution at Graterford instead of the Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill, to which he was sentenced.
His contentions are without merit. Although his original commitment to the Industrial School as a juvenile expired under the Juvenile Court Law when he became 21 years of age, he is not now serving under the juvenile court commitment, but under a sentence imposed in the court of quarter sessions. This sentence was imposed under the Act of April 28, 1887, P.L. 63, § 4, as amended by the Act of June 30, 1951, P.L. 974, § 3, and further amended by the Act of July 29, 1953, P.L. 1447, 61 P. S. § 483, 484, 485. It was for a maximum term of five years, — the maximum penalty for the offense for which he was sentenced. See Act of June 24, 1939, P.L. 872, as amended, 18 Pa.C.S.A. § 4817.
Act of June 2, 1933, P.L. 1433, § 12, 11 P. S. § 254.
The sentencing judge in the court of quarter sessions lacked statutory authority to limit the sentence to the Pennsylvania Industrial School to the time of the convict's minority (See 61 P. S. § 484, supra), and the judge made no effort to limit the sentence to that period. He was merely recommending to the authorities charged with parole that they should not release the prisoner on parole until he became 21 years of age. The sentence was for five years, and the prisoner having been paroled and having violated his parole, can be legally imprisoned until he has served the five year sentence.
The prison authorities have the power to transfer prisoners from the Pennsylvania Industrial School at Camp Hill to the State Correctional Institution at Graterford. Com. ex rel. Clawges v. Claudy, 173 Pa. Super. 410, 98 A.2d 225 (1953); Com. ex rel. Reed v. Maroney, 194 Pa. Super. 514, 168 A.2d 800 (1961). See also Com. ex rel. Stranahan v. Banmiller, 190 Pa. Super. 420, 154 A.2d 307 (1959).
Order affirmed.