From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Warner v. A. G. Anderson, Inc.

Supreme Court of Minnesota
May 8, 1942
212 Minn. 610 (Minn. 1942)

Opinion

No. 33,185.

May 8, 1942.

Municipal court — review of judgment.

Certiorari upon the relation of Victor A. Warner to review a judgment of the municipal court of Duluth, St. Louis county, Richard M. Funck, Judge, adverse to relator. Writ quashed.

Leslie S. High, for relator.

A.J. Zoerb, for respondent.



This matter is purportedly before us upon a writ of certiorari to review a judgment of the municipal court of Duluth adverse to relator. However, we are not authorized to review it. By statute, a party may appeal from a judgment of the municipal court of Duluth "upon the same grounds and in like manner, and upon like proceedings" as in the case of appeals from the district court to the supreme court. L. 1923, c. 238, § 47; amended, L. 1937, c. 143. "A judgment * * * in a civil action in a district court may be removed to the supreme court by appeal, as provided in this chapter, and not otherwise." Mason St. 1927, § 9490. Review by certiorari is thus excluded. The writ, having been improvidently issued, must be quashed. State ex rel. Village of Buhl v. District Court, 136 Minn. 461, 161 N.W. 1055; Neumann v. Edwards, 146 Minn. 179, 178 N.W. 589.

So ordered.


Summaries of

Warner v. A. G. Anderson, Inc.

Supreme Court of Minnesota
May 8, 1942
212 Minn. 610 (Minn. 1942)
Case details for

Warner v. A. G. Anderson, Inc.

Case Details

Full title:VICTOR A. WARNER v. A. G. ANDERSON, INC

Court:Supreme Court of Minnesota

Date published: May 8, 1942

Citations

212 Minn. 610 (Minn. 1942)
3 N.W.2d 673