Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York July 2006 casesState v. LuisAnderson v. Our LadyPeople v. DunbarFuhrmann v. City of BinghamtonMtr. of KadeemPeople v. EleyPeople v. FullerPlatinum RX, LLC v. PosePatricia v. N.Y. State UrbanPeople v. UthmanMtr. of DevonnaPeople v. ComfortPeople v. N.YPeople v. AnthonyPeople v. Kathy XX.People v. N.YClaim of Cagle v. Judge Motor Corp.Page v. PageMtr. of CalebState v. LobleyIn the Haggerty v. Queens Cou. Rep. ComPeople v. BoschPetrocelli v. MarrelliMtr. OnondagaPeople v. ArringtonLamy v. PierreHalim v. StateAvella v. BattBraun v. County of OrangePeople v. Khuong Dinh PhamRobin Beal v. Jeffrey BealMatter of Sharone TElena v. AbbateCarlson v. Suit-Kote Corp.People v. NicholsonYenom Core v. 155 WoosterCoppage v. Hacking Corp.People v. AnonymousMtr. of Connolly v. Rye SchoolPeople v. N.YMtr. of JohnNapoli v. AmbusTower v. All State Ins. Co.David v. NicoleShanley v. WelchWalker v. AdamsState v. TaylorPeople v. ThompsonMtr. of Ins. v. DepalmaFUNG v. JAPANMtr. of HelenCynthia Diaz v. EminentRetamozzo v. Ny. Dept. of Corre. ServKevin v. Point Dedicated ServsMtr. of CindyWilliams v. SuffolkPeople v. Darrell MackPeople v. ThomasDavis-Elliott v. New York City Department of EducationJosephine v. MainieroHancher v. HancherVaval v. NyracTitle Ins. Com. v. PascalePeople v. Alex VielmanFallati v. MackeyPalma v. HarnickPeople v. BarvilleLisi v. CocoMatthew v. SuccessCavota v. PeriniPeople v. SharonPeople v. JohnnieTodd v. Wayne Coopera. Insu. ComMtr. of RobertTrust v. OakesWyant v. Prof. Furn. Equip. Inc.Tornheim v. GeorgePeople v. GanoeSUB v. NATIONALDavid v. TribunalMtr. of BellPeople v. GarnerPeople v. BellMoore v. GoordState v. SelwynPeople v. PaulKoslosky v. KhorrmianHarris v. City of GenevaDianna v. ErnestIn re BaxPeople v. RowlandState v. DarylState v. EricPeople v. HornMaxson v. BrentwoodSheldon v. LindenWalker v. DeriggiJoseph v. CarolSidney v. CantwellCarter v. ShahRent-A-Car v. HoldersPeople v. VanhoesenRios v. StarrettFrances v. New YorkBusiness v. WagnerRaena v. MichelleBP Air Conditioning Corp. v. One Beacon Insurance GroupLenhard v. Patrons Co-op. Ins. ComPeople v. MadisonLinarello v. Colin Ser. SysPeople v. CarterPeople v. La PorteStenberg v. DavisPomietlasz v. SmithBzduch v. Bovis Constr. ComPeople v. N.YMichale v. PediatricPeople v. AdamusPeople v. SearsPeople v. BryantJoe v. GrantCostner v. GoordPeople v. ThompsonHepnandez v. ComGeorge v. BrendaMtr. of RhondalynAlex Othman v. Terrence LandPeople v. Cody A.RPeople v. AmesSchreiber-Cross v. StatePEOPLE OF v. JEF FREYPeople v. Troy HectorPeople v. RuffinsPeople v. StephensN.Y. v. Inc. ComKessler v. KesslerMtr. of LynchPeople v. RuddyGoldberger v. JoelTesla v. JonesChrisler v. SpencerNorth v. KaplanBurns v. StrangerMaltsev v. Ny. Division of Human RightsJurgielewicz v. JurgielewiczMullen v. LaufferPeople v. ComfortWaki Milling v. BerbaryPeople v. LonnieState v. EttariRicky v. DennisonGoldman v. Simon Property Group, Inc.People v. JohnsonHacker v. QuestarPeople v. BentonRogers v. Zurich Life Ins. ComMtr. of YasinPeople v. ScottPena v. Limousine