Summary
reversing post-August 6, 1982 district court order which had suppressed results of breathalyzer test administered to defendant prior to August 6, 1982
Summary of this case from Farleigh v. Municipality of AnchorageOpinion
No. 7071.
August 30, 1982.
Appeal from the District Court, Fourth Judicial District, Fairbanks, Stephen R. Cline, J.
Michael S. McLaughlin, Asst. Dist. Atty., Harry L. Davis, Dist. Atty., Fairbanks, and Wilson L. Condon, Atty. Gen., Juneau, for petitioner.
Robert M. Beconovich, Lynch, Farney Crosby, Fairbanks, for respondent.
Before BRYNER, C.J., and COATS and SINGLETON, JJ.
OPINION
In this case the district court entered an order suppressing the results of a breathalyzer examination administered to the defendant. The breathalyzer test was given to the defendant prior to our decisions in Cooley v. Municipality of Anchorage, 649 P.2d 251 (Alaska App., 1982), and Municipality of Anchorage v. Serrano, 649 P.2d 256 (Alaska App., 1982). In suppressing the test results, the district court relied on these decisions, reasoning that they applied retroactively to cases in which suppression motions were pending at the time Cooley and Serrano were decided. The state petitioned for review. We granted the petition in order to clarify any possible ambiguity on the issue of retroactivity.
In Municipality of Anchorage v. Serrano, 649 P.2d 256, at 260-261 (citation omitted), we stated, in part, that our ruling would apply retroactively
to those cases which have been consolidated for consideration here and in Cooley v. Municipality of Anchorage; to those cases in which suppression of the breathalyzer test has already been ordered by the lower courts; and to cases which arise after the date of this decision.
The reference in Serrano to "cases which arise after the date of this decision" includes only those cases in which breathalyzer examinations were administered after August 6, 1982. Thus, Serrano applies to only three categories of cases: (1) cases formally joined with those decided in Serrano and Cooley; (2) cases in which suppression had already been ordered on or before August 6, 1982; and (3) cases in which breathalyzer tests were administered after August 6, 1982.
The suppression order entered by the district court is REVERSED.