Patent Trial and Appeal Board July 2020 casesMalte NeussSchaeffler Technologies AG & Co. KGWentink, Maarten Menzo.CARRIER CORPORATIONClearSign Combustion CorporationInternational Business Machines CorporationApple Inc.Ostergren, Brian Hunter. et al.ARM LIMITEDSpan-America Medical Systems, Inc.The Boeing CompanyRosemount Aerospace Inc.SABIC Global Technologies B.V. Akimasa Ichikawa et al.Uniloc 2017 LLCMICROSOFT CORPORATIONThermiGen, LLCSoitecPike, Mark et al.WEATHERHAVEN GLOBAL RESOURCES LTD.APPLE INC.Imagination Technologies LimitedLundberg, Brock M.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONASML NETHERLANDS B.V.C. Kumar et al.Infineum International LimitedBSH HAUSGERAETE GMBHAntecip Bioventures II LLCChristopher Migliaccio et al.WATLOW ELECTRIC MANUFACTURING COMPANYSymrise AGGoogle Inc.VLSi Technology LLCBritax Childcare Pty LtdUNIVERSITY OF STRATHCLYDEThe Mosaic CompanyYaacov SHIRAZICCS Technology, Inc.CONTINENTAL AUTOMOTIVE FRANCE et al.The Regents of the University of CaliforniaFord Global Technologies, LLCSymrise AGMasterCard International IncorporatedEdwin Earl. FreedBell Northern Research, LLC, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Hilco Patent Acquisition 56, LLC, which is owned by both Hilco IP Merchant Capital, LLC, and Hilco, Inc.ADP, LLCnuTonomy Inc.Seki, KoheiMark Etzel et al.Viacom International, Inc.Jonathan M. Griebel et al.Philip Young et al.Virtual Sports Training, Inc.Bruker Daltonik GmbHHitachi Metals, Ltd.Milwaukee Electric Tool CorporationShockwave Medical, Inc.Lundberg, Brock M.Lee, Eugene M.Siemens AktiengesellschaftTenacious Holdings, Inc.PPG Industries Ohio, Inc.Advanced Micro Devices, Inc.eBay Inc.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY L.P.Greenthread LLCMedline Industries, Inc.The Procter & Gamble CompanyROBERT BOSCH GMBHOregon State UniversityCecil Sunder et al.CORNING INCORPORATEDHerman, KentCalendar Research LLCEVONIK DEGUSSA GMBHAmazon Technologies, Inc.Anthony Mark. Phillips et al.DANGEVILLE, NICOLAS et al.Adobe Inc.TBI Innovations, LLC et al.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCThermiGen, LLCSole Supports, Inc.ABBOTT POINT OF CARE, INC.LARRY VERBOWSKIAsavie R&D LimitedLG Display Co., Ltd.Schexnaider, Neil Patrick. et al.France Behr et al.Apple Inc.Douglas M. OkuniewiczHEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.TriTeq Lock and Security LLCMalte NeussLoving, Scott M. et al.Fresenius Medical Care Holdings, Inc.CUPP Computing ASInternational Business Machines CorporationQualcomm IncorporatedInternational Business Machines CorporationUNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONVisa International Service AssociationGreenthread LLCThe Procter & Gamble CompanyEVONIK DEGUSSA GMBHCorning IncorporatedEMC IP Holding Company LLCZietchick Research Institute, LLCThe Procter & Gamble CompanyThe Procter & Gamble CompanySinghal, Tara Chand.MTU Aero Engines AGTHE GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER COMPANYPalo Alto Research Center IncorporatedKING.COM LIMITEDNICIRA, INC.L'OR¿ALHuntsman International LLCMark Bischoff et al.Garg, Vibhav et al.Medlmpact Healthcare Systems, Inc.INTEGRAL DEVELOPMENT CORP.Edwin Earl. FreedWEATHERHAVEN GLOBAL RESOURCES LTD.SoitecDavid C. ReardonRobin Dillard et al.Vrabete, BradeBay Inc.Cameron