From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Russell

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
May 22, 1884
14 R.I. 506 (R.I. 1884)

Summary

In State v. Russell, 14 R.I. 506 (1884) this court stated that the offense of being a common night walker consisted not "of particular acts but of an habitual practice evidence by a series of acts."

Summary of this case from State v. Reis

Opinion

May 22, 1884.

The words "common night walker" have a technical meaning in criminal law. Hence a complaint charging a woman with being a "common night walker" is sufficient without the allegation of particular acts. If for her defence the accused requires more definite information, she can obtain it by asking for a bill of particulars.

EXCEPTIONS to the Court of Common Pleas.

Stephen A. Cooke, Jun., for plaintiff.

John M. Brennan, for defendant.


The exceptions raise only one question, namely: Is a complaint under Pub. Stat. R.I. cap. 244, § 22, against a woman for being a common night walker sufficient if it simply charges her with being a common night walker without alleging particular acts? It is well settled that for the offence of being a common scold or a common barrator such a charge is sufficient. The reason is, the offence does not consist of particular acts but of an habitual practice evidenced by a series of acts. It may be argued that if a vicious practice constitutes the offence, then the practice ought to be alleged descriptively in the complaint or indictment. The answer is, the words "common scold" and "common barrator" are words having a technical meaning in the law, and that they import ex vi terminorum all that would be expressed if the practice were so alleged. In State v. Dowers, 45 N.H. 543, the same reasoning was held to be applicable where the offence is the offence of being a common night walker, and in that case it was decided that it was enough to charge the offender with being a common night walker. We think the decision was correct. The words "a common night walker" are words having a technical meaning in the law, and it would therefore be superfluous to spread their definition on the record. If, for the purposes of defence, the accused needs more definite information than the record affords, she should ask for a bill of particulars, which, of course, in so far as the offence is capable of being particularized, ought to be and would be supplied. Wharton's Crim. Plead. Prac. § 155; Commonwealth v. Davis, 11 Pick. 432; Commonwealth v. Pray, 13 Pick. 359; Commonwealth v. Wood, 4 Gray, 11.

Exceptions overruled.


Summaries of

State v. Russell

Supreme Court of Rhode Island
May 22, 1884
14 R.I. 506 (R.I. 1884)

In State v. Russell, 14 R.I. 506 (1884) this court stated that the offense of being a common night walker consisted not "of particular acts but of an habitual practice evidence by a series of acts."

Summary of this case from State v. Reis

In State v. Russell, 14 R.I. 506, the defendant was charged with being a "common nightwalker," (in violation of a statute) without alleging any particular facts.

Summary of this case from State v. Cherry

In State v. Russell, supra, it was held that the words "common night-walker" have a technical meaning in law, and in a complaint charging such offense it is not necessary to allege particular acts, inasmuch as the offense does not consist of particular acts, but of a habitual practice evidenced by a series of acts. Where the words of the statute are descriptive of the offense, it is ordinarily sufficient to charge the offense in the language of the statute, or in words of similar import.

Summary of this case from Levine v. State
Case details for

State v. Russell

Case Details

Full title:STATE vs. GERTRUDE RUSSELL

Court:Supreme Court of Rhode Island

Date published: May 22, 1884

Citations

14 R.I. 506 (R.I. 1884)

Citing Cases

State v. Reis

The adjective "common" and the phrase "common nuisance" are words of art used since the days of common law.…

State v. Napier

The State, however, may be required before trial to give the defendant notice of the particular instances…