From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Price

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Jul 11, 1927
113 So. 882 (La. 1927)

Opinion

No. 28704.

July 11, 1927.

Appeal from Eighth Judicial District Court, Parish of LaSalle; F.E. Jones, Judge.

J.D. Price was charged with having committed a misdemeanor in office. From a judgment quashing the indictment, the State appeals. Appeal dismissed.

Percy Saint, Atty. Gen., and Harry Fuller, Dist. Atty., of Winnfield (E.R. Schowalter, of New Orleans, of counsel), for the State.

Overton Hunter, of Alexandria, and Henagan Gaharan, of Jena, for appellee.


The state appeals from a judgment quashing an indictment against the defendant which charged him with having committed a misdemeanor in office in violation of Act 254 of 1912.

The defendant has filed a motion to dismiss the appeal for want of appellate jurisdiction in this court.

The penalty prescribed by the statute is a fine not exceeding $500 or imprisonment not exceeding six months.

The appellate jurisdiction of this court in criminal matters extends, on questions of law only, to cases in which the punishment of death or imprisonment at hard labor may be inflicted, or a fine exceeding $300 or imprisonment exceeding six months is actually imposed. Section 10, art. 7, Constitution of 1921.

It will be seen that, while in the first-mentioned class of cases (felonies) the question of appellate jurisdiction is determined by the character of the offense charged as measured by the punishment that may be inflicted, in the last-mentioned class of cases (misdemeanors), the question of appellate jurisdiction is determined, not by the penalty that may be imposed, but by that which is actually imposed, and which must be a fine exceeding $300 or an imprisonment exceeding six months.

The instant case belongs to the last-mentioned class of cases, and, as no sentence has been imposed, there is no appeal. There can be no appeal by the state in misdemeanors where the indictment or information has been quashed. State v. Smith, 39 La. Ann. 231, 1 So. 452; State v. Blanchard, 45 La. Ann. 939, 12 So. 933; State v. Cox, 114 La. 570, 38 So. 456; State v. Kramer, 127 La. 1034, 54 So. 341.

The appeal is dismissed.


Summaries of

State v. Price

Supreme Court of Louisiana
Jul 11, 1927
113 So. 882 (La. 1927)
Case details for

State v. Price

Case Details

Full title:STATE v. PRICE

Court:Supreme Court of Louisiana

Date published: Jul 11, 1927

Citations

113 So. 882 (La. 1927)
113 So. 882

Citing Cases

State v. Shushan

The concluding paragraph of Section 10 of Article VII of the Constitution provides that the appellate…

State v. McNeal

Article 7, Section 10, of the Louisiana Constitution of 1921 provides, insofar as it is applicable to this…