From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Shavers v. Murphy

United States District Court, N.D. Mississippi, Delta Division
Jun 12, 2006
Case No. 2:05CV202 (N.D. Miss. Jun. 12, 2006)

Summary

applying the Barton doctrine

Summary of this case from Equip. Leasing, LLC v. Three Deuces, Inc.

Opinion

Case No. 2:05CV202.

June 12, 2006


ORDER


This cause comes before the Court on the motion of defendants Dwayne M. Murray and Michael A. Crawford to dismiss the pro se plaintiffs' suit against them pursuant to Rule 12(b)(1) for lack of subject matter jurisdiction [23-1; 48-1]. Murray and Crawford were respectively the bankruptcy trustee and court-approved counsel in plaintiff John E. Shavers involuntary bankruptcy proceedings in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Mississippi, Gulfport Division, as Case NO. 03-55729. Murray and Crawford argue that subject matter jurisdiction is lacking because the plaintiffs failed to seek leave of the appointing court (i.e., the Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of Mississippi) prior to filing the instant suit, as is required by the Barton doctrine. See Barton v. Barbour, 104 U.S. 126, 129, 26 L.Ed. 672 (1881) (requiring permission from appointing court before filing of suit against court-appointed receiver or comparable functionary). The plaintiffs argue that the Barton doctrine is not applicable in this case because they are suing Murray and Crawford both individually and in their official capacity and because their complaint is premised in part on the fact that the Bankruptcy Court lacked jurisdiction over them to begin with. Be that as it may, the plaintiffs offer no support for their theory that this Court may collaterally attack the jurisdiction of one of its sister courts in an ongoing action, and the Court is persuaded that the Barton doctrine applies in this case.

ACCORDINGLY, it is hereby ORDERED:

1. that the motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction [23-1; 48-1] is GRANTED; and
2. that defendants Dwayne M. Murray and Michael A. Crawford are dismissed from this case without prejudice.


Summaries of

Shavers v. Murphy

United States District Court, N.D. Mississippi, Delta Division
Jun 12, 2006
Case No. 2:05CV202 (N.D. Miss. Jun. 12, 2006)

applying the Barton doctrine

Summary of this case from Equip. Leasing, LLC v. Three Deuces, Inc.
Case details for

Shavers v. Murphy

Case Details

Full title:JOHN E. SHAVERS and B.G. PERRY Plaintiffs, v. DWAYNE M. MURRAY et all…

Court:United States District Court, N.D. Mississippi, Delta Division

Date published: Jun 12, 2006

Citations

Case No. 2:05CV202 (N.D. Miss. Jun. 12, 2006)

Citing Cases

Equip. Leasing, LLC v. Three Deuces, Inc.

See In re WRT Energy Corp., 402 B.R. 717, 722 (Bkrtcy. W.D. La. 2007) (recognizing "the viability of the…