From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Barbaree v. Coffin

Supreme Court of Georgia
May 15, 1956
92 S.E.2d 860 (Ga. 1956)

Summary

In Barbaree v. Coffin, 212 Ga. 370 (92 S.E.2d 860), the acknowledgment of service by the attorney for the defendant in error recognized that he had been served with a copy of the bill of exceptions and then went on expressly to waive the privilege and opportunity to be heard on the question of whether the bill of exceptions was correct and complete.

Summary of this case from Sargeant v. Starr

Opinion

19296.

ARGUED APRIL 9, 1956.

DECIDED MAY 15, 1956.

Injunction. Before Judge Rees. Stewart Superior Court. January 16, 1956.

Carlton S. Brown, for plaintiff in error.

W. W. McKinnon, J. Frank Myers, contra.


The only acknowledgment of service of the bill of exceptions made in this case was as follows: "The undersigned, the attorney at law of E. C. Coffin, defendant in error in the above-stated case, acknowledges that I have been served with a copy of the foregoing bill of exceptions. I hereby waive the privilege and opportunity to be heard on the question of whether or not the bill of exceptions is correct and complete and I hereby approve the foregoing bill of exceptions as correct and complete as to the facts therein stated. This the ____ day [no date] of February, 1956." A waiver of the notice provided for by Code (Ann. Supp.) § 6-908.1 as to the correctness and completeness of the bill of exceptions prior to certification by the trial judge does not dispense with service of a copy of the bill after approval by the trial judge, as provided by Code (Ann Supp.) § 6-911. Statham v. Saxon, 210 Ga. 369 ( 80 S.E.2d 182). Compliance with the latter Code section is essential to give this court jurisdiction. ( Mauldin v. Mauldin, 203 Ga. 123, 45 S.E.2d 818; Harper v. A. W. P. R., 204 Ga. 311, 49 S.E.2d 513; Parker v. Parker, 208 Ga. 190, 65 S.E.2d 794); and where this section is not complied with, the writ of error must be

Dismissed. All the Justices concur.

ARGUED APRIL 9, 1956 — DECIDED MAY 15, 1956.


Summaries of

Barbaree v. Coffin

Supreme Court of Georgia
May 15, 1956
92 S.E.2d 860 (Ga. 1956)

In Barbaree v. Coffin, 212 Ga. 370 (92 S.E.2d 860), the acknowledgment of service by the attorney for the defendant in error recognized that he had been served with a copy of the bill of exceptions and then went on expressly to waive the privilege and opportunity to be heard on the question of whether the bill of exceptions was correct and complete.

Summary of this case from Sargeant v. Starr
Case details for

Barbaree v. Coffin

Case Details

Full title:BARBAREE et al. v. COFFIN

Court:Supreme Court of Georgia

Date published: May 15, 1956

Citations

92 S.E.2d 860 (Ga. 1956)
212 Ga. 370

Citing Cases

Universal C.I.T. Credit Corporation v. Johnson

1 does not dispense with service of the bill of exceptions, or waiver thereof, as required by Code § 6-911,…

Scott v. State

Since there is no return of service, acknowledgment or waiver thereof, on the bill of exceptions, or in the…