From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Ulrich v. Kessler

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Dec 9, 1938
282 N.W. 801 (Minn. 1938)

Opinion

No. 31,749.

December 9, 1938.

New trial — inadequate damages.

A new trial should be had where inadequate damages are awarded under the influence of passion and prejudice.

Action in the district court for LeSueur county to recover damages for assault. The case was tried before Joseph J. Moriarty, Judge, and a jury. After verdict in his favor for $50, plaintiff appealed from an order denying his motion for a new trial. Reversed.

Lauerman Pfeiffer and Edwin C. Kraus, for appellant.

H.A. Irwin, for respondent.



Plaintiff sues for assault, claiming that on September 18, 1936, defendant struck him in the mouth with such force as to knock off and break loose three of his front upper teeth, necessitating extraction by a dentist. As a result plaintiff suffered severe bodily and mental pain and suffering. Defendant admitted that he struck plaintiff and claimed self-defense. Plaintiff's special damages for dental services were $65 and undisputed. The case was submitted under adequate instructions. The jury rendered a verdict in favor of plaintiff for $50. Either plaintiff was entitled to recover the $65 special damages and something additional for general damages or he was not entitled to recover at all. The verdict is predicated upon a finding of defendant's liability. The damages are not adequate to compensate for the special damages sustained by plaintiff. A new trial should be had where, as here, the damages awarded are inadequate and appear to have been awarded under the influence of passion or prejudice. Hill v. Ross, 198 Minn. 199, 269 N.W. 396; Flaugh v. Egan Chevrolet, Inc. 202 Minn. 615, 279 N.W. 582. The inadequacy of damages coupled with a finding of liability shows failure to give the case impartial and conscientious consideration.

Reversed and new trial granted.


Summaries of

Ulrich v. Kessler

Supreme Court of Minnesota
Dec 9, 1938
282 N.W. 801 (Minn. 1938)
Case details for

Ulrich v. Kessler

Case Details

Full title:HENRY ULRICH v. EDWIN KESSLER

Court:Supreme Court of Minnesota

Date published: Dec 9, 1938

Citations

282 N.W. 801 (Minn. 1938)
282 N.W. 801

Citing Cases

Seydel v. Reuber

Under the circumstances, we feel that no logical purpose will be served in sending the case back for trial on…

Olson v. Christiansen

Either plaintiff was entitled to recover his actual special damages and something additional for general…