From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Williams v. Baker

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jul 1, 1816
4 N.C. 401 (N.C. 1816)

Opinion

(July Term, 1816.)

An infant under the age of 21 years cannot dispose of his personal estate by will.

THE special verdict in this case found that the testator, Robert Bignall, duly made his last will and testament on 13 July, 1809, and that at the time of his so doing he was upwards of 17 years old, but not of the age of 18, but was of sound discretion. The question reserved is whether he was of sufficient age to make a will of personal property.

A. Henderson and R. H. Jones in support of the will. (402)

Baker in opposition to the will.


The only question raised on the special verdict found in this case is whether a person under the age of 18 years can dispose of his personal estate by will.

The common law has wisely fixed on the age of 21 as the earliest period when the human mind has attained sufficient maturity to act with discretion. The rules established in the ecclesiastical courts of England, which allow infants to dispose of their personal estate by will, have never been in force and use in this State. If they had, we should feel ourselves bound by them, notwithstanding their repugnancy to common sense and the common law. We cannot subscribe to the doctrine that a person may have a legal capacity to dispose of property by will, and yet be under a legal incapacity to dispose of the same property by deed.


Summaries of

Williams v. Baker

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jul 1, 1816
4 N.C. 401 (N.C. 1816)
Case details for

Williams v. Baker

Case Details

Full title:WILLIAMS v. BAKER. — 2 L. R., 599

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jul 1, 1816

Citations

4 N.C. 401 (N.C. 1816)