From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

First Union National Bank v. FCVS Communications

Supreme Court of South Carolina
Dec 16, 1997
328 S.C. 290 (S.C. 1997)

Summary

dismissing interpleader action as moot after granting motion to release funds pursuant to agreement among parties

Summary of this case from Vincent Metro, LLC v. Yah Realty, LLC

Opinion

Opinion No. 24726

Heard November 19, 1997

Decided December 16, 1997

Appeal From Richland County, Costa M. Pleicones, Judge.

DISMISSED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART.

James R. Allen, of Barnes, Alford, Stork Johnson, L.L.P., of Columbia, for petitioners/respondents.

Craig K. Davis and James F. Flanagan, both of Columbia, for respondent/petitioner.


Petitioners/respondents (collectively Bank) is the depository for funds owned by respondent/petitioner (FCVS). Bank sought interpleader on the ground there were conflicting claims between the majority and minority partners of FCVS regarding the funds. The trial judge granted interpleader and ordered the funds be held by Bank until further order of the court. He then discharged Bank from the suit, effectively dismissing FCVS's counterclaims against Bank. The trial judge also denied Bank's request for attorney's fees. The Court of Appeals affirmed the grant of interpleader, reversed dismissal of FCVS's counterclaims, and remanded to the trial court to determine attorney's fees. First Union National Bank of South Carolina v. FCVS Communications, 321 S.C. 496, 469 S.E.2d 613 (Ct.App. 1996). This Court granted the parties' petitions for a writ of certiorari to review all three issues.

FCVS recently filed a motion with this Court representing that the partners of FCVS have now resolved their conflict regarding the funds. FCVS seeks an order, with the consent of the minority partners, requiring Bank to release the funds since there are no longer conflicting claims. We grant the motion. Since the issue of interpleader is now moot, we dismiss the writ as to this question. Jones v. Dillon-Marion Resources Dev. Comm'n, 277 S.C. 533, 291 S.E.2d 195 (1982) (when an event occurs while a case is pending on appeal so there remains no actual controversy between the parties, the case is moot and the appeal will be dismissed).

Further, we reverse the Court of Appeals' decision reinstating FCVS's counterclaims. These counterclaims allege liability arising from Bank's failure to honor the majority partners' instructions regarding the funds. In granting interpleader under Rule 22 (a), SCRCP, however, the trial judge necessarily found Bank was entitled to protection from the conflicting claims of the majority and minority partners. Accordingly, under Rule 22 (b), SCRCP, Bank was entitled to be "discharged from liability as to such claims." Since the Court of Appeals found interpleader was appropriately granted, it erred in reversing Bank's discharge from the suit.

Finally, we reverse the Court of Appeals' ruling that Bank was entitled to attorney's fees as an innocent stakeholder in this case. Attorney's fees are not recoverable unless authorized by contract or statute. Tharp v. S.C. Dept. of Soc. Servs., 312 S.C. 243, 439 S.E.2d 854 (1993).

DISMISSED IN PART; REVERSED IN PART.


Summaries of

First Union National Bank v. FCVS Communications

Supreme Court of South Carolina
Dec 16, 1997
328 S.C. 290 (S.C. 1997)

dismissing interpleader action as moot after granting motion to release funds pursuant to agreement among parties

Summary of this case from Vincent Metro, LLC v. Yah Realty, LLC
Case details for

First Union National Bank v. FCVS Communications

Case Details

Full title:First Union National Bank of South Carolina and First Union Brokerage…

Court:Supreme Court of South Carolina

Date published: Dec 16, 1997

Citations

328 S.C. 290 (S.C. 1997)
494 S.E.2d 429

Citing Cases

Vincent Metro, LLC v. Yah Realty, LLC

Moreover, even when an agreement among claimants obviates the need for the court to determine to whom the…

Threlkeld v. Lyman Warehouse, LLC

" (citations and internal quotation marks omitted)); Rule 22(a), SCRCP ("Persons having claims against the…