From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Stanfill v. Powers

Michigan Court of Appeals
Apr 6, 1976
68 Mich. App. 488 (Mich. Ct. App. 1976)

Summary

applying Manistee Bank to a July 4, 1970, accident and a May, 1975, trial

Summary of this case from Old Reliable v. Schaub

Opinion

Docket No. 24912.

Decided April 6, 1976.

Appeal from Wayne, Horace W. Gilmore, J. Submitted March 2, 1976, at Detroit. (Docket No. 24912.) Decided April 6, 1976.

Complaint by Eugene Stanfill, a guest passenger, against Larry Powers, an owner-operator, for damages for injuries from an automobile accident. Judgment for defendant. Plaintiff appeals. Reversed and remanded.

Rader Eisenberg, P.C., for plaintiff.

Rouse, Selby, Dickinson, Pike Mourad, for defendant.

Before: D.E. HOLBROOK, JR., P.J., and McGREGOR and N.J. KAUFMAN, JJ.


Plaintiff, a guest passenger, instituted suit against the defendant, owner-operator, following a single-vehicle accident which occurred on July 4, 1970. A jury trial was held on May 5 and 6, 1975, resulting in a verdict of no cause of action.

On appeal plaintiff raises two allegations of error. Resolution of the first, however, is dispositive.

Plaintiff initially contends that the trial court reversibly erred by instructing the jury that under the guest passenger statute, MCLA 257.401; MSA 9.2101, it was necessary for the jury to find that the defendant's conduct constituted gross negligence in order for the plaintiff to recover. We agree with plaintiff's contention.

In Manistee Bank Trust Co v McGowan, 394 Mich. 655; 232 N.W.2d 636 (1975), the Michigan Supreme Court in a 3-2 decision held the guest passenger statute unconstitutional as violative of the Equal Protection Clause of the Michigan Constitution. While we do not feel bound to follow a 3-2 decision of the Michigan Supreme Court, we nevertheless choose to do so for two reasons. First, we agree with the logic and reasoning of Justice LEVIN'S majority opinion in that case. Second, while Manistee Bank Trust Co v McGowan, supra, standing alone is not binding precedent we conclude that when considered in conjunction with Dunham v Lowinger, 395 Mich. 793 (1976), a 6-0 determination, it is.

The jury verdict is therefore set aside and this case is remanded to the trial court for a new trial.

Reversed and remanded.


Summaries of

Stanfill v. Powers

Michigan Court of Appeals
Apr 6, 1976
68 Mich. App. 488 (Mich. Ct. App. 1976)

applying Manistee Bank to a July 4, 1970, accident and a May, 1975, trial

Summary of this case from Old Reliable v. Schaub
Case details for

Stanfill v. Powers

Case Details

Full title:STANFILL v POWERS

Court:Michigan Court of Appeals

Date published: Apr 6, 1976

Citations

68 Mich. App. 488 (Mich. Ct. App. 1976)
243 N.W.2d 24

Citing Cases

Old Reliable v. Schaub

There, on the basis of Manistee Bank, the Supreme Court reversed a 1973 decision of this Court. See also…

Herrick v. Taylor

In Old Reliable Fire Ins Co v Schaub, 85 Mich. App. 294; 271 N.W.2d 206 (1978), this Court found that the…