Service Corp.People v. WrightMidura v. 740 Corp. LLCBremner v. GearZupa v. Paradise Point Ass'nDurante Bros. v. St. John'sPeople v. BrinkJohnson v. Peconic DinerTracy v. FaginSpearhead Inc. v. Spearhead Sys. ConsulDanne v. Otis Elev. CorpoStefanescu v. City of New YorkMatthew v. LakelandGagliano v. County of NassauElite Gold Inc. v. TT Jewelry Outlet Corp.William v. DunkirkTraders Co. v. AST Sportswear, Inc.Donna Kk. v. Barbara IKatherine v. 1652 AssociatesMtr. of LawrenceMtr. of KalichmanPeople v. WilliamState v. JulioPeople v. ScottMtr. of TimiaState v. MelissaPeople v. TriplettGomez v. RodriguezPeople v. N.YCostner v. GoordPeople v. Ramel WalkerGavigan v. BuffaloPeople v. BryantMtr. of WilliamsDeluca v. BlancoPeople v. BoyerChernoff v. ChernoffPeople v. SimmonsSingh v. AtakhanianDicke v. JamesBlendex v. Mount Sinai Yacht ClubJames v. ClerkSkrypek v. BennettZukowski v. GokhbergGajjar v. ShahPeople of v. Patric K BryanMtr. Tavarez v. SamanthaWoszczyna v. BJW AssociatesMartin v. GeicoPeople v. AngelPhilip v. KoulsDiane v. BryanPeople v. HargroveState v. DannyMtr. of JonathanMontefiore v. Liberty Mut. Ins. ComIn re GrossmanPeople v. MartinezState v. JosephKumar v. TisackPeople v. DavisGerold v. Companion Life Insurance CompanyState v. ReeseAlbany Prep. Char. Sch. v. City of AlbanyPeople v. WigginsVialet v. RiverbayPeople v. KunzPeople v. JamesZichron v. Lillian IlowitzStark v. City of New YorkPeople v. TaylorPeople v. N.YAmy L.M. v. Kevin M.M.Keith v Cindy HolmesAshley v. CharlottePeople v. DaleyRutkunas v. StoutBrain v. BennettMcClain v. GrossoCarla v. HardyBreco Envtl. Contractors v. Town of SmithtownJoanne Ewan. v. Verdi Equi. Inc.Bendiner v. FiretogMtr. of PassalacquaFortunato v. Woman'sCopp v. City of ElmiraFuel v. Fire Insure. ComReade v. JohnGordon v. EsopusAnderson v. Beth Israel Medical CenterSuffolk v. EquitiesState v. Corey428 E. 66TH St. LLC v. MeirowitzPeople v. SoevynPrzybylak v. BellPeople v. HarrisPeople v. WynterMtr. of RebeccaPeople v. SmithPeople v. WilsonPeople v. RumolaPeople v. YakimPeople v. ReidOboler v. City of N.YGeneral v. GeneralPeople v. AbreuLewis v. BoyceGiles v. DennisonHygiene v. DennisDavis v. OnondagaPeople v. HofelichMutual Automobile Ins. v. ProdhodkoPeople v. MarksMeridian v. GeicoKeith v. AlexPeople v. GraeberIannone v. IannoneFrost v. GoldbergClifford v. WoodlawnFlynn v. Toys "R" Us, Inc.William v. KafkaJoseph v. Marissa BrooksWillie v. GoordPeople v. PorchPeople v. ScottPeople v. DaldryPeople v. StokesState v. JohnPeople v. RollePeople v. BermudezMtr. of HorrellMitchell v. GlennLloyd v. CommissionerAngelo v. KoloskiArm v. 2148 Ocean Avenue, LLCHigh Point of Hartsdale I Condominium v. AOI Construction, Inc.Lutz v. GoldstoneGarcia v. DobsonPerez v. MontanezPeople v. ChatmonPeople v. DorisStephanie v. CommackMckinney v. MckineyTorianne v. SteubenPeople v. Lisle-CannonMtr. of BowlbyMartelle v. City of N.YRKO Properties, Ltd. v. BoymelgreenWalters v. PapanastassiouBuywise v. John A. HarrisClifford R. Gray, Inc. v. LeChase Construction Services, LLCCoque v. WildflowerThomson v. RubensteinPeople v. Alan LancePeople