Opinion
20-cv-367-jdp
03-08-2022
SHOMAS T. WINSTON, Plaintiff, v. SHERRI A. PULDA and KRIS DEYOUNG, Defendants.
SPECIAL VERDICT FORM
We, the jury, for our special verdict, do find as follows:
CLAIMS AGAINST SHERRI PULDA
QUESTION 1. Did defendant Sherry Pulda violate plaintiff Shomas Winston's rights under the Eighth Amendment?
Answer: No (Yes or No)
Answer Question 2.
QUESTION 2. Was defendant Pulda negligent in providing medical care to plaintiff Winston, causing Winston harm?
Answer: No (Yes or No)
If you answered YES to Question I OR Question 2, answer Question 3. If you answered NO to Question 1 AND Question 2, go on to Question 5.
QUESTION 3. What amount of money, if any, would fairly and adequately compensate Winston for the harm caused by Pulda?
Answer: $ 0
If you answered YES to Question 1, answer Question 4. If you answered NO to Question I, go on to Question 5.
QUESTION 4. What amount of money, if any, do you award as punitive damages against Pulda?
Answer: $ 0
Answer Question 5.
CLAIMS AGAINST KRIS DEYOUNG
QUESTION 5. Did defendant Kris DeYoung violate plaintiff Shomas Winston's rights under the Eighth Amendment?
Answer: No (Yes or No)
Answer Question 6.
QUESTION 6. Was defendant DeYoung negligent in providing medical care to plaintiff Winston, causing Winston harm?
Answer: (Yes or No)
If you answered YES to Question 5 OR Question 6, answer Question 7. If you answered NO to Question 5AND Question 6, STOP and do not answer anymore questions.
QUESTION 7. What amount of money, if any, would fairly and adequately compensate Winston for the harm caused by DeYoung?
Answer: $ 0
If you answered YES to Question 5 answer Question 8. If you answered NO to Question 5, STOP and do not answer any more questions.
QUESTION 8. What amount of money, if any, do you award as punitive damages against DeYoung?
Answer: $ 0