From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

W. S. Thompson Co. V. Bond, County Treas

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 8, 1915
149 P. 1098 (Okla. 1915)

Opinion

NO. 6908

Opinion Filed June 8, 1915.

COURTS — Supreme Court — Jurisdiction — Taxation — Assessment of Omitted Property. The Supreme Court is without jurisdiction to review on appeal an order or judgment of the county court rendered on appeal from an order or decision of a county treasurer, assessing property for taxation alleged to have been unlawfully omitted from the tax returns of a certain year.

(Syllabus by the Court.)

Error from County Court, Atoka County; Baxter Taylor, Judge.

Appeal by W. S. Thompson Co. from the action of Henry J. Bond, County Treasurer, assessing certain property for taxation. From the judgment of the county court, W. S. Thompson Co. brings error. Dismissed.

J. G. Ralls, for plaintiff in error.

J. W. Clark, Co. Atty. of Atoka County, for defendant in error.


This is an appeal from a judgment of the county court, rendered April 18, 1914, on appeal to said court from the action of Henry C. Bond, county treasurer, assessing for taxes certain property belonging to plaintiff in error, alleged to have been omitted from the tax returns for the year 1910. Defendant in error seeks by motion to dismiss the appeal.

In the case of McAlester Trust Co. v. Watson, County Treas., 45 Okla. 607, 146 P. 586, it was held that no appeal lies to the Supreme Court to review an order or judgment of the county court rendered on appeal to that court from the action of a county treasurer, assessing property for taxation unlawfully omitted from the tax returns for a certain year.

Plaintiff in error, in his brief, contends that the action of the county court was in exercise of original, and not appellate, jurisdiction. Without discussing this question in the light presented, it is sufficient to say that it has been established as the law of this jurisdiction that this court has no jurisdiction in such cases.

On the authority of the above case and cases therein cited, the appeal is dismissed.

All the Justices concur.


Summaries of

W. S. Thompson Co. V. Bond, County Treas

Supreme Court of Oklahoma
Jun 8, 1915
149 P. 1098 (Okla. 1915)
Case details for

W. S. Thompson Co. V. Bond, County Treas

Case Details

Full title:W. S. THOMPSON CO. v. BOND, County Treasurer

Court:Supreme Court of Oklahoma

Date published: Jun 8, 1915

Citations

149 P. 1098 (Okla. 1915)
149 P. 1098

Citing Cases

Watson v. Bond, County Treasurer

BROWN, J. This is a companion case to W. S. Thompson Co. v. Henry S. Bond, County Treasurer, ante, 149 P.…

School Dist. No. 7 of Johnston County v. Cunningham

The statute gave an appeal from the action of the county treasurer to the county court, but was silent as to…