Solutions, Inc.Motorola Mobility LLCFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCGraphic Packaging International, Inc.Avaya Inc.Barbour, Jesse et al.Steven J. Bullied et al.Landmark Graphics CorporationMModal Services Ltd.Google, LLC Rick L. Adkins et al.BROADWAY FINANCIAL TECHNOLOGY LIMITEDMILWAUKEE ELECTRIC TOOL CORPORATIONHitachi Metals, Ltd.Andreas Etelközi et al.Arbutus Biopharma CorporationTejal Desai et al.Sonoco Development, Inc.Dropbox, Inc.Bell Northern Research, LLC, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Hilco Patent Acquisition 56, LLC, which is owned by both Hilco IP Merchant Capital, LLC, and Hilco, Inc.Marsh, Eugene P. et al.VALEO SYSTEMES D'ESSUYAGEAdvanced Micro Devices, Inc.HEWLETT PACKARD INDIGO BVEqualum Ltd.Barbour, Jesse et al.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCCruz-Hernandez, Juan Manuel.The Toronto-Dominion BankMarkus Kostrzewa et al.Uniloc Luxembourg S.A.BEMIS COMPANY, INC.Karl Zuercher et al.InVue Security Products, Inc.Axis ABNIPPON TELEGRAPH AND TELEPHONE CORPORATIONHoffberg, Steven M.Biomedical Synergies, Inc.Shockwave Medical, Inc. Yann Simonneaux et al.UNIVERSITY OF KANSASGE HEALTHCARE LIMITEDHino, Takanori PERSONAL WEB TECHNOLOGIES, LLC (ASSIGNEE) et al. | LEVEL 3 COMMUNICATIONS, LLCHui Xu et al.Hillcrest Laboratories, Inc.Ronald Biediger et al.Verizon Patent and Licensing Inc.HEWLETT PACKARD INDIGO BVTA Instruments - Waters L.L.C.STATS ChipPAC Pte. Ltd.Turner, Qian et al.SYMRISE AGGeorge Perry. HaynesARBOR PHARMACEUTICALS, LLCCLEARCAPITAL.COM, INC.Cruz-Hernandez, Juan Manuel.COVESTRO DEUTSCHLAND AGBaker Hughes IncorporatedINTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONQUALCOMM, INCORPORATEDWilson Sporting Goods Co.Andreas Etelk¿zi et al.Herman, Kent INTEGRAL DEVELOPMENT CORP.Kengo TakedaChristy, Richard W. et al.CUPP Computing ASInternational Business Machines CorporationMDX Medical, Inc.MAHAFFY, Kevin E. et al.Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.ROCKWELL AUTOMATION TECHNOLOGIES, INC.SkyBell Technologies, Inc.McCue CorporationTBI Innovations, LLC et al.The Procter & Gamble CompanyHALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.Morand, Michel Siemens AktiengesellschaftChristopher CentenoEtubics CorporationLG Display Co., Ltd.Uniloc Luxembourg S.A.Corning IncorporatedPROLACTA BIOSCIENCE, INC.MasterCard International IncorporatedOracle International CorporationStephen C.P. Joseph et al.Michael KimmetGracenote, Inc.LG Display Co., Ltd.Zietchick Research Institute, LLCPunit Seth et al.Matthew Sivertson et al.Speich, Jan et al.Pimpinella, Richard J. et al.4361423 CANADA INC.Mary Helander et al.The Government of the United States of America, as Represented by the Secretary, Department of HomelFORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCHONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.BKLK Ltd.San Quach et al.Qualcomm IncorporatedBRITISH TELECOMMUNICATIONS PUBLIC LIMITED COMPANYInfineon Technologies Austria AGCLEARCAPITAL.COM, INC.BlackBerry LimitedPULSE ELECTRONICS, INC.,NXP B.V.PHYTON HOLDINGS, LLCInternational Business Machines CorporationSpeich, Jan et al.eBay Inc.pMDsoft, Inc.Planet Social, L.L.C.ORBIS CorporationThe Procter & Gamble CompanyRealtek Semiconductor Corp.Etubics CorporationCREE, INC.Gale, BrianEtubics CorporationAINGEL CORP.To ChinRobert M. Chinn et al.Adobe Inc.William Mutilangi et al.Adobe Inc.Dell Products L.P.Wade Bowe et al.PHILIPS LIGHTING HOLDING B.V.Realtime Adaptive Streaming, LLCApple Inc.Jump Rope Systems, LLCElection Systems & Software, LLCL'OR¿ALOracle International CorporationTenacious Holdings, Inc.Keysight Technologies, Inc.AMOGREENTECH CO., LTD.Microsoft Technology Licensing LLCUNIVERSITY OF CHICAGOAdobe Inc.Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.Firstface Co., Ltd.S.L.A. PHARMA AGUniloc Luxembourg S.A.QUALCOMM IncorporatedClearSign Combustion CorporationGeneral Electric CompanyLam Research CorporationARM LIMITEDTelefonaktiebolaget L M Ericsson (PUBL)R.J. Reynolds Tobacco CompanyFirst Data CorporationKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.NINTENDO CO., LTD.United Technologies CorporationAINGEL CORP.Unirac, Inc.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLCTA Instruments - Waters L.L.C.K¿sters, Heiner et al.Wade Bowe et al.Facebook, Inc.Adobe Inc.Hironori Takuechi et al.Cree Fayetteville, Inc.Unify GmbH & Co. KGWolfgang SteinerSamsung Electronics Co., Ltd.O'Keeffe's, Inc.Epoch Lacrosse, LLC.Ronald Biediger et al.VP Holdings, Inc.Cadence Design Systems, Inc.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION Steven J. Bullied et al.Punit Seth et al.Francisco RuetteJohnpro Biotech Inc.Alexandra Blak et al.WACKER CHEMIE AGHillcrest Laboratories, Inc.AKZO NOBEL COATINGS INTERNATIONAL B.V. Jonathan M. Griebel et al.Kambiz YadidiKabam, Inc.UChicago Argonne, LLCMD Insider, Inc.ADVANCED BIONICS AG et al.MERCK PATENT GMBHBanti, Edward Thomas. et al.General Electric CompanyNathan HitsonRed Hat, Inc.DREXEL UNIVERSITYFord Global Technologies, LLCRICHARD BERGNER VERBINDUNGSTECHNIK GMBH & CO. KGInternational Business Machines CorporationCCL Label, Inc.S.L.A. PHARMA AGABB TECHNOLOGY AGGuada Technologies LLCWill VolnakBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftApple Inc.BIOSENSE WEBSTER (ISRAEL), LTD.TALIA LUXURY GOODS, LTD.The Boeing Company Adobe Inc.International Business Machines CorporationGeneral Electric Company Anouk Charlotte. O'Prinsen et al.France Behr et al.HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL INC.William MorrissApple Inc.POLARCUS DMCC et al.9376305 et al.Ecolab USA Inc.MAHAFFY, Kevin E. et al.LUMILEDS LLCWAYNE STATE UNIVERSITYBIOSENSE WEBSTER (ISRAEL), LTD.Swaminathan, Viswanathan et al.V¿¿N¿NEN, MikkoDarron Kirby. LaceyApple Inc.International Business Machines CorporationUniloc 2017 LLCEcolab USA Inc.Daiichi Sankyo Company, LimitedRobert Bosch GmbHSTATS ChipPAC Pte. Ltd.Hans B¿r et al.Daijitsu Harada et al.International Business Machines CorporationBEMIS COMPANY, INC.HALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.Broderick, Kate et al.VP Holdings, Inc.Visa International Service AssociationRick L. Adkins et al.Szu-Heng TSENG et al.Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.Anthony Mark. Phillips et al.Brown, Joe Denton.SHELL OIL COMPANYGreenthread LLC David C. ReardonCARRIER CORPORATIONSANOFI - TOPAZ, INC.Stephen ShoemakerSharps Compliance, Inc.Integral Development Inc.ENTIT SOFTWARE LLCBredemeier, Lori A. et al.9051147 Canada Inc.Patrick O. TennicanMicrosoft Technology Licensing, LLCSANOFI - TOPAZ, INC.Yaacov SHIRAZIPeter FinanASML NETHERLANDS B.V.Joseph Farkas et al.Gale, Brian International Business Machines CorporationSamsung Electronics Co., Ltd.Philip Young et al.The Procter & Gamble CompanyAlistair E. JeffsSPX Flow, Inc.ADVANCED BIONICS AG et al.Avaya Inc.Linda T. DozierRovi Guides, Inc.Uniloc 2017 LLCBell Northern Research, LLC, which is a wholly owned subsidiary of Hilco Patent Acquisition 56, LLC, which is owned by both Hilco IP Merchant Capital, LLC, and Hilco, Inc.Bierdel, Michael et al.Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.Adobe Inc.Yoshitaka Komuro et al.Ford Global Technologies, LLCLinda T. DozierKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V. Michael A. Marth et al.Hans Bär et al.Bliss Hammocks Inc.Smith, Janet et al.SMARTSKY NETWORKS LLCNVIDIA CORPORATIONTraxo, Inc.Judith H. Bank et al. Wolfgang SteinerCanon, Inc.Huntsman International LLCLoubier, Christopher Petteri Lunden et al.NIKE, Inc.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.International Business Machines CorporationHino, TakanoriHEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.BOSTON SCIENTIFIC SCIMED, INC.NVIDIA CORPORATIONVESTAS WIND SYSTEMS A/SEyran Lida et al.C. R. Bard, Inc.Zier, Thomas et al.APPLE INC.Foamtec International Co., Ltd.Intel CorporationButler Home Products, LLCSAP SECoupons.com incorporatedPersonali Inc.JOHNSON & JOHNSON CONSUMER INC.Wang, MinFisher, MichelleQUALCOMM IncorporatedMarkus Schneider et al.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.Vanek, Joseph M.Murphy, Matthew Robert M. Chinn et al.Continental Intermodal Group - Trucking LLCPURE DATA SYSTEMS, LLCVP Holdings, Inc.STC.UNMInternational Business Machines CorporationImagination Technologies LimitedHuang Liu et al.Johnson Matthey Davy Technologies LimitedAkimasa Ichikawa et al.Loubier, ChristopherEthicon Endo-Surgery, Inc.Ye-Kui Wang et al.Apple Inc.RINCOVER, Aaron et al.MasterCard International IncorporatedNicira, Inc.Locker, Howard et al. Hermanus Jongkind et al.Visa International Service AssociationDerek KinchLenovo (Singapore) Pte. Ltd.Intuit Inc.TL FAB, LPFraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Forderung der angewandten Forschung e.V.Gamon Plus, Inc.Garg, Vibhav et al.Ford Global Technologies, LLCVirentem Ventures, LLC d/b/a EnounceSkyBell Technologies, Inc.Ryan, Thomas A. et al.United Technologies CorporationOregon State UniversityHeatherly, Christopher W.Pimpinella, Richard J. et al.GEMA SWITZERLAND GMBHROBERT BOSCH GMBHIdaax Technologies Private LimitedNICIRA, INC.STREMSDOERFER, Mathieu et al.VÄÄNÄNEN, Mikko Robert ConradWAYNE STATE UNIVERSITYKOM Software, Inc.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONJoseph Farkas et al.Unique Fabricating, Inc.Medtronic, Inc.Infineon Technologies AGHawley, George C.Chicago Mercantile Exchange Inc.VALEO SYSTEMES D'ESSUYAGEBOSTON SCIENTIFIC SCIMED, INC.DR¿GER SAFETY AG & CO.Sharps Compliance, Inc.David Hill et al.Microsoft Technology Licensing, LLC.Align Technology, Inc.Apple Inc.The Toronto-Dominion BankSYNTHETIC GENOMICS, INC.Jerry L. AllenPike, Mark et al.NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANYROCKWOOL INTERNATIONAL A/S (3RD PTY. REQ.)Louis Chiappetta et al.Visa International Service AssociationVigneri, AlexanderAlistair E. JeffsBayerische Motoren Werke