From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State v. Lyon

The Supreme Court of Washington
Nov 23, 1933
27 P.2d 131 (Wash. 1933)

Opinion

No. 24533. Department One.

November 23, 1933.

CORPORATIONS (139) — OFFICERS AND AGENTS — LIABILITY FOR CORPORATE ACTS — CRIMINAL RESPONSIBILITY. Under Rem. Rev. Stat., § 8330, requiring every distributor of liquid fuel to render monthly statements of the liquid fuel sold, to be sworn to by an officer of the distributor if made by a domestic corporation, and Id., § 8338, making violations of the act a gross misdemeanor, an officer of a corporation distributing liquid fuel cannot be charged with the offense, in view of Id., §§ 2011-1 to 2011-4, outlining the procedure for criminal actions against corporations.

Appeal from a judgment of the superior court for Spokane county, Webster, J., entered February 18, 1933, dismissing a prosecution for failure to report and pay excise taxes on sales of liquid fuel, upon sustaining a demurrer to the information. Affirmed.

Chas. W. Greenough and Carl P. Lang, for appellant.

Orville W. Duell and Gleeson Gleeson, for respondent.


Defendant was charged in each of three counts of an information with the crime of "failure to report sales of liquid fuel," and in a fourth count with the crime of "failure to pay excise tax on sales of liquid fuel." A demurrer to each count of the information was sustained. The state having elected to stand on the information, judgment of dismissal was entered, from which the state has appealed.

The information alleged that respondent was the manager and principal officer of Consumers Mutual Oil Company, a domestic corporation and a distributor of liquid fuel, and that, as such officer, he had wilfully and unlawfully failed to prepare and render to the director of licenses of the state a sworn statement of the number of gallons of liquid fuel sold by the company during certain months; further, that, as such officer, he had wilfully and unlawfully failed to pay to the state treasurer the excise tax due the state on liquid fuel sold by the company on and prior to a certain date.

Rem. Rev. Stat., § 8330, provides that every distributor of liquid fuel shall render to the director of licenses, on or before the fifteenth day of each month, on forms prescribed, prepared and furnished by the director, a statement of the number of gallons of liquid fuel sold by it, him or them, during the preceding calendar month, "which statement shall be sworn to by one of the principal officers in case of a domestic corporation." Rem. Rev. Stat., § 8338, provides that any distributor, association of persons, firm or corporation who shall violate any of the provisions of the act containing the above sections shall be guilty of a gross misdemeanor.

It is not alleged in the information that the respondent was himself a distributor, but merely that he was an officer of a distributor.

[1] Obviously, the statute imposes certain duties upon distributors of liquid fuel, not upon their officers or employees. With reference to the required monthly statement, the gist of the offense is not the failure of an officer of a corporation to swear to such statement, but the failure of the distributor to render a statement properly sworn to. With reference to the payment of the tax, the offense is not the failure of the officer to pay it, but the failure of the distributor to pay it. The duties and obligations created by the statute are upon the distributor, and the offense arising from the failure to comply with the statute is, likewise, the offense of the distributor.

The procedure for criminal actions against corporations is outlined in Rem. Rev. Stat., §§ 2011-1 to 2011-4, inclusive. If, in this instance, any offense was committed, it was committed by the corporation distributor, not by the respondent, its officer.

The judgment of dismissal is affirmed.

BEALS, C.J., MAIN, MITCHELL, and MILLARD, JJ., concur.


Summaries of

State v. Lyon

The Supreme Court of Washington
Nov 23, 1933
27 P.2d 131 (Wash. 1933)
Case details for

State v. Lyon

Case Details

Full title:THE STATE OF WASHINGTON, Appellant, v. A.H. LYON, Respondent

Court:The Supreme Court of Washington

Date published: Nov 23, 1933

Citations

27 P.2d 131 (Wash. 1933)
27 P.2d 131
175 Wash. 199

Citing Cases

County of King v. Graf

The petitioners have nothing to do with operating or maintaining such places and cannot be subject to…