Opinion
Criminal Case No. 09-cr-00215-WYD.
November 4, 2010
ORDER
THIS MATTER comes before the Court on the Government's Unopposed Motion to Permit Disclosure of Grand Jury Transcripts of Testimony Before the Grand Jury Before Trial [ECF No. 120], filed October 29, 2010. Having reviewed the file and being sufficiently advised in the premises, the Court finds and concludes as follows:
Rule (6)(e)(3)(E) provides in part that the "court may authorize disclosure — at a time, in a manner, and subject to any other conditions that it directs — of a grand jury matter: (i) preliminarily to or in connection with a judicial proceeding . . ." Rule (6)(e)(3)(F) provides in part that, when the government files a motion for disclosure, the hearing on said motion may be done ex parte.
In this case, as in many cases, there are competing considerations of trial efficiency and grand jury confidentiality. The government's motion suggests some conditions which would accommodate the best interests of justice served by Fed.R.Crim.P. 6 and 26.2.
Being now sufficiently advised in the premises, the Court hereby
ORDERS that the government may disclose to the active defense counsel of record in this case transcripts of grand jury testimony or material considered by the grand jury (whether on paper or by means of electronic media) in relation to the indictment or superseding indictments, if any, of the above named defendants.
The receipt of said grand jury material shall be subject to certain conditions. The Court directs and hereby
ORDERS that: (1) copies of grand jury transcripts or other material provided to the defense counsel of record shall remain in the personal control of counsel — although the defendant may review the Grand Jury transcript or material, the grand jury transcripts and material shall not be entrusted to the defendant outside of the presence of counsel; (2) although a print out for official use only may be permitted, no further publication or duplication of such grand jury transcripts or material shall be made without permission of the Court; and (3) any grand jury transcripts or material disclosed pursuant to this order, including print outs from electronic media, shall to be delivered to the United States Attorney's Office after the conclusion of the case. Any grand jury transcripts or material received pursuant to this order shall be used for official purposes only.
Dated: November 4, 2010