From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

STATE v. HOGG

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jul 1, 1818
6 N.C. 319 (N.C. 1818)

Opinion

July Term, 1818.

From New Hanover.

A commissioner of navigation is not exempt from serving as a tales juror.

THE defendant was returned as a talesman, to serve on the jury during the day on which he was returned. He came into court and stated that he was a commissioner of navigation for the Port of Wilmington, and was exempt from serving on juries by the act of 1807, ch. 51, sec. 3, and prayed a discharge. The court held that he was not exempt from serving as a tales juror; and it was submitted to this court to decide whether he was exempt.


We look into the act of 1807, ch. 51, and sundry others of a similar nature; and the result is that we think the exemptions therein meant are from services as jurors of the original panel. Such exemptions are not intended as privileges or a compensation to the party, unless where it is expressly so stated, as in the act of 1794, ch. 4, in favor of patrols. The purpose of the Legislature is to forward and promote the public advantage, by leaving officers, physicians and others to exercise their employments without interruption. So far, therefore, as serving on a jury does not interfere with their public avocations, they are still liable to be called on for that service. But inasmuch as no one can be summoned as a (320) talesman except a bystander at the court, no inconvenience can result to the community from compelling a person to serve in that capacity; for the very fact of his being a bystander proves that he has not then any official or professional engagements which require his attention. If, however, such duties should occur, after he is summoned, it is in the power and has been the practice of the courts to excuse a juror upon a proper case.

Cited: S. v. Williams, 18 N.C. 374; S. v. Whitford, 34 N.C. 101; S. v. Willard, 79 N.C. 661; S. v. Cantwell, 142 N.C. 614.


Summaries of

STATE v. HOGG

Supreme Court of North Carolina
Jul 1, 1818
6 N.C. 319 (N.C. 1818)
Case details for

STATE v. HOGG

Case Details

Full title:STATE v. JOHN HOGG

Court:Supreme Court of North Carolina

Date published: Jul 1, 1818

Citations

6 N.C. 319 (N.C. 1818)

Citing Cases

Williams v. Funeral Home

As said in 35 C.J.S. 185: "As a general rule, in an action or proceeding to enforce or establish an exemption…

State v. Willard

There have been three decisions bearing upon the case in our State: The first was the S. v. Hogg, 6 N.C. 319.…