From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Welby v. H.J. Sandberg Co.

Oregon Supreme Court
Jul 29, 1959
343 P.2d 528 (Or. 1959)

Opinion

Argued June 18, 1959

Affirmed July 29, 1959

Appeal from the Circuit Court, Multnomah County, E.K. OPPENHEIMER, Judge.

James C. Dezendorf argued the cause for appellant. On the briefs were Koerner, Young, McColloch Dezendorf and Marshall C. Cheney, Jr., Portland.

William C. Martin argued the cause for respondent. On the brief were Dusenbery, Martin, Schwab, Beatty Parks, Portland.

Before McALLISTER, Chief Justice, and WARNER, SLOAN and MILLARD, Justices.


AFFIRMED.


This is an appeal from a judgment in an action wherein the plaintiff, Welby, as a former employee of the defendant, H.J. Sandberg Co., a corporation, sought to recover for commissions alleged to have been earned on certain furnace sales made by him in behalf of defendant prior to the termination of his employment on June 30, 1954.

Reference is made to the case of Lenchitsky v. H.J. Sandberg Co., 217 Or. 483, 343 P.2d 523, decided this date. Therein, it will be found that the issues are identical with those in this case, except in terms of amounts and period of employment covered. Welby's employment was terminated June 30, 1954, whereas, Lenchitsky's connection with defendant continued until July 24, 1954. Both employees operated under the same form of employment contract.

Likewise, the assignments of error urged by the appellant in the Lenchitsky case have their counterpart in the instant matter, with one exception. Here, the appellant makes no assignment with respect to requested instructions.

The arguments here also raise identical questions and present parallel authorities to those in Lenchitsky.

The facts upon which the claim of accord and satisfaction rests, though somewhat different in substance, are so nearly the same in legal effect that we find it unnecessary to spread any part of them in this report.

Therefore, on the authority of Lenchitsky, supra, the judgment in the instant matter is affirmed.


Summaries of

Welby v. H.J. Sandberg Co.

Oregon Supreme Court
Jul 29, 1959
343 P.2d 528 (Or. 1959)
Case details for

Welby v. H.J. Sandberg Co.

Case Details

Full title:WELBY v. H.J. SANDBERG COMPANY

Court:Oregon Supreme Court

Date published: Jul 29, 1959

Citations

343 P.2d 528 (Or. 1959)
343 P.2d 528