From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Rocky Produce v. Frontera

Michigan Court of Appeals
Dec 18, 1989
181 Mich. App. 516 (Mich. Ct. App. 1989)

Summary

finding default improper when party had not received an order or a subpoena, but only an "unsigned, undated trial notice"

Summary of this case from Dernis v. Amos Fin., LLC

Opinion

Docket No. 112422.

Decided December 18, 1989.

Joseph B. Evanski, for plaintiff.

Karbel, Brukoff, Rothstein, Stewart Wallace, P.C. (by Robert A. Karbel), for defendant.

Before: McDONALD, P.J., and MICHAEL J. KELLY and MURPHY, JJ.


Defendant appeals as of right from a default judgment entered in plaintiff's favor for approximately $36,000. Plaintiff claimed that money was owed to it by defendant on an account stated and also for unjust enrichment. Defendant, in her answer and by subsequent affidavit, denied that she ever contracted with or incurred a debt to plaintiff relative to the purchase of certain produce.

Although defendant's attorney was present on behalf of defendant for the scheduled trial, the record reflects that the trial court entered a default judgment against defendant because she failed to appear for trial.

Apparently, an unsigned and undated trial notice containing the typed name of the trial judge was sent to the attorneys of record but no subpoena or order to attend the trial was ever issued or served on defendant.

The right to representation by legal counsel in a civil case is provided in our Michigan Constitution, Const 1963, art 1, § 13. This right is further augmented by MCR 2.117(B)(1), which provides in part:

An attorney may appear by an act indicating that the attorney represents a party in the action. An appearance by an attorney for a party is deemed an appearance by the party. Unless a particular rule indicates otherwise, any act required to be performed by a party may be performed by the attorney representing the party.

A party may be required to appear at trial if a properly issued subpoena or order from the court commands the appearance and failure to comply can result in a default judgment. MCR 2.506. However, absent a subpoena or order from the court to appear, a defendant in a civil case is not required to appear in person for a scheduled trial. The record in this case does not reflect either the issuance of a subpoena or an order to appear. The unsigned, undated trial notice which was sent to defendant's attorney did not constitute an order to appear. MCR 2.602(A).

Accordingly, the default judgment is reversed and this matter is remanded for trial.


Summaries of

Rocky Produce v. Frontera

Michigan Court of Appeals
Dec 18, 1989
181 Mich. App. 516 (Mich. Ct. App. 1989)

finding default improper when party had not received an order or a subpoena, but only an "unsigned, undated trial notice"

Summary of this case from Dernis v. Amos Fin., LLC

reversing default judgment based on civil defendant's failure to appear personally at trial because, “absent a subpoena or order from the court to appear, a defendant in a civil case is not required to appear in person for a scheduled trial”

Summary of this case from Jack v. P & a Farms, Ltd.

reversing a default judgment entered based on a civil defendant's failure to personally appear at trial and holding that, "absent a subpoena or order from the court to appear, a defendant in a civil case is not required to appear in person for a scheduled trial"

Summary of this case from Ogawa v. Ogawa, 125 Nev. Adv. Op. No. 51, 48571 (2009)

In Rocky Produce, Inc v Frontera, 181 Mich App 516, 517; 449 NW2d 916 (1989), the trial court entered a default judgment against the defendant because she failed to appear for trial, even though her attorney was present on her behalf for the scheduled trial.

Summary of this case from Bastin v. Welch
Case details for

Rocky Produce v. Frontera

Case Details

Full title:ROCKY PRODUCE, INC v FRONTERA

Court:Michigan Court of Appeals

Date published: Dec 18, 1989

Citations

181 Mich. App. 516 (Mich. Ct. App. 1989)
449 N.W.2d 916

Citing Cases

Dernis v. Amos Fin., LLC

Certainly, attendance can be compelled by "a properly issued subpoena or order from the court" that commands…

Weber v. Draper

Respondent, however, had the right to representation by legal counsel. Rocky Produce, Inc v Frontera, 181…