AktiengesellschaftTheodore LipaKONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Karl Zuercher et al.3M INNOVATIVE PROPERTIES COMPANYDSM IP ASSETS B.V.INNOVATIVE SONIC CORPORATIONOpower, Inc.PayPal, Inc.MagQuest, Inc.Joovv, Inc.WATERS TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONDANGEVILLE, NICOLAS et al.KOM Software, Inc.Virtual Sports Training, Inc.SAP SE Ronald Becker. WilliamsEthicon Endo-Surgery, Inc.COCHLEAR LIMITEDMTD Products IncWentink, Maarten Menzo.GEMA SWITZERLAND GMBHIGTMALLINCKRODT HOSPITAL PRODUCTS IP LIMITEDAvigilon Fortress CorporationLutnick, Howard W. et al.Fraunhofer-Gesellschaft zur Forderung der angewandten Forschung e.V.MTD Products IncHALLIBURTON ENERGY SERVICES, INC.KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.Calendar Research LLCAdvanced Poly-Packaging, Inc.Hui Xu et al.Peter FinanToshiba Global Commerce Solutions Holdings CorporationUman, Julie et al.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONBOSTON SCIENTIFIC SCIMED, INC.LUMILEDS LLCCOVESTRO DEUTSCHLAND AGDaijitsu Harada et al.DREXEL UNIVERSITYMedtronic MiniMed, Inc.Fisher, Michelle Bo-I Lee et al.Firstface Co., Ltd.Uniloc Luxembourg S.A.Dolby Laboratories Licensing CorporationInternational Business Machines CorporationMModal Services Ltd.CORNING INCORPORATEDAlign Technology, Inc.Hermanus Jongkind et al.Infineon Technologies Austria AGRackham, Guy Jonathan James.UNITED TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATIONC. Kumar et al.CCS Technology, Inc.Lowe's Companies, Inc.International Business Machines CorporationWang, Min SEW-EURODRIVE GMBH & CO. KGHRB Innovations, Inc.FORD GLOBAL TECHNOLOGIES, LLCSony CorporationCardiac Pacemakers, Inc.KING SHOW GAMES, INC.CONTINENTAL AUTOMOTIVE FRANCE et al.WATLOW ELECTRIC MANUFACTURING COMPANYROCKWELL AUTOMATION TECHNOLOGIES, INC.Francisco RuetteInternational Business Machines CorporationGEMALTO M2M GMBHKambiz YadidiUnited Technologies CorporationJoovv, Inc.HEWLETT-PACKARD DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.P.Eyran Lida et al.C. R. Bard, Inc.Kengo TakedaBruker Daltonik GmbHSergei Zenovich et al.Bouma, Peter Hermanus. et al.COCHLEAR LIMITEDMaxlinear, Inc.Micron Technology, Inc.Google LLCBritax Childcare Pty LtdLi, Huajing et al.The Procter & Gamble CompanyHoffberg, Steven M.ROBERT BOSCH GMBHMULTIPLE SCLEROSIS RESEARCH CENTER OF NEW YORKNant Holdings IP, LLCPROLACTA BIOSCIENCE, INC.SHELL OIL COMPANYChristopher CentenonuTonomy Inc.KOM Software, Inc.INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS MACHINES CORPORATIONeBay Inc. Thomas J. Gilg et al.The Government of the United States, as Represented by the Secretary of the ArmyThe Procter & Gamble CompanyDavid W. Baarman et al.Mary Helander et al.Toyota Motor Engineering & Manufacturing North America, Inc.Lev A. Koyrakh et al.Kebron DejeneABBOTT POINT OF CARE, INC.Adobe Inc.NuVasive, Inc.DENSO CORPORATION et al.NuVasive, Inc.Stephen C.P. Joseph et al.QUALCOMM IncorporatedUniversal Electronics Inc.Wang, Zhikui et al.Graphic Packaging International, Inc.Rite Aid Hdqtrs. Corp.Medtronic, Inc.Maxell, Ltd.Pahls, Avery Colorado. et al.MULTIPLE SCLEROSIS RESEARCH CENTER OF NEW YORKFacebook, Inc.Naoki MATSUNAGAJohannes Foufas et al.Chevron U.S.A. Inc.Facebook, Inc.Avaya Inc.Canon Inc.Swaminathan, Viswanathan et al.