From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

State ex Rel. Sheble v. District Court

Supreme Court of Montana
Oct 22, 1932
15 P.2d 238 (Mont. 1932)

Opinion

No. 7,023.

Submitted September 19, 1932.

Decided October 22, 1932.

Certiorari — Adoption — Jurisdiction — Order Made Without Notice to Parent Void. 1. Held, on application for writ of certiorari by a father, the only surviving parent of a minor child, that an order of adoption made without notice of the contemplated adoption or showing that he waived notice or consented to the adoption was void.

Original application for writ of certiorari by the State, on the relation of James E. Sheble, against the District Court in and for the county of Glacier, and R.M. Hattersley, judge thereof. Order annulled.

Messrs. Molumby, Busha Greenan, for Relator, submitted a brief; Mr. Loy J. Molumby argued the cause orally.

No appearance on behalf of Respondents.


1. Necessity for notice to parents or legal custodian before adoption of child, see note in 76 A.L.R. 1077. See, also, 1 Cal. Jur. 429; 1 R.C.L. 607 (1 Perm. Supp., p. 167).


This is a proceeding in certiorari. The relator alleged that his minor child, Constance Bernadine Sheble, one year of age, without his consent and without notice to him, had been unlawfully adopted by Henry L. Magee and wife under an order made and entered by the district court of Glacier county, Montana, on June 22, 1932. The mother died upon the day following the child's birth.

The application being deemed sufficient to show prima facie [1] that the district court had proceeded without jurisdiction in the adoption proceedings, we issued the writ prayed for commanding the district court to certify to us the record of its proceedings in the matter, which was done. It does not appear therefrom that any notice of the application of Mr. and Mrs. Magee to adopt the child was given to the father, and there is not any showing that he waived notice; nor is there any showing that he consented to the adoption of the child. The application, consent, and agreement of Mr. and Mrs. Magee, and the order of adoption, were made on the same day.

Upon the authority of State ex rel. Thompson v. District Court, 75 Mont. 147, 242 P. 959, the order, being void as to the father, applicant here, is annulled.

ASSOCIATE JUSTICES ANGSTMAN and MATTHEWS, HONORABLE JEREMIAH J. LYNCH and HONORABLE JOHN HURLY, District Judges, sitting, respectively, in place of JUSTICES GALEN and FORD, disqualified, concur.


Summaries of

State ex Rel. Sheble v. District Court

Supreme Court of Montana
Oct 22, 1932
15 P.2d 238 (Mont. 1932)
Case details for

State ex Rel. Sheble v. District Court

Case Details

Full title:STATE EX REL. SHEBLE, RELATORS, v. DISTRICT COURT ET AL., RESPONDENTS

Court:Supreme Court of Montana

Date published: Oct 22, 1932

Citations

15 P.2d 238 (Mont. 1932)
15 P.2d 238

Citing Cases

Hammer v. Hammer

However, in all of these cases no notice was given to the parent not having such custody, and in some, as the…

Bascom v. Carpenter

The decided cases sustaining this rule are too numerous to be cited here. They will be found collected in a…