From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Wojtaszek v. Department of Street Railways

Supreme Court of Michigan
Dec 14, 1937
276 N.W. 457 (Mich. 1937)

Opinion

Docket No. 21, Calendar No. 39,641.

Submitted October 13, 1937.

Decided December 14, 1937.

Appeal from Wayne; Merriam (DeWitt H.), J. Submitted October 13, 1937. (Docket No. 21, Calendar No. 39,641.) Decided December 14, 1937.

Case by Pauline Wojtaszek against Department of Street Railways of the City of Detroit and City of Detroit, a municipal corporation, for personal in juries sustained when alighting from a street car. Verdict and judgment for defendants. Plaintiff appeals. Affirmed.

Berger, Manason Barris ( Isadore Berger, of counsel), for plaintiff.

Rodney Baxter and Leon H. Harman, for defendants.


In action for damages for injuries caused by operation of a street car, the only testimony as to the circumstances of the claimed negligent conduct was given by the plaintiff and as follows:

"The street car stopped to leave me off at Otis. I was getting off the front end of the car and had one foot on the step and the other foot in the air when the street car started with a sudden jerk and threw me to the pavement. I was dizzy afterwards and got up and went home. How I got there I don't know."

Plaintiff claimed that both physical injuries and "traumatic hysteria and traumatic neurosis" resulted from the fall.

The jury returned a verdict for the defendant.

Plaintiff's complaint is that defendant's doctor was permitted to testify that in his opinion the cause of plaintiff's neurotic condition was an unfortunate economic and domestic life and not the accident she had sustained. Whether admissible or not, this testimony bore only upon the measure of damages, a subject which the jury did not reach because it found want of liability in defendant. Consequently admission of the testimony did not constitute reversible error.

Affirmed, with costs.

NORTH, WIEST, BUTZEL, BUSHNELL, SHARPE, POTTER, and CHANDLER, JJ., concurred.


Summaries of

Wojtaszek v. Department of Street Railways

Supreme Court of Michigan
Dec 14, 1937
276 N.W. 457 (Mich. 1937)
Case details for

Wojtaszek v. Department of Street Railways

Case Details

Full title:WOJTASZEK v. DEPARTMENT OF STREET RAILWAYS, CITY OF DETROIT

Court:Supreme Court of Michigan

Date published: Dec 14, 1937

Citations

276 N.W. 457 (Mich. 1937)
276 N.W. 457

Citing Cases

Valenti v. Mayer

Appellee argues this court should not consider these charges since the damages were not considered by the…