From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Weatherman v. Tobacco Company

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Apr 1, 1930
152 S.E. 796 (N.C. 1930)

Opinion

(Filed 16 April, 1930.)

Negligence D c — Nonsuit is proper where evidence fails to show that plaintiff was injured by negligence of defendant.

An action to recover damages for a personal injury alleged to have been negligently inflicted will be nonsuited in the absence of evidence tending to show that the plaintiff was injured by the negligence of the defendant as alleged in the complaint. Owenby v. Power Co., 194 N.C. 129, cited and applied.

APPEAL by plaintiff from Schenck, J., at February Term, 1930, of FORSYTH. Affirmed.

John D. Slawter and Parrish Deal for plaintiff.

Manly, Hendren Womble for defendant.


STACY, C. J., not sitting.


This is an action to recover damages for personal injuries sustained by plaintiff, while he was at work as a carpenter in a building under construction by the defendant.

The action was tried in the Forsyth County Court. From judgment dismissing the action as upon nonsuit, at the close of the evidence, plaintiff appealed to the Superior Court of Forsyth County. His only assignment of error on said appeal, was based on his exception to the judgment of the County Court.

From judgment of the Superior Court, overruling his assignment of error, and affirming the judgment of the County Court, plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court.


The judgment of the Forsyth County Court, dismissing this action, at the close of the evidence, as upon nonsuit, is supported by the decision of this Court in Owenby v. Power Co., 194 N.C. 129, 138 S.E. 529. The evidence did not tend to show any facts upon which defendant could be held liable to plaintiff for damages resulting from his injuries. In the absence of evidence tending to show that plaintiff was injured by the negligence of defendant, as alleged in the complaint, the action was properly dismissed by the Forsyth County Court.

There is no error in the judgment of the Superior Court, affirming the judgment of the County Court. The judgment is

Affirmed.

STACY, C. J., not sitting.


Summaries of

Weatherman v. Tobacco Company

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Apr 1, 1930
152 S.E. 796 (N.C. 1930)
Case details for

Weatherman v. Tobacco Company

Case Details

Full title:W. C. WEATHERMAN v. R. J. REYNOLDS TOBACCO COMPANY

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Apr 1, 1930

Citations

152 S.E. 796 (N.C. 1930)
152 S.E. 796

Citing Cases

King v. Printing Co.

" The Court, speaking through the Chief Justice, said: "Plaintiff's injury seems to have resulted from one of…