From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Union National Bank, v. Mayor, Aldermen and Commonalty

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Sep 1, 1872
51 N.Y. 638 (N.Y. 1872)

Summary

In Hodges v. Guardian Life Ins. Co., 51 N.Y. 638, the plaintiff's counsel was permitted, in summing up, to read from and state, after objections, the contents of a certain pamphlet which had been rejected when offered in evidence, although proved to have been issued by the defendant.

Summary of this case from Hoffman v. New York Railways Co.

Opinion

Argued May 17, 1872

Decided September term, 1872

W. Howard Waite for the appellant.

R. O'Gorman for the respondents.


LOTT, Ch. C., reads for reversal.

Judgment for plaintiff for amount of its claim, with interest from the time tax was paid, with costs, unless defendants elect to withdraw demurrer and answer complaint on payment of all costs accruing subsequent to demurrer.

All concur.

Judgment accordingly.


Summaries of

Union National Bank, v. Mayor, Aldermen and Commonalty

Court of Appeals of the State of New York
Sep 1, 1872
51 N.Y. 638 (N.Y. 1872)

In Hodges v. Guardian Life Ins. Co., 51 N.Y. 638, the plaintiff's counsel was permitted, in summing up, to read from and state, after objections, the contents of a certain pamphlet which had been rejected when offered in evidence, although proved to have been issued by the defendant.

Summary of this case from Hoffman v. New York Railways Co.
Case details for

Union National Bank, v. Mayor, Aldermen and Commonalty

Case Details

Full title:THE UNION NATIONAL BANK OF THE CITY OF NEW YORK, Appellant, v . THE MAYOR…

Court:Court of Appeals of the State of New York

Date published: Sep 1, 1872

Citations

51 N.Y. 638 (N.Y. 1872)

Citing Cases

Hoffman v. New York Railways Co.

In the case at bar it appears clearly (1) that the references to the extraneous matters were made in palpably…

Hamilton v. County of San Diego

San Francisco , 16 Cal. 255; Louisville v. Anderson , 79 Ky. 334; 42 Am. Rep. 221; Talbot v. National Bank ,…