v. ThristPeople v. FaganPeople v. WilsonEast New York v. GuraryPeople v. WilsonPeople v. N.YCampbell v. PoolePeople v. MichaelRamos v. Triboro Coa. Corp.Nicholas v. EPO-Harvey Apartments, Ltd.People v. WashingtonGrune v. ParoleRessis v. CapannaTucker v. NuttallVialva v. McMillanPeople v. PierreGreenbaum v. HershmanPeople v. PeckMtr. of SharardPEOPLE v. NYState v. EdwinKashelkar v. DaveMtr. of BurrowsMiller v. MarchuskaPeople v. AbdullahLotardo v. MaryKuhl v. PiatelliJackson v. LaumatJuan Ramos v. Jaime RamirezLSPA Enter., Inc. v. Jani-King of N.Y., Inc.Pagliaro v. PagliaroCruz v. N.Y. City Transit AuthMtr. of HenningPeople v. DjanieFlush v. AlbertRuth v. RochesterPeople v. MorenoIn re the Estate of UhlState v. BogueZupa v. Zoning Board of Appeals of Town of SoutholdPeople v. BermudezThompson v. OttiliePeople v. Carolyn WarmusPeople v. McculloughPeople v. CedricRobert v. StatePeople v. CrosbyPeople v. N.YPeople v. BoykinMtr. MildredState v. LuisMtr. of BernardMatter of LeeStillman v. KalikowMatter of DalyHollow Road Farms, Inc. v. Quo Vadis International, LLCCraig Ellis v. Air ConditioningMtr. of LisaPeople v. AckridgeEklund v. PinkeyAtlantic v. Joyce InterModzelewska v. City of New YorkBerlin v. KopmanJones v. Allstate Insu. CompJohnson v. Title NorthAnita Martin v. Lafayette MorrisonLumbermens v. RestaurantRicher v. StateWaldman v. KiryasWeinstein v. David BreitbartPeople v. ConwayMtr. of Catskill Reg. v. StateRudolf v. DachsMaguire v. BeyerPeople v. SchermerhornMtr. of DonteMtr. of DanielleTechnologies v. Intersil Corp.N.Y. and Pres. Hos. v. ComThomas Newman Regent Contracting Corp.Daniels v. GlennCiccone v. GrassiPeople v. MelvinPeople v. ErickLevy v. MorganMichael v. LindaCross Deve. v. Travelers ComSanto v. Government Employees Ins. Co.Myers v.Friends of Shenendehowa Crew, Inc.Douglas v. Sam Greco Constn. Inc.Fund v. CarterAhmed v. Momart Discount Store, Ltd.Hinkson v. HinksonJorbel v. KopkoLijo v. City of New YorkMerchants v. WeaverPeople v. McFarleyMtr. of SeviroliHughes v. CaiCampbell v. City of New YorkMtr. of MillsGilmore v. GarveyBruce v. ProctorMoira v. LancasterJoe v. EllenPeople v. SillsCommissioners of the State Insurance v. Tom L. La Mere & Associates, Inc.State v. JamalPeople v. UnieshaPeople v. CosbyAlexander v. Jean LeonPalmieri v. New York State Department of Environmental ConservationPeople v. BarryReilly v. CarrollwoodPeople v. N.YAlicea v. SelskyGibbons v. GibbonsMtr. of MichaelState v. MichaelPeople v. NugentPeople v. WardMtr. of TalbottClaim of Lopez v. Superflex, Ltd.People v. ThomasMtr. of WaltersIn re Ida EE.People v. DudleyShehata v. ShehataMurin v. SchwalenPeople v. MaddoxMancini v. Hardscrabble Commons AssociatesFryer v. Maimonides Medical CenterDlamond v. ShameakaQuintana v. RupaBhola v. SmallLopez v. MelidisCollado v. PinedaMtr. of D'Satmar v. KahanaSmith v. Tenshore RealtyCity Ny. v. Safeoc Ins. Com. of AmericaShore v. LumbermensPeople v. SyrellPeople v. AlexanderFair Price Med. v. Elrac IncKevin v. Point Dedicated ServsPeople v. VenablePeople v. SenecaHalime v. CokyukselTerri v. EmerlingMtr. of CarmodyOdosia