From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Williams v. Montgomery

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Apr 27, 1875
60 N.Y. 648 (N.Y. 1875)

Summary

In Williams v. Montgomery (supra) the Court of Appeals in its memorandum decision that declared jurors could not be heard to impeach their verdict, cited only Clum v. Smith and Coster v. Merest (supra), which was a rule nisi for a new trial when the Court of Common Pleas refused affidavits from the jurymen, thinking it might be of pernicious consequence in any case.

Summary of this case from People ex Rel. Nunns v. County Court

Opinion

Argued April 13, 1875

Decided April 27, 1875

N.C. Marvin for the appellant.

W.H. Johnson for the respondent.


ALLEN, J., reads for dismissal of appeal.

All concur; MILLER, J., not sitting.

Appeal dismissed.


Summaries of

Williams v. Montgomery

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Apr 27, 1875
60 N.Y. 648 (N.Y. 1875)

In Williams v. Montgomery (supra) the Court of Appeals in its memorandum decision that declared jurors could not be heard to impeach their verdict, cited only Clum v. Smith and Coster v. Merest (supra), which was a rule nisi for a new trial when the Court of Common Pleas refused affidavits from the jurymen, thinking it might be of pernicious consequence in any case.

Summary of this case from People ex Rel. Nunns v. County Court
Case details for

Williams v. Montgomery

Case Details

Full title:THOMAS D. WILLIAMS, Appellant, v . JOHN C. MONTGOMERY, Respondent

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Apr 27, 1875

Citations

60 N.Y. 648 (N.Y. 1875)

Citing Cases

People ex Rel. Nunns v. County Court

The relator was not brought to book because of his verdict, or because of his part in the rendition of it. Of…

People v. De Lucia, Montella

" (Italics supplied.) In Schrader v. Gertner ( 282 App. Div. 1064), the Second Department said (pp.…