From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Vermeer Manufacturing Co. v. Vandiver Ford

Supreme Court of Arkansas
May 9, 1983
650 S.W.2d 244 (Ark. 1983)

Summary

holding that order dismissing just one defendant was not final, appealable order

Summary of this case from Downing v. Lawrence Hall Nursing Ctr.

Opinion

Opinion delivered May 9, 1983

APPEAL ERROR — JUDGMENT INVOLVING MULTIPLE PARTIES — FAILURE OF ORDER OF COURT TO COMPLY WITH ARCP RULE 54 (b) REQUIRES DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE. — Where the order of the trial court dismissing one of several defendants does not recite that there is no just reason for delaying an appeal nor does it direct the entry of a final judgment in favor of said defendant, ARCP Rule 54(b) requires that the appeal be dismissed without prejudice to appeal when a final judgment is entered.

Motion to Dismiss; motion granted.

Pollard Cavaneau, by: Jerry Cavaneau, for appellant.

Lightle, Beebe, Raney Bell, by: Donald Raney, for appellee Vandiver.

Smith Nixon, by: W. R. Nixon, Jr., for appellee Ford Motor Company.


This case involves multiple claims of relief and liability among multiple parties. The trial court dismissed one defendant, Ford Motor Company, on the basis of lack of venue. The other parties now seek to appeal that ruling. However, the order of the trial court does not recite that there is no just reason for delaying an appeal nor does it direct the entry of a final judgment in favor of Ford Motor Company. Therefore, ARCP Rule 54(b) requires that the present appeal be dismissed without prejudice to appeal when a final judgment is entered.


Summaries of

Vermeer Manufacturing Co. v. Vandiver Ford

Supreme Court of Arkansas
May 9, 1983
650 S.W.2d 244 (Ark. 1983)

holding that order dismissing just one defendant was not final, appealable order

Summary of this case from Downing v. Lawrence Hall Nursing Ctr.

In Vermeer Manufacturing Co. v. Vandiver, 279 Ark. 218, 650 S.W.2d 244 (1983), only one claim was resolved against one party in a multiple-party case.

Summary of this case from Downing v. Lawrence Hall Nursing Ctr.
Case details for

Vermeer Manufacturing Co. v. Vandiver Ford

Case Details

Full title:VERMEER MANUFACTURING COMPANY v. Jimmy VANDIVER, a/k/a VANDIVER EQUIPMENT…

Court:Supreme Court of Arkansas

Date published: May 9, 1983

Citations

650 S.W.2d 244 (Ark. 1983)
650 S.W.2d 244

Citing Cases

Downing v. Lawrence Hall Nursing Ctr.

The court explained that "[b]ecause there is not a final order as to these two defendants or a Rule 54(b)…