From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Warren v. Brown

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1870
64 N.C. 381 (N.C. 1870)

Opinion

January Term, 1870.

A note payable "in current notes of the State of North Carolina," is not negotiable; therefore, under our former system an endorsee thereof could not maintain an action at law upon it, in his own name.

ASSUMPSIT, tried before Cloud, J., at Fall Term 1869 of WILKES Superior Court.

Boyden Bailey for the appellant.

No counsel contra.


The plaintiff declared as endorsee ( second) of a note for $1175.50 made by the defendant, June 18th 1862, at one day after date "to be paid in current notes of the State of North Carolina."

The defendant objected that he could not maintain an (382) action upon it in his own name.

His Honor was of a different opinion. Verdict and Judgment for the plaintiff, and Appeal by the defendant.


Are "current notes of the State of North Carolina" the same things as money, in contemplation of law?

Nothing but coin was a legal tender in payment of a note for money, before the recent acts of Congress. This note bears date June 18th 1862, and is payable "in current notes of the State of North Carolina," which may mean, either Treasury Notes of the State, or, notes on various banks of the State. A note, to be negotiable, should be for a sum certain, payable in money, and without conditions. Here the suit was instituted before the adoption of the Code, by a second endorsee, in his own name, on a note not negotiable.

The objection is fatal to the present action.

Per curiam.

Judgment reversed.

Cited: Johnson v. Henderson, 76 N.C. 229.


Summaries of

Warren v. Brown

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jan 1, 1870
64 N.C. 381 (N.C. 1870)
Case details for

Warren v. Brown

Case Details

Full title:P. M. WARREN v. NOAH BROWN

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jan 1, 1870

Citations

64 N.C. 381 (N.C. 1870)

Citing Cases

Johnson v. Henderson

And unless the instrument on its face affords every element to fix its value such a paper is only a special…