Univ. of Pittsburgh of the Commonwealth Sys. of Higher Educ. v. Varian Med. Sys., Inc.

Full title: UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH OF THE COMMONWEALTH SYSTEM OF HIGHER EDUCATION…

Court: UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA

Date published: Apr 2, 2012

Civil Action No.: 2:08-cv-01307 (W.D. Pa. Apr. 2, 2012)

Opinion

Civil Action No.: 2:08-cv-01307

04-02-2012

UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH OF THE COMMONWEALTH SYSTEM OF HIGHER EDUCATION d/b/a UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH Plaintiff, v. VARIAN MEDICAL SYSTEMS, INC. Defendant.

Arthur J. Schwab

Judge Arthur J. Schwab

FILED ELECTRONICALLY

ORDER OF COURT RE: PARTIES' OBJECTIONS TO EXHIBITS FOR INVALIDITY PORTION OF TRIAL

Presently before this Court is the Amended Combined Exhibit Chart for the Invalidity Trial, which include their objections to exhibits' authenticity and/or admissibility. Doc. No. 752. After careful review of the exhibits and objections thereto, the Court rules as follows:

AND NOW, on this 2nd day of April 2012, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT:

1. Defendant's objections to the following Plaintiff's exhibits are OVERRULED:

• PPP-005 (provided a witness authenticates);
• PPP-007 (provided a witness authenticates);
• PPP-008 (provided a witness authenticates);
• PPP-009 (provided a witness authenticates);
• PPP-020-043; and
• PPP-133a.

2. Defendant's objection to the following Plaintiff's Exhibits are SUSTAINED:

• PP-072;
• PPP-044;
• PPP-131-133;

3. Plaintiff's objections to the following Defendant's exhibits are SUSTAINED:

• D-013;
• D-016;
• D-110-111;
• D-115;
• D-194;
• D-196;
• D-218;
• D-218a;
• D-219;
• D-219a;
• D-220;
• DD-073;
• DD-664;
• DDD-001 (because PPP-129 includes DDD-001);
• DDD-031;
• DDD-054;
• JT-027 (pages 01-278); and
• JT-028.

4. Plaintiff's objections to the following Defendant's exhibits are OVERRULED:

• D-050a;
• D-050b;
• D-051;
• DDD-007;
• DDD-021-023;
• DDD-025-028;
• DDD-030;
• P-185;
• P-199;
• P-252; and
• JT-027 (pages 279-504).

5. Defendant's objection to the Plaintiff's Exhibit PP-069 is OVERRULED AS MOOT (pursuant to the parties' stipulation).

6. Plaintiff's objections to the following Defendant's exhibits are SUSTAINED, pursuant to the Court's rulings on the motions in limine (doc. no. 741):

• D-029-34;
• D096;
• D-109;
• D-112;
• D-124;
• D-126-127;
• D-129;
• D-132;
• D-135-136;
• D-139-141;
• D-144-145;
• D-147-149;
• D-154-155;
• D-171;
• D-213-215;
• DD-161;
• DD-282;
• DDD-032-053; and
• DDD-055-065.

___________

Arthur J. Schwab

United States District Judge

cc: All Registered ECF Counsel and Parties