From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Spiers v. Davidson

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Nov 7, 1955
83 So. 2d 653 (La. 1955)

Summary

interpreting procedural provisions similar to LSA-CCP Arts. 1911 and 2083

Summary of this case from Fogleman v. Crowley Building Loan Association

Opinion

No. 42486.

November 7, 1955.

APPEAL FROM SIXTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT, PARISH OF TENSAS, STATE OF LOUISIANA, HONORABLE FRANK VOELKER, J.

Alwine L. Mulhearn, Tallulah, for plaintiff-appellant.

Young Watson, St. Joseph, McHenry, for Lamkin, Snellings Breard, Monroe, for appellee.


Appellant sued appellee to reform a deed to real estate in Tensas Parish and further to annul and set it aside as a simulation. Following a hearing on exceptions of want of tender no right or cause of action and estoppel interposed by appellee, the judge sustained all defensive pleadings. This is shown by a minute entry of the court dated April 28, 1955, but no final judgment of dismissal of the suit was ever rendered and signed. Nonetheless, counsel for appellant moved for and was granted an appeal which was lodged in this court on June 23, 1955.

On June 29, 1955, appellee moved to dismiss the appeal on the ground that there has not been a definitive judgment rendered or signed by the judge. Since the filing of this motion, appellant has appeared and, admitting that the position taken by appellee is well founded, likewise moves for a dismissal.

Appellant rightly concedes that her appeal must be dismissed as there is no entry of a final signed judgment from which an appeal could be taken. See Articles 546 and 565 of the Code of Practice; River Rails Terminals, Inc., v. Louisiana Ry. Nav. Co., 157 La. 1085, 103 So. 331, and cases there cited.

The appeal is therefore dismissed at appellant's costs.


Summaries of

Spiers v. Davidson

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Nov 7, 1955
83 So. 2d 653 (La. 1955)

interpreting procedural provisions similar to LSA-CCP Arts. 1911 and 2083

Summary of this case from Fogleman v. Crowley Building Loan Association
Case details for

Spiers v. Davidson

Case Details

Full title:MRS. AMALIA STEEN SPIERS v. MRS. CARRIE MOORE DAVIDSON

Court:Supreme Court of Louisiana

Date published: Nov 7, 1955

Citations

83 So. 2d 653 (La. 1955)
228 La. 632

Citing Cases

Manuel v. Employers' Fire Insurance Company

Although the record does not reflect that an appeal was taken in this case, the record has been lodged in…

Fogleman v. Crowley Building Loan Association

No appeal lies from a judgment before it is signed, and an appeal taken prior to signing is premature and…