U.S. v. Philip Morris USA Inc.

Full title: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, Plaintiff, v. PHILIP MORRIS USA INC. (f/k/a…

Court: United States District Court, D. Columbia

Date published: Oct 5, 2003

Civil Action No. 99-CV-2496 (GK) (D.D.C. Oct. 5, 2003)

Opinion

Civil Action No. 99-CV-2496 (GK).

October 5, 2003

ORDER # 677

GLADYS KESSLER, District Judge

Upon consideration of the Notice of Filing By Defendant Liggett Group Inc. In Support Of Protection At Trial Of Information In The Proffered Designated Testimony and Exhibits of Drs. Robert Bereman and Anthony Albino, it is this 5th day of October, 2003

ORDERED that the following portions of the April 23, 2002 deposition of Dr. Robert Bereman shall be redacted and maintained as confidential, and under seal, and shall not be made public at the trial of this action:

Page Line

13 21-25

14 1-2 4 7-10 12 15-17 21-23

15 3-22

21 9-25

22 2-11

23 19-25

24 2

29 25

30 2-13

31 7-9

34 10-12 18-25

35 2-25

38 14-25

39 8-13 (Cat II) 17-24 (Cat II)

40 8-13 (Cat II) 15-25 (Cat II)

41 2-3 (Cat II) 6-25 (Cat II)

42 2-22 (Cat II) 25 (Cat II)

43 2-10 (Cat II) 14-25 (Cat II)

44 2-5 (Cat II) 11-25 (Cat II)

45 2-3 (Cat II) 7 10-25 (Cat I)

46 1-25 (Cat I)

47 1-13 (Cat I) 16-19 (Cat I) 21-22 (Cat I) 48 3-25 (Cat II)

49 2-25 (Cat II)

50 2-25 (Cat II)

51 2-7 (Cat II) 9-11 13 (Cat II) 20-25 (Cat II)

52 14-25

53 2-7

54 3-25 (Cat I)

55 2 13-25 (Cat II)

56 2-3 6-9 (Cat II)

58 3-6 9-21

60 3-4 (Cat I) 9-18 (Cat I) 20-25 (Cat II)

61 2-20 (Cat II) 22-25 (Cat II)

62 2-25 (Cat II)

63 4-7 (Cat I) 17-19 (Cat II)

64 6-10 (Cat II) 12-17 (Cat II)

65 4-8 (Cat I) 12-17 (Cat I) 22-25 (Cat II)

66 2-13 (Cat II) 22-25 (Cat II)

67 8-10 (Cat II) 13-19 (Cat II) 21 (Cat II) 25 (Cat II)

68 4-5 7 (Cat I) 18-21 (Cat II) 23-25 (Cat II)

69 2-9 (Cat II) 15-18 (Cat II) 22-25 (Cat II)

70 1-12 (Cat II)

72 11-25 (Cat I)

73 2

75 16-18

76 14-17 22-23

77 9-13 (Cat II) 16-20 (Cat II) 22-25 (Cat II)

78 2-20 (Cat II)

79 7-14 (Cat II) 17-25 (Cat II)

80 2-25 (Cat II)

81 1-8 (Cat II) 13-14 17-25 82 2 6-10 (Cat II) 12-16 (Cat II) 18-21

83 9-25 (Cat II)

84 4-10 (Cat II) 22-23 (Cat II)

85 2-13 (Cat I) 16-19 24-25

86 13-25 (Cat II)

87 2-4 (Cat II) 13-20

88 3-25 (Cat II)

89 2-11 (Cat II) 17-25 (Cat II)

90 1-25 (Cat II)

91 1-25 (Cat II)

92 1-21 (Cat II)

93 9-25 (Cat II)

94 2-21 (Cat II)

95 7-13

97 20-25 (Cat I)

98 2-6 (Cat I) 24-25 (Cat I)

99 2-7 (Cat I) 18-22

100 6-10 18-22 25

101 2-6 (Cat I) 18-19

104 17-25 (Cat II)

105 2-23

107 3-7 10-11 14-16

108 2-6 (Cat II) 12-15 (Cat I) 17-22 (Cat I)

109 2-6 (Cat I) 14 18-20 23

110 13-19 (Cat I) 22-25

111 2-6 14-17 20-22 24-25

112 2-5 13-14 16-18

113 22-25

114 2-4 10-12

115 11-25 (Cat II)

116 10-11

117 22-25 (Cat I)

118 2-25 (Cat II)

119 2-11 (Cat II) 15-19 (Cat II)

120 1-8 (Cat II) 11-12 (Cat II) 16-18 (Cat II) 20 (Cat II)

122 13-25

124 11-15 20-25 (Cat I)

