From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

People v. 25 Stations

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Dec 6, 1957
146 N.E.2d 691 (N.Y. 1957)

Summary

In People v. 25 Stations (3 N.Y.2d 488, 490) defendants maintained a sign measuring 5 feet in length and 3 1/2 feet in width on the pumps which read: "Owned Operated by 25 Stations Inc."

Summary of this case from People v. Carillo

Opinion

Argued October 21, 1957

Decided December 6, 1957

Appeal from the Court of Special Sessions of the City of New York, Appellate Part, Second Department, JOHN R. STARKEY, M.

Edward S. Silver, District Attorney ( Frank Di Lalla of counsel), for appellant.

Theodore D. Ostrow and Noel Rubinton for Gasoline Merchants of Brooklyn, Inc., amicus curiae, in support of appellant's position. George Abrams for respondents.


Defendants were convicted of a violation of the Administrative Code in the Magistrate's Court of the City of New York. On appeal to the Court of Special Sessions the judgments were reversed, the complaints dismissed and the defendants discharged. An appeal has been allowed to this court pursuant to section 520 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.

Since the complaints have been dismissed below the single question presented for review is whether, in any view of the evidence, it can be said that a question of fact existed as to defendants' guilt or innocence ( People v. Bellows, 281 N.Y. 67, 73; People v. Potskowski, 298 N.Y. 299, 303; People v. Scheinman, 295 N.Y. 142, 144; People v. Rudolph, 303 N.Y. 73, 79). On this record we think such a question was presented.

Section B36-103.0 of the Administrative Code of the City of New York proscribes the posting at, near or about premises where gasoline is being sold, of any sign larger than 12 inches in height and 12 inches in width, which refers directly or indirectly to the price of the gasoline. Defendants, corporate owner of a gas station and its president-manager, maintained a sign measuring 5 feet in length and 3 1/2 feet in width, reading "Owned Operated by 25 Stations Inc." on the pumps used for dispensing gasoline at the station. The numerals "25" were painted in red and measured 36 inches in height. The words "Owned Operated", appearing above the "25", were painted in a less striking black and measured only 6 inches in height. "Stations" appeared beneath the numerals, also in black and also only 6 inches in height. The abbreviation "Inc." was in still smaller letters beneath the word "Stations".

Suffice it to say that from the photographic exhibits alone and the clear picture they give of the size, location and effect of this placard or sign, there was ample evidence upon which the Magistrate could find, as he did, that the sign indirectly referred to the price of gasoline and constituted a violation of the Administrative Code.

Although we hold that the record did present a question of fact for the Magistrate and that consequently a dismissal of the complaints was improper because the reversal at Special Sessions was stated to be on the facts as well as the law, a new trial must be ordered ( People v. Bellows, 281 N.Y. 67, 77, supra).

Accordingly, the order of Special Sessions, insofar as it dismisses the complaints as to each defendant, should be reversed, and a new trial ordered.

Chief Judge CONWAY and Judges DESMOND, DYE, FULD, FROESSEL and VAN VOORHIS concur.

Order reversed and a new trial ordered.


Summaries of

People v. 25 Stations

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Dec 6, 1957
146 N.E.2d 691 (N.Y. 1957)

In People v. 25 Stations (3 N.Y.2d 488, 490) defendants maintained a sign measuring 5 feet in length and 3 1/2 feet in width on the pumps which read: "Owned Operated by 25 Stations Inc."

Summary of this case from People v. Carillo

In People v. 25 Stations (3 N.Y.2d 488) the New York City Administrative Code prohibited signs larger than 12 inches by 12 inches referring directly or indirectly to the price of gasoline.

Summary of this case from People v. Al Oil Co.
Case details for

People v. 25 Stations

Case Details

Full title:THE PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, Appellant, v. 25 STATIONS, INC., and…

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Dec 6, 1957

Citations

146 N.E.2d 691 (N.Y. 1957)
146 N.E.2d 691
168 N.Y.S.2d 962

Citing Cases

Dept. of Agriculture v. Tide Oil Co.

Such signs certainly are indicative of and referable to the price of gasoline as those words are used in…

People v. Save Way Northern Blvd., Inc.

Leo A. Larkin, Corporation Counsel ( Beatrice Shainswit and Seymour B. Quel of counsel), for respondent.…