From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State, Helena Adjustment Company v. Dist. Ct. of Lewis

Supreme Court of Montana
May 7, 1932
92 Mont. 587 (Mont. 1932)

Opinion

No. 6,994.

Decided May 7, 1932.

Original application for alternative writ of prohibition directed to the district court of Lewis and Clark county to restrain it from proceeding further in the cause of Helena Adjustment Co., plaintiff, against William Traynor, defendant, pending in said court on appeal from a justice court, on the grounds that an insufficient notice of appeal had been served and filed, and that the undertaking on appeal filed was of no effect, in that it had been signed by two attorneys without an order of court permitting them to sign as sureties, as provided by section 8991, Revised Codes 1921. Application denied.

Mr. C.A. Spaulding, for Relator.


Decided May 7, 1932.


The application for an alternative writ of prohibition is denied. The notice of appeal, while not commended as a model, is not so defective as to fail to give the district court jurisdiction. It directed the attention of the adverse party to the fact that the judgment will be the subject of review in the appellate court. ( State ex rel. Rosenstein v. District Court, 41 Mont. 100, 21 Ann. Cas. 1307, 108 P. 580. And see In re Day, 18 Wn. 359, 51 P. 474.)

The weight of authority is that a statute providing that an attorney shall not become surety for his client is merely directory, and that the obligation, when once entered into, is not void, although the violation of the ruling statute may subject the attorney to punishment for contempt. In other words, the obligation is simply defective. (Note to State v. Babin, 18 Ann. Cas., p. 838; DeJarnett v. Marquez, 127 Cal. 558, 78 Am. St. Rep. 90, 60 P. 45.)

Statutes must be liberally construed to maintain the right of appeal. ( Morin v. Wells, 30 Mont. 76, 75 P. 688; Krause v. Insurance Co. of North America, 73 Mont. 169, 235 P. 406; State ex rel. Stevens v. Keaster, 82 Mont. 126, 266 P. 387.)


Summaries of

State, Helena Adjustment Company v. Dist. Ct. of Lewis

Supreme Court of Montana
May 7, 1932
92 Mont. 587 (Mont. 1932)
Case details for

State, Helena Adjustment Company v. Dist. Ct. of Lewis

Case Details

Full title:STATE EX REL. HELENA ADJUSTMENT CO., RELATOR, v. DISTRICT COURT OF LEWIS…

Court:Supreme Court of Montana

Date published: May 7, 1932

Citations

92 Mont. 587 (Mont. 1932)

Citing Cases

Weatherby v. Jackson

sec. 4; 59 C.J. 186, sec. 323; State v. McKay, 43 Mo. 594; State ex rel. Kelly v. Hackmann, 275 Mo. 636, 205…

Chicago Etc. R.R. Co. v. Fallon County

On the other hand the words "shall" and "must," which are mandatory in form, have been held to be permissive…