125 2-10 (Cat I)

126 11-14 (Cat I)

128 9-10 18-25 (Cat II)

129 2-25 (Cat II)

130 2 (Cat II) 6-9 (Cat II) 11-15 (Cat II) 17 (Cat II) 20-23 (Cat I)

131 4-5 20-21

132 8-23 (Cat II)

133 2-3 6-7 11

134 6-14 (Cat II)

136 6

137 9-11 (Cat II)

138 9-10 (Cat II) 14-15 (Cat I)

139 13-15 (Cat I) 17 (Cat I)

144 11 25

145 2-10 (Cat II)

146 5-11 (Cat II)

148 3-12 (Cat I) 17-24 (Cat I)

149 2-18 (Cat I)

152 24

157 3-5 (Cat II) 24-25

AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the following portions of the April 26, 2002 deposition of Dr. Anthony Albino shall be redacted and maintained as confidential, and under seal, and shall not be made public at the trial of this action:

Page Line

11 3-14

15 4-25

16 2-9 14-16 18-25

17 2

27 6-24

28 12-25

29 2-24

30 2-15

31 2-18

32 2-25

33 2-25

34 2-8 (Cat I) 12-25 (Cat I)

35 2-25 (Cat I)

36 2-4 13-21 22-25

37 2-25 (Cat I)

38 2-25 (Cat I)

39 2-8 (Cat I) 16-25 (Cat I)

40 5-22 (Cat I) 23-25 (Cat II)

41 2-3 (Cat II) 4-14 (Cat I) 22-24 (Cat I)

42 4-25 (Cat I)

43 5-7 (Cat I) 10 12 14-17 (Cat I) 21-25 (Cat I)

44 4 (Cat I) 7-9 (Cat I) 12-13 17-23

45 10-21 25

46 2 16-18 (Cat I) 21-22

47 4-8 10 12-13 (Cat I) 15-22 (Cat I)

48 4-20 (Cat I)

49 2-3 (Cat I) 5-6 10 16-19 22

50 3-9 14-19 (Cat I)

51 23-25 (Cat I)

52 19-22

53 15-22

54 7-12 13-14 (Cat I) 15-19 20-22 (Cat I) 25 (Cat I)

55 2 (Cat I) 6-9 (Cat I) 12-13 (Cat I) 16 (Cat I) 18 (Cat I) 20-25 (Cat I)

56 2 (Cat I) 6-7 (Cat I) 9-14 (Cat I) 17-18 (Cat I) 20-22 (Cat I)

57 2-7 (Cat I) 9 12-25 (Cat I)

58 5-7 10-12 17-25 (Cat I) 59 2-25 (Cat I)

60 5-7 (Cat I) 13-22 (Cat I) 24-25 (Cat I)

61 2-9 (Cat I) 14 (Cat I)

62 6-25 (Cat I)

63 2-10 (Cat I) 17-25 (Cat I)

64 2-14 (Cat I) 17-24 (Cat I)

65 2-7 (Cat I) 17-25 (Cat I)

68 5-7 (Cat I) 9 17-18 (Cat I)

69 2-17 (Cat I) 24-25 (Cat I)

70 2-5 (Cat I)

71 25

72 2-25

73 2

74 5-17 21-25

75 2-11

76 4-7 14-25

77 2-9 13-16

78 15-25

79 2-25

80 2-25

81 2-25

82 24-25

83 2-23 24-25 (Cat I)

84 2 (Cat I) 6-10 18-20 22-25 (Cat I)

85 2 (Cat I) 4-13 (Cat I)

86 17-25

87 2-25 (Cat I)

88 2-7 17-25 (Cat I)

89 2-14 (Cat I) 17-24 25 (Cat I)

90 2-14 (Cat I)

91 14-25

92 2-16 (Cat I)

93 18-21

95 4-25

96 5-25

97 2-8

AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the following portions of the June 26, 2003 deposition of Dr. Anthony Albino shall be redacted and maintained as confidential, and under seal, and shall not be made public at the trial of this action:

Page(s) and Line(s)

Page 21, Line 14 through Page 26, Line 8

Page 28, Line 15

Page 29, Lines 18-20

Page 32, Lines 9-22

Page 33, Lines 12-18

Page 33, Lines 23 through Page 36, Line 11

Page 53, Line 19 through Page 56, Line 19

Page 39, Line 18 through Page 40, Line 213

Page 72, Line 11 through Page 108, Line 16

Page 143, Line 4 through Page 232, Line 5

AND IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the following exhibits shall be maintained as confidential, and under seal, and shall not be made public at the trial of this action:

U.S. Exhibit Nos. 72,701; 72,412, 64,727; 64,731; 64,732; 77,744; and 77,745.