v. Kennedy Hou. Owners Inc.Mtr. of Lutz v. GoldstoneNaylor v. Knoll Farms of Suffolk County, Inc.Cataract Metal Finish v. Centimark Corp.Andre-Long v. VerizonMtr. of WilliamGrayson v. BryanMtr. of JohnCurro v. GoordChristine Newcomb v. Guptill Holding Corp.People v. GreenIn re April C.Rakiecki v. StateMtr. of EstateSmith v. MooreCouluris v. Harbor Boat Realty Inc.Glenville Police Benevol. v. Clarence MosherWilliams v. Jeffmar Manag. Corp.Kearney v. Neurosurgeons of N.YWarsaski v. SpiegelPeople v. SotoMcDonald v. Zoning BoardThomas Newman Bison Electrical Ser. Corp.Security v. TracieChris v. GoordAnthony v. StatePeople v. Jeffrey WardSalvador v. PlanningMtr. of CynthiaPeople v. HarrisLeibowitz v. HeimanMtr. OnondagaHoffman v. BernsteinPeople v. StantonCNP Mechanical, Inc. v. AngelloPeople v. ColeEberwein v. NewburghUbaydov v. Kenny's Fleet MainState Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. v. JacksonPeople v. LinnanPeople v. ConnellPeople ex rel. Pruitt v. ZonMtr. OnondagaPeople v. TurnerRadiator Inc. v. N.Y. Human RightsCardone v. City of N.YNappi v. University HospitalKevin v. Tradescape Co.People v. BarberPeople v. SimmonsMtr. of MatthewGutman v. GutmanDima v. Morrow Street Associates, LLCPeople v. PriceHackbarth v. McDonalds Corp.Luis v. JoanMartocci v. DanielPeople v. RiveraSchiff v. StatePortlette v. ToussaintPeople v. VigilPeople v. TerrancePeople v. N.YLonner v. Simon Property Group, Inc.People v. AdamsBailey v. WalshBennett v. FergusonState ex rel. Harkavy v. ConsilvioPeople v. SmithGeneral Motors Acce. Corp. v. VucichPeople v. PittmanPeople v. ClaudioRuzicka v. RuzickaPeople v. HectorPeople v. SmithGopie v. HenriquezPeople v. Brian RiordanPeople v. NolanWilliam v. SusanKevin v. HeatherPeople v. RobertState v. WalkerPeople v. CruzMtr. of DonavannSilva v. VizcarrondoAnonymous v. AnonymousFeldman v. RailcarPeople v. MarkellPeople v. WilliamsPeople v. BoykinMichael v. DennisonSelective Ins v. Merchants Ins. GroupState v. DallasRAD Ventures Corp. v. ArtukmacMatter of Sharone TKryzhanovskaya v. City N.YMtr. of CavalloSneed v. SchackPerez v. PaljevicHigh Point of Hartsdale I Condominium v. AOI ConstructionDevey v. State of N.YSurgical Design Corp. v. CorreaState v. PaytonMtr. of ShawndalayaSicurella v. EmbroAnita Scala v. Anthony ScalaRea v. GallagherBrennan v. SinskiPeople v. BrownPeople v. DerrellWilloughby v. WebsterEvelyn v. DefilippisPeople v. AttfieldMtr. of AckermannPeople v. Roy VelsorPeople v. SanchezCucci v. CucciPeople v. CokeC.B. v. HewbergState v. DavidMtr. Rufus DDeborah v. LeeChacha v. ClementPatrick v. Long Island RailPeople v. CarterPeople v. KozielPeople v. GibbsSchupak v. MarbletownDawson v. Joel M. GoldbergDellagatta v. McGillicuddyPadovan v. Teddy'sCity Police v. OswegoMatone v. Sycamore RealTornheim v. GeorgeOrenzo v. Mass, Inc.Wheeler v. Grande'Vie Senior Living CommunityLodovichetti v. BaezRotondi v. DrewesDukett v. WilsonTaussig v. Luxury CarsState v. TopolskiGinther v. ScintaO'Mara v. City of N.YPeople v. AbuizMtr. of JasonTafari v. GlennPeople v. CharlesPalmieri v. Ny. State DeparCavota v. Perini CorporationJerome v. ElizabethRuddock v. BolandPeople v. CabralMtr. of Ellwanger v. EllwangerPeople v. ArmstrongJupiter Envtl. Serv. v. Graystone ConstrMtr. of CostantinoDawn M.L. v. Gary A.MPeople v. OrtizO'Leary v. Clean Cut Carpentry, Inc.People v. ChurchKay Foun. v. S F Tow. Ser. of State IslandCampbell-Lopez v. CruzPeople v. WallaceLubitz v. Village of ScarsdaleWilliams v. Stevenson Commons AssociatesAshley v. Robert MitchellAstree v. Ny. City Transit AuthBranham v. LoewsPerkins v. Dryden Ambulance Inc.Evans v. City of N.YMoran v. CarboneAlben v. Mid-Hudson Medical Group, P.C.People v. KoehlerMtr. of CynthiaAcevedo v. York International Corp.Searle v. Cayuga Med. Ctr. at IthacaPeople v. GandhiPeople v. Akuan JohnsonMtr. of GreenbergerState v. ArthurPeople v. DiazPeople v. BellFarms v. BrookhavenPeople v. CuevasPeople v. D'AmicoMLB Industries, Inc. v. East Greenbush Central School DistrictBallow v. BraistedPeople v. DiggsPeople v. YangShapard v. ZonKirkorov v. RobertUniversal v. PeerlessPeople v. James WalkerPeople v. Moreno TrinidadPeople v. BowensMtr. of MarilynReddy v. 369 Lexington Ave. Co., L.P.Felice v. TownInternational v. Tax AppealsTora v. GVP AGPeople v. IsgarRamirez v. ParachePeople v. DennisState v. NelsonPeople v. TrumbachPeople v. N.YFlynn v. FedcapPeople v. CampassoJorbel v. KopkoCassandra v. DumondMtr. Michael Goldman v. New YorkSpira v. Ny. Housing AuthReal Estate Llc. v. Zoning BoardSheldon v. GoordMark A.P. v. Penny E.OHernandez v. Ten Ten ComPadovano v. MassapequaMtr. of MorgaineHart v. AllieHcmillian v. RizzoRochester City Scl. v. N.Y. State Edn. DepatNM IQ LLC v. OmniSky Corp.Berardi v. Coney Island Avenue Realty, LLCMtr. Sztabnik v. New YorkRadish v. RodriquezCardillo v. XenakisPeople v. WebbBenitez v. MileskiJackson v. JacksonBreco Envtl. Contractors v. Town of SmithtownCramer v. SaboDoyle v. SiddoMtr. of JosephCedrone v. Bon Secours Community HospitalPasieka v. N.YPeople v. IvyKelly v. KellyPeople v. RushSteblein v. BernardVenuti v. NewburghPeople v. TuttPeople v. PackerSargent v. Klein Eversoll Inc.TRISTAR v. RAD ENERGY CORPGathers v. GoordSimmons v. TaylorWilliams v. GoordDelaware v. PontoneroRosana v. LandoPeople v. Alicea-CruzMorse v. FrancesNORA ESCH. v. KOHL'S DEPARTafari v. SelskyBryant v. Transit AuthorityHamilton v. AndersonFarnsworth v. Brookside Cons. Co. Inc.Brett v. Mid-WestchesterBarber v. BPS Venture, Inc.Cahill v. Tribor. BridgeCubas v. MartinezAstrel v. YarboroughJones v. W + M AutoPeople v. JoseCit Group v. RiddleMtr. of AprilSinger v. NeriWiese v. JamesPeople v. StrongPeople v. TorresPeople v. N.YGuerin v. City of N.YMtr. of RamseyPeople v. BorisPeople v. SandraPeople v. BibbsPeople v. Darrell MackState v. JohnGaldamez v. TaylorRessis v. CapannaAmericaConsultants v. Cedar Income Fund Partnership L.P.People v. FootmanJennifer v. SelkirkGavrielatos v. HotelHoffman v. HoffmanJupiter Envtl. Serv. v. Graystone Cons. Corp.Page v. PageFrankson v. Philip Morris IncorpMtr. of Mccabe v. Town of ClarkstownKormusis v. Jeffrey Gardens Apartment Corp.Powell v. AladePerlongo v. Park City 3 & 4 Apartments, Inc.Mtr. of Noble