From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Williams v. Raines

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1951
67 S.E.2d 343 (N.C. 1951)

Opinion

Filed 7 November, 1951.

1. Appeal and Error 39b — Assignments of error relating to an issue answered in appellant's favor can afford no ground for new trial.

2. Appeal and Error 6c (6) — Exception to misstatement of a contention must be entered in apt time.

APPEAL by plaintiff from Morris, J., May Term, 1951, LENOIR.

Jones, Reed Griffin for plaintiff, appellant.

Whitaker Jeffress for defendants, appellees.


Action for damages arising out of a collision of two automobiles at a street intersection.

Issues of negligence, contributory negligence, and damages were submitted to the jury. The jury answered each of the first two issues "yes." From judgment on the verdict plaintiff appealed.


All of plaintiff's assignments of error, save one, are bottomed on exceptions to the charge of the court on the first issue. As the verdict on that issue was in favor of plaintiff, any error in the charge of the court in respect thereto is harmless and affords no cause for a new trial.

The lone exception to the charge on the second issue is directed to the statement of a contention. It does not appear that this exception was entered in apt time. In any event, we are unable to perceive that plaintiff was prejudiced thereby.

The jury, in a trial free from error on the second issue, has resolved the question of contributory negligence against the plaintiff. He must abide the result.

No error.


Summaries of

Williams v. Raines

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Nov 1, 1951
67 S.E.2d 343 (N.C. 1951)
Case details for

Williams v. Raines

Case Details

Full title:PERCY E. WILLIAMS v. FLOYD RAINES AND WIFE, THELMA NOE RAINES

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Nov 1, 1951

Citations

67 S.E.2d 343 (N.C. 1951)
67 S.E.2d 343

Citing Cases

McLean v. McLean

Plaintiff may not in this manner exculpate himself from fault after the marriage. While it is true the…

Anderson v. Office Supplies

Again, appellant directs six other exceptions to portions of the charge which relate to